Teaching Grammar in ESL/EFL: A Critical Review of Widodo
This paper critically examines Widodo's (2006) article "Approaches and Procedures for Teaching Grammar," which proposes a multi-strategy framework for teaching English grammar in ESL and EFL settings. The review explores the strengths of Widodo's approach, including his foundational argument for the importance of grammar in all facets of language development, his critique of traditional grammar-translation methods, and his detailed contrast of explicit versus implicit learning and inductive versus deductive teaching strategies. The paper also identifies structural and practical weaknesses, such as the late and disjointed presentation of the core five-step plan, insufficient guidance for handling struggling learners, and inconsistencies in step-by-step coverage across strategies. The review concludes that while the article offers valuable content, organizational shortcomings limit its direct classroom applicability.
- Introduction: Context for ESL/EFL grammar teaching challenges
- Overview of Widodo's Framework: Five-step method for teaching ESL grammar
- Strengths of the Article: Theoretical grounding and strategy differentiation praised
- Weaknesses and Structural Concerns: Disjointed structure and missing practical guidance
- Conclusion: Format limits an otherwise content-rich article
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper follows a clear critical review structure, moving from summary to strengths to weaknesses before offering a final evaluative judgment — a sound academic approach for a source critique.
- It uses direct quotations from the source text to ground its evaluative claims, lending credibility to both the praise and the criticism offered.
- The critique is balanced: the writer acknowledges genuine merit in Widodo's framework before systematically identifying specific structural and practical shortcomings, avoiding one-sided dismissal.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates source evaluation — the ability to read an academic article critically, identify the author's argumentative strategy, and assess both what works and what falls short. This is a foundational graduate skill in applied linguistics and education, requiring the writer to engage analytically rather than simply report what the source says.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief contextual introduction to ESL/EFL grammar instruction, then summarizes Widodo's five-part framework. It devotes roughly equal space to strengths (the theoretical grounding, critique of grammar-translation, and strategy differentiation) and weaknesses (disjointed organization, lack of remediation guidance, inconsistent step coverage). The conclusion synthesizes the evaluation, attributing the article's limitations to format rather than content. Total length is appropriate for an undergraduate critical review.
Introduction
English is one of the hardest languages to learn. It has a number of complex grammatical structures and conventions that are often not aligned with other languages, making it difficult for learners to grasp English grammar while studying it as a second or foreign language in ESL or EFL classes. Traditional methods for teaching grammar are often inadequate in ESL and EFL courses. Thus, Widodo (2006) provides a series of alternative strategies with clearly outlined steps to help better introduce complex conventions of English grammar to those learning English as a second language.
Overview of Widodo's Framework
Widodo (2006) developed a five-point method for teaching English grammar within the context of his work, "Approaches and Procedures for Teaching Grammar." It is geared specifically towards teaching English as a second language in EFL and ESL courses. These students already have an advanced understanding of grammatical conventions in another language and are learning English as their second language. Widodo (2006) understands how important grammar conventions are in order to increase the degree of fluency students can achieve, and he developed a strategy that aims to use their advanced thinking skills to help them digest new grammatical materials and rules.
This five-point method contains a number of steps meant to introduce students to grammatical conventions, provide opportunities for practicing the skills they are learning, and support more comprehensive thinking that allows students to extend their knowledge of certain conventions beyond what they have been immediately taught. The steps include practice, conscious-raising, explicit and implicit knowledge, and deductive and inductive strategies for teaching grammar. Practice entails providing room for students to practice and then be evaluated on their performance, whereas conscious-raising activities are meant to make students aware of the context of certain grammatical rules.
References
Widodo, H. (2006). Approaches and procedures for teaching grammar. English Teaching: Practice and Critique, 5(1), 122–141.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.