This paper examines the growing teacher shortage in Florida's public schools, situating it within the broader national crisis of high teacher turnover rather than enrollment growth alone. Drawing on data from the Florida State Board of Education, the National Commission on Teaching and America's Future, and independent research, the paper identifies specific subject-area shortages, certification gaps, and alarming attrition rates. It then critiques Governor Jeb Bush's Amendment 9 implementation proposals as insufficient and offers an alternative recruitment and retention plan centered on large-scale corporate co-sponsorships, celebrity-driven marketing campaigns, teacher salary enhancements, and incentive-based retention strategies.
The ongoing shortage of public school teachers across the nation has become an enormous, multi-dimensional dilemma crying out for solutions. While the problem is often associated exclusively with increased student enrollment — and that dynamic is certainly an issue — recent research indicates that teacher shortages "stem largely from high rates of pre-retirement teacher turnover" (Education Daily, 2004).
Surprisingly, according to research conducted by University of Pennsylvania sociologist Richard M. Ingersoll, the teachers who are leaving the profession are not, in the main, those retiring after many years of service. Of the 278,000 teachers who left teaching between the end of the 1999–2000 school year and the start of the 2000–2001 school year, only 24% (67,000) were retiring after long careers. Rather, the bulk of those leaving were younger, newer teachers who quit because of "poor salaries… too many intrusions on classroom teaching time, student discipline problems," and a lack of administrative support, among other reasons.
According to a survey by the National Commission on Teaching and America's Future (NCTAF), "half of new teachers — 46 percent — quit within five years, and 24 percent leave by the end of their second year" (What Works in Teaching and Learning, 2003). In the 1999–2000 school year, U.S. public schools hired 535,000 teachers; but just one year later, "about 252,000 teachers had moved to other schools, and 287,000 left teaching altogether." That "revolving door" syndrome is a very serious problem in Florida and elsewhere, particularly when compared with new enrollment growth issues. This paper proposes a positive program for the recruitment, retention, and maintenance of a solid, sustainable core of teachers in Florida, grounded in an analysis of the unhelpful dynamics currently at work.
Like many states, Florida is experiencing a teacher shortage so critical that it requires aggressive and creative ideas and methods to reach a satisfactory solution. According to a report issued by the Florida State Board of Education's Office of Evaluation and Reporting, the state is facing "critical teacher shortages" for the 2004–2005 school year, with further critical shortages projected for 2005–2006 in: middle and secondary mathematics and science, reading, technical education, industrial arts, physical sciences, English for speakers of other languages, and exceptional education programs. Critical shortages of school psychologists are also expected in 2004–2005.
Over the past five years, the report notes, "middle and high schools have seen sizable increases in enrollments," but the number of teachers graduating from Florida colleges and universities in math and science education "have not kept pace." Because the rate of Florida's population growth places an additional 50,000 or more students each year into already crowded classrooms, some 2,000 to 3,000 new teachers will be needed annually just to cover that expansion.
Add to those numbers the ongoing implementation of the class size amendment — pre-kindergarten through grade three, 18 students per class; grades four through eight, 22 students per class; and grades nine through twelve, 25 students per class — which places a tremendous amount of pressure on school districts to recruit even more teachers.
The situation has grown so serious that school districts have been hiring teachers who are not technically qualified for the classrooms they were assigned to — that is, teachers who were not certified in the subjects they are teaching. Of the new teachers hired in the fall of 2003, 11.5 percent "were not properly certified," according to the report. Breaking this down further: approximately 17% of teachers hired to teach reading lacked proper certification; 14% of science and math teachers hired were not certified in those fields; and 49.7% of teachers assigned to teach students with exceptional needs were not qualified to serve in that category.
School districts will soon face even further pressure from the "No Child Left Behind" guidelines set to be enforced in the 2005–2006 school year. The federal law requires "a highly qualified teacher in every core-subject classroom," meaning those 11.5% of improperly certified teachers from 2003–2004 will either need to obtain credentials or leave the classroom.
Exacerbating the problem further is Florida's teacher turnover rate: in the 2002–2003 school year, 13,751 teachers left the field — 62% through resignations, with the remainder leaving through retirements or "other reasons." Currently, one-fifth of teachers in Florida's public schools are 55 years of age or older, raising the question of how long those teachers can be expected to continue working.
Florida Governor Jeb Bush put forward a number of ideas for the implementation of Amendment 9 — intended to help schools meet the amendment's academic requirements — and offered many recommendations for action at the local school district level. Among Bush's recommendations (Governor Bush's Amendment 9 Implementation Plan, 2003): "Streamline teacher certification process to expedite certification of qualified individuals"; "Require all new schools to meet established cost guidelines"; "Use innovative methods to reduce the cost of school construction"; "Use joint-use facilities through partnerships" with colleges; "Redraw school attendance zones" to maximize use and minimize transportation costs; and "Operate schools beyond normal operating hours."
Additionally, Bush's program calls for spending $2.2 billion through the "Classrooms for Kids" bond program — taxpayer money distributed throughout the state — on new construction, school renovation, and teacher salaries. His proposal also calls for spending up to $630 million in public funds for infrastructure and other support for rural and urban schools. His ideas are positive, but they do not go far enough, and they rely too heavily on public funds.
"Corporate funding model and celebrity-driven recruitment campaign"
"Salary increases, teacher cooperatives, and benefit concerts"
Florida's teacher shortage demands bold, creative solutions that go beyond the limits of public funding alone. The data make clear that the crisis is driven not simply by enrollment growth but by a systemic failure to support, compensate, and retain the educators already in the profession. The proposals outlined in this paper — large-scale corporate co-sponsorships, celebrity-driven recruitment campaigns, salary enhancements, and innovative retention structures — represent a starting point for building a sustainable, well-supported teaching workforce capable of meeting Florida's educational needs both now and in the years ahead.
You’re 56% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.