This paper presents a contrarian investment analysis of Finish Line, Inc. (ticker: FINL), a specialty athletic footwear retailer operating over 670 stores across 48 states. Written around mid-2006, the analysis evaluates FINL's valuation relative to industry peers, noting its low price-to-earnings ratio, substantial market capitalization, and earnings strength despite a recent downward price trend. The paper examines the impact of the company's lowered earnings estimate and a Bank of America price-target reduction, argues that the stock may be trading at a significant discount, and outlines conditions under which a long-term purchase could yield approximately 20% returns. Takeover potential is also identified as an additional upside catalyst.
Finish Line, Inc. is an interesting company that an investor could potentially do quite well with over the next year. It is currently trading close to its 52-week low, and according to the charts, its price appears to be nearing a bottom. The stock has recently been trading in the $10.92 to $12.00 range, with a 52-week high of just under $19.00. Its downward trend is primarily attributable to a lowering of earnings estimates by the company at a time when many of its competitors are raising theirs. For context on how 52-week highs and lows function as technical reference points, investors typically treat proximity to a 52-week low as a signal warranting closer fundamental scrutiny.
Taking a contrarian viewpoint, an investor focusing specifically on the numbers would notice several compelling figures. Finish Line, Inc. carries a market capitalization of over $528 million — slightly lower than three companies in the same industry that are trading at much higher prices. Its price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is under 11, which is significantly lower than that of almost every publicly traded company in the same industry. Furthermore, its earnings and annual income are higher than all but three companies considered direct peers.
The comparisons are stark. Unless Finish Line is going to fail entirely at its core mission, the stock appears to be trading at a substantial discount relative to its fundamentals. This type of value investing approach — identifying companies whose market price diverges meaningfully from intrinsic value — is precisely what a contrarian analysis is designed to uncover.
The depressed share price may be partly explained by the fact that the company recently lowered its earnings estimate, prompting analysts and investors to react — perhaps more severely than the underlying fundamentals warrant. Bank of America lowered its target price on the stock from $13 to $12 on August 16, 2006, which almost certainly weighed on the share price. While many other stocks in the same industry were on an upswing during the preceding 30-day period, Finish Line was trending lower.
Based on technical chart analysis, an investor should be able to purchase the stock at close to the $10 range, or possibly lower, in the very near future. If the stock reaches that level, or if it begins an upward trend in the near term, purchasing shares would likely be a sound decision.
A recommendation to purchase the stock as a long-term hold would likely reward patient investors, provided they are willing to hold for at least one to two years. The average rate of return over that period could approach 20%, based on historical performance and an assumption of flat sales and profits. Bank of America's stated target price of $12 supports this thesis: if an investor can acquire the stock near the $10 level, a 20% return on investment over the next 12 to 18 months is quite feasible.
Understanding the broader athletic footwear retail landscape is helpful context here. The sector is competitive, but Finish Line's cost structure and store footprint give it meaningful staying power even in a difficult revenue environment.
The primary risk in this stock is the possibility that management fails to rectify its revenue issues and sales continue to decline. That said, the company's profitability is relatively high — and substantially higher than it was just two years ago, when the stock was trading in the same price range. The charts indicate that the stock has reached a support level, and unless it breaks through that support and trends even lower, the current environment could represent a buying opportunity.
"Revenue risk offset by takeover potential"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.