This essay examines Socrates' account of inner and outer morality as presented in Plato's Republic, focusing on Chapter 6. It traces how Socrates identifies wisdom, courage, and self-discipline as the three essential elements of a well-functioning community, arguing that their harmonious interaction produces morality as a fourth element. The essay connects this communal analysis to Socrates' tripartite psychology, which divides the individual mind into three corresponding parts. Inner morality emerges when reason guides each part of the mind without dominating the others, while outer morality reflects the same harmony at the societal level. The paper concludes with a personal reflection on the relevance of these ideas to modern social life.
According to Socrates in Plato's Republic, morality is one of the four elements of goodness in a community. Inner morality is the rule of reason over other parts of the mind, whereby a person allows reason and rationality to govern. Throughout Chapter 6, morality is described in terms of harmony. Socrates argues that when there is harmony between all elements of a community, morality will emerge — this is outer morality. Inner morality, by contrast, is the harmony that exists between all parts of the mind.
It must be understood that the rule of reason over other parts of the mind does not suggest that the rational mind must dominate every other desire. It only means that reason must be recognized in all parts of the mind and then allowed to exist in harmony with the whole. This is closely connected with the tripartite psychology of Socrates.
In Plato's Republic, it is Socrates who argues with various important personalities of Greece and conducts a long dialogue with them. In Chapter 6, he is communicating with Adeimantus and trying to explain what constitutes inner and outer morality. These, he explains, are required for a community's goodness. When there is conflict between the essential elements of a community, anarchy and discord result, endangering the community as a whole.
Socrates argues for the existence of four essential elements in a society for it to function properly. In fact, there are three essential elements which, when they work in harmony, give birth to the fourth. These are described as wisdom, courage, and self-discipline. Socrates tells his interlocutors at the onset of the dialogue that when any three elements are found, whatever the fourth is must be morality. He states:
"Imagine any set of four things, and imagine we're exploring something for one of the four. Either we'd recognize it straight away and that would do the job, or we would recognize the one we're looking for by first recognizing the other three, in the sense that whatever is left is bound to be the one we're looking for." (p. 134)
To this everyone agrees, and the exploration begins.
From the discussion, they realize that wisdom must act as the guardian of a community. A person with knowledge is considered wise only when he can think about the entire community rather than merely a few limited things. Thus, a carpenter, while possessing knowledge, would not necessarily be considered wise, because his expertise is confined to making furniture. Wisdom therefore entails a broader application of knowledge. When Socrates inquires which citizens possess it, Adeimantus replies: "It is guardianship... and the people who have it are those rulers — the ones we not long ago called guardians in the strict sense of the word." (p. 135). Not all rulers would be wise, but in an ideal community, rulers must be people whose resourcefulness both comes from and leads to wisdom.
The second important element, courage, was found in the militia and law-enforcing agencies. Socrates explained that courage was a form of "retention" (p. 136): the person demonstrating courage is one who understands the law and fears it where it must be feared. "This ability to retain under all circumstances a true and lawful notion about what is and is not to be feared is what I'm calling courage." (p. 137). When one fears the things that must be feared, one is following the law; and the one who follows the law is also capable of implementing it. Thus, soldiers and law-enforcing agencies fall into this category of courage.
"Self-discipline and conflict-free community roles"
"Three-part mind mirrors community structure"
Inner and outer morality are thus linked with the tripartite philosophy. They cannot be fully understood without grasping the essence of tripartite thought. Socrates is correct in pointing out that harmony is the essential requirement of morality — it cannot exist where discord exists. However, what Socrates describes is an ideal state or community, and in modern times we seldom see clear evidence of that ideal anywhere in the world. This has led to serious conflict, and disharmony, immorality, and anarchy have become common.
You’re 54% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.