Leadership And Ethical Decision Making Scenario Essay

PAGES
4
WORDS
1318
Cite

Bill's Invitation

Joe has made considerable progress towards contract renewal between UWEAR and Peninsula Hotel chain and has planned a meeting with his management team to discuss the contract renewal. In light of the challenges relating to decline sales and profitability of UWEAR as well as the increased pressures to perform, Joe is optimistic that the contract renewal between these two firms will help in promoting continued success and employment with UWEAR. However, the contract negotiations have created a strained relationship between Joe and Bill lately because of the complexities involved in the negotiation process. Actually, the good relationship between Joe and Bill played an influential role in securing the contract renewal between the two companies despite the significantly cheaper offer from Threads4U. Bill has invited Joe and his wife for a short trip on the yacht, which will provide a good opportunity for both couples to catch up since they haven't been out together in a while.

While Joe is relieved to have received this invitation to help strengthen their relationship, it presents some ethical challenges/issues that Joe must consider. The invitation raises some considerations for Joe given the significance of ethical decision-making during this period of negotiations for contract renewal. Joe must consider the potential implications of accepting or declining the invitation with regards to its impact on their relationship and the contract renewal process. From an ethical perspective, the most important consideration for Joe in this situation is how his response to the invitation would affect UWEAR in light of the contract renewal process with Peninsula. Even though accepting the invitation would help strengthen the relationship between Joe and Bill, it could have significant negative impacts on UWEAR and Peninsula with regards to the contract renewal process. Therefore, Joe needs to consider the wellbeing of the company more than his relationship with Bill when making decisions about the invitation.

As shown in the consideration that Joe should make,...
...

The interests of these different stakeholders in the situation play a crucial role in determining the most suitable decision and course of action for Joe. The first two stakeholders in this situation are Joe and Bill who have established a great working relationship over the years. Joe and Bill are crucial stakeholders in this situation because their relationship has been crucial towards creation of business contracts between UWEAR and Peninsula. Actually, one of the considerations for Joe when determining whether to accept the invitation or not is the nature of their relationship with Bill. The other stakeholders are UWEAR and Peninsula whose business interests have played a crucial role in previous and current contracts or business deals between the two companies. In this regard, Joe's decision requires consideration of the business interests of UWEAR and Peninsula and its potential impact on the operations of these two companies.
The situation Joe is currently facing is a scenario with probable conflict of interest, which is basically a situation that could create conflicts between personal interests and the interests of a business organization or institution (Heathfield, 2017). Given the emerging conflict of interest in this situation, there are various potential outcomes. First, if Joe accepts Bill's invitation, there could be organizational consequences in relation to business ethics. Such a decision is likely to generate concerns that Joe influenced Bill to maintain the current higher price and award the contract to UWEAR or that Bill influenced Joe to lower the price of the offer. Secondly, if Joe declines Bill's invitation, it could significantly harm their good working relationship, which bas been strained lately because of contract negotiations.

Part II -- Joe's Decision



While the situation generates significant ethical concerns and issues, Joe must make a decision on whether or not to accept Bill's invitation. Given the issues highlighted and discussed in Part I of this paper,…

Cite this Document:

"Leadership And Ethical Decision Making Scenario" (2017, April 22) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/leadership-and-ethical-decision-making-scenario-essay-2168210

"Leadership And Ethical Decision Making Scenario" 22 April 2017. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/leadership-and-ethical-decision-making-scenario-essay-2168210>

"Leadership And Ethical Decision Making Scenario", 22 April 2017, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/leadership-and-ethical-decision-making-scenario-essay-2168210

Related Documents

UWEAR is undergoing a difficult period that has been characterized by declining sales and relatively low profit margins. This situation has generated considerable concerns and pressure of the firm's employees include Joe who is fearing cutbacks and layoffs because of the company's merger with PALEDENIM. However, Joe has established good relations with the CEO of Peninsula Hotels and signed a contract with them in the past financial year. Given the

Ethics are essential for organizational success. They influence the decisions made by the employees and managers on issues affecting the performance of the firm (Project Management Institute, n.d.). An organization that upholds ethical behaviors has a culture that fosters not only productivity but also excellence in service and product provision to its target markets. Managers are tasked with the role of ensuring that ethics are upheld in a firm. However,

Cultural Differences in Ethical Decision-Making Using Multidimensional Ethics Scale The objective of this study is to examine cultural differences in ethical decision-making using the multidimensional ethics scale. The Multidimensional Ethics Scale (MES) was developed originally by Reidenbach and Robin (1988, 1990) and is one of the most often used measures in business ethics research. (Lin and Ho, 2008, p.1213) The MES is an instrument found to be useful in business

The two scenarios are likely to sway employees to provide false information if they are encouraged. However, the relationship had much strength in the positive. Therefore, in this study, there were clear choices. The participants were required to either tell the truth or lie. If things were easy for individuals in the world, lines of making moral decisions tend to be much fuzzier, however, the bottom line remains the same

The dominant, goal-oriented person can focus on the ultimate objective, the influence-based person can examine the interpersonal dynamics of the decisions that must be made, the steady person can foster harmony and a positive atmosphere, and the conscientious person can stay on task in a reliable fashion. While clashing personalities can thwart reaching positive and goal-directed solutions, they can create a better solution and check the excesses of one

Decision Making Barnes and Noble Inc. is one of the most successful bookstores in the world. The company operates throughout the United States and boasts roomy inviting stores. In addition to books, the company also sells DVDs and music. The company operates both brick and mortar stores and it is also the largest internet bookstore. Furthermore, Barnes & Noble, Inc. is a Fortune 500 company and the largest bookseller in the