This paper analyzes D.C. Berry's poem "On Reading Poems to a Senior Class at South High," examining how Berry uses an extended aquatic metaphor to portray the complex relationship between a poetry teacher and his students. The analysis traces how imagery shifts from frozen, disinterested students to living, swimming participants in shared communication. It also considers Berry's use of symbolism, diction — including alliteration — and verse structure to reinforce his central themes of connection, isolation, and the inherent challenges of teaching poetry to reluctant high school students.
This paper demonstrates the technique of tracing a single literary device — the extended metaphor — through multiple analytical lenses. Rather than treating imagery, symbolism, and diction as isolated elements, the writer shows how each one reinforces and extends the poem's central aquatic conceit, producing a unified interpretive argument about teacher-student communication.
The paper opens with a thesis-driven introduction establishing Berry's tone and central metaphor. Each subsequent paragraph isolates one literary element: imagery and its transformation, symbolism, diction and alliteration, and verse structure. The conclusion synthesizes these elements around the poem's emotional core — the tension between loneliness and moments of genuine connection in the classroom.
D.C. Berry lyrically describes his experience of teaching in "On Reading Poems to a Senior Class at South High." Readers can easily relate to his straightforward extended metaphor and poignant imagery describing the classroom as a giant fish tank. Berry portrays his multifaceted feelings about teaching with this poem, acknowledging the communication problems that exist between teacher and students. The poet's words are sensitive and unbiased, directed neither toward the students nor the teacher. Instead, "On Reading Poems" addresses the fundamental problems with the teacher-student relationship, especially when the subject matter is poetry. Because of the inherent difficulties with teaching poetry, the narrator flounders in front of his class and does not feel safe until he is at home with his cat.
Imagery is the main vehicle through which D.C. Berry communicates his central message. The first stanza of the poem paves the way for the extended metaphor, as the students are immediately described as "sitting there as orderly as frozen fish in a package." Although Berry continues to use aquatic imagery throughout, this initial comparison of the students to "frozen" fish indicates that they seem disinterested. Required to attend class in order to graduate from high school, the students seem as enthused as frozen fish. However, this imagery transforms over the course of the poem as the students come alive. Thawing their initial frozen reaction to the teacher, the students and teacher must now attempt to swim in a sea of words.
Imagery easily becomes symbolism in a poem, and Berry has no difficulty capitalizing on the symbolic nature of fish and water. Remarkably, both teacher and students are not fish out of water; rather, they are in the water together. When the water fills the room, the teacher and students are both part of the same world. The water that fills the room symbolizes communication. The narrator notices the water only when it reaches his ears, in the second stanza. Thereafter, the "sounds of fish in an aquarium" remind the teacher of his fear of drowning the students "with words." Instead, the teacher notices, the students "opened up like gills for them and let me in." The open gills represent open minds that accept the viscous words as part of their education and maturation. Initially the teacher fears that they will all drown and are swimming aimlessly, but he ends up swimming together with his students, like "thirty tails whacking words."
Imagery, symbolism, diction, and structure aptly convey the poet's sentiments and sensations. The narrator of the poem fears he will flounder in front of his class. He imagines his students as frozen fish at first, but they come alive and "together...swam around the room." When the bell rings to end the session, the class collectively "leaked out" of the hole in the door created by the shift in focus. There is a sense of loneliness pervading "On Reading Poems" that is punctuated by touching moments of connection between teenagers and the English teacher. D.C. Berry's "On Reading Poems to a Senior Class at South High" is an accessible illustration of the experience of teaching — one that all readers can relate to.
You’re 77% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.