Justice and Eudaimonia in Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics
This paper examines Aristotle's treatment of justice, virtue, and happiness (eudaimonia) in the Nicomachean Ethics. It traces Aristotle's argument that justice is the highest moral virtue, requiring all other virtues, while distinguishing between natural justice — universal and unchanging — and legal justice, which varies by society. The paper also explores Aristotle's hierarchy of virtues, in which intellectual virtues surpass moral ones, and his conclusion that a life of philosophical contemplation yields the greatest eudaimonia. A life devoted to politics and justice is presented as the next best path, necessary for maintaining the conditions under which philosophical life can flourish.
- Introduction: Happiness and Virtue in the Nicomachean Ethics: Aristotle links eudaimonia to virtuous activity of the soul
- Justice as the Highest Moral Virtue: Justice unifies all other virtues in Aristotle's ethics
- Natural Justice and Legal Justice: Aristotle distinguishes universal natural justice from variable legal justice
- Justice, Politics, and the City-State: Politics directs all sciences toward the common human good
- Intellectual Virtues versus Moral Virtues: Intellectual virtues ranked above moral virtues including justice
- Conclusion: The Philosophical Life and the Role of Justice: Philosophical contemplation yields greater eudaimonia than political life
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It anchors every major claim in direct quotations from the Nicomachean Ethics, giving the analysis textual authority and preventing unsupported assertion.
- It moves logically from defining happiness and virtue, to categorizing justice, to distinguishing moral from intellectual virtues — building toward a coherent conclusion about the hierarchy of the good life.
- It maintains a clear through-line: every section returns to the central question of how justice relates to eudaimonia, keeping the argument focused despite covering several distinct Aristotelian concepts.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates sustained close reading of a primary philosophical text. Rather than paraphrasing Aristotle in general terms, the author integrates specific passages from identified books of the Nicomachean Ethics and interprets them in relation to the paper's central thesis. This technique — quoting, attributing, and then analyzing — is the foundation of philosophical essay writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by introducing eudaimonia and the role of virtue, then narrows to Aristotle's concept of justice (dikaiosune) in Book V. It distinguishes natural from legal justice, examines justice in relation to friendship and politics, and then broadens to the moral-versus-intellectual virtue hierarchy. The conclusion synthesizes these threads, restating Aristotle's ranking of the philosophical life above the political life while acknowledging the necessity of the latter.
Introduction: Happiness and Virtue in the Nicomachean Ethics
In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle's attempts to understand human nature ultimately lead him to an understanding of justice. He attempts to understand how humans can reach true happiness, delving deeply into the definitions of true happiness (eudaimonia) and virtue, and outlining how virtue and happiness are intertwined. The Nicomachean Ethics deals with metaphysics and focuses on ideas such as soul, happiness, virtue, and friendship. Aristotle concludes that happiness ultimately derives from activities of the soul that are in accordance with virtue. As he states, "happiness is an activity of soul in accordance with perfect virtue" (Book I).
Aristotle argues that the life that leads to the greatest happiness is a life of philosophical contemplation. However, he acknowledges that in order to achieve this life, some members of a city-state must live a life of politics, adhering to the principles of justice — the highest of the virtues. Ultimately, Aristotle argues that a life devoted to virtues is second only to a life devoted to philosophical reflection in achieving eudaimonia.
Justice as the Highest Moral Virtue
In Book V of the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle delves into a discussion of dikaiosune (justice). He notes that justice is extremely important in a society of free and equal people. He also makes a clear distinction between justice and ethics: justice consists of following the rules, while ethics involves doing the right and moral thing in cases where justice may lead to the wrong result.
To Aristotle, justice is the ultimate virtue, as it requires having all other virtues and serves to unify and order them. The other virtues he identifies include friendliness, temperance, truthfulness, wit, courage, generosity, magnanimity, magnificence, right ambition, and good temper. Aristotle states of justice: "all men mean by justice that kind of state of character which makes people disposed to do what is just and makes them act justly and wish for what is just; and similarly by injustice that state which makes them act unjustly and wish for what is unjust" (Book V).
Works Cited
Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics: Edited with a Commentary by G. Ramsauer. New York: Garland, 1987.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.