Law and Justice Across the Ages of Term Paper

Download this Term Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Term Paper:

Law and justice across the ages of artistic representation -- a fair system of justice means nothing when ice water, corruption, and evil run through the hearts of those appointed to enforce the system

The 1980's crime novel Gorky Park, Shakespeare's 'problem' play "Measure for Measure," Marx and Engels political manifesto "The Communist Manifesto," and the World War II Warner Brothers motion picture "Casablanca" all fundamentally ask, at their respective narrative and philosophical hearts the fundamental human question: what is justice? All grapple with the issue of how best to create a truly rather than a superficially just society. Do just men and women, or a just system of laws, produce fair and equitable societies? What is more important, a fair code of laws, or good people attempting to do what is right within any particular moral context? Despite having been produced during different times and for different purposes, these four works form a textual unit that may be analyzed as argument by the critically inquisitive reader. Taken as a whole, this package of textual materials argues that the formulaic construction of law and government are meaningless and the acts of good human beings alone can construct a truly just society.

In Gorky Park, Arkady Renko, a police inspector, faces the vexing dilemma of how to solve triple murder in a Moscow park. Although the book was written during one of the coldest periods of the Cold War, the reader is encouraged to feel tremendously sympathetic to this Russian chief homicide investigator and even identify with the Russian's struggles. Although the investigator is trapped in a difficult and unjust system, the central character is still full of a passion for common, human justice that transcends any of the inequities of the communist system. The book begins after three corpses are found frozen in the snow, faces and fingers missing. The KGB presents the investigator with seemingly innumerable obstacles to solve the crimes. Yet not simply the injustices of the Soviet legal system threaten the efforts of Arkady Renko. The FBI and the New York police as well attempt to circumvent his quest for justice as well as his life and livelihood. It is not the evils of the communist system that are most at fault for Renko's difficulties, for such a system can produce good people such as Renko as well as evil people in the KGB. Rather it is the corruption within any system, democratic or communist, that is run by bad individuals. It does not fundamentally matter if the system were negative and oppressive like communism or positive and democratic like the United States system of justice. Even Renko himself is nearly undone by his own personal foibles, most notably love, after, at the end of Chapter 11. Renko watches the girl he once loved, whom has entangled herself in his investigation, putting a cigarette out against the bark of a birch tree," as if the warm stab were being pressed into his heart. He [had] believed her. The truth had gone from her into the tree and into him." The immoral nature of an unfortunate love affair nearly proves Renko's undoing, not any systemic evils of communism or democracy -- a character rather than a systemic, structural flaw in the justice system is what nearly unravels his entire investigation. In Chapter 2, "naked," the woman he loves is shown "peeling an orange," but utterly closed, in truth, in her heart to the investigator who loves her -- she is never unpeeled until the end, much like the mystery that unravels through Renko's personal dedication rather than through any systemic construction of justice in America or in Russia.

Shakespeare's "Measure for Measure" also starkly illustrates the principle that good people matter more than good laws. At the beginning of the play, the weak but kindly Duke temporarily cedes power to the Puritanical, morally fanatic Angelo. "I have deliver'd to Lord Angelo, / A man of stricture and firm abstinence, / My absolute power and place here in Vienna," (1.3) The system structurally has not changed from the passage of authority from one man to the other. But Angelo, because of his narrow-minded character finds archaic aspects of law to prosecute those…[continue]

Cite This Term Paper:

"Law And Justice Across The Ages Of" (2004, May 20) Retrieved October 21, 2016, from

"Law And Justice Across The Ages Of" 20 May 2004. Web.21 October. 2016. <>

"Law And Justice Across The Ages Of", 20 May 2004, Accessed.21 October. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Law Enforcement and Age Discrimination

    Many of these have been challenged throughout the years. In fact, here have been a number of cases challenging age discrimination within this more complicated situation. In the case, EEOC v. City of Janesville an individual fought the fifty-five-year cut off age for police officers in that county (Vance 1986). Opponents of the age cut off argued that age discrimination was acceptable only in "particular business," meaning for police officers

  • Justice Crime and Ethics

    Justice, Crime and Ethics Prepping the President: Ethical Analysis and Future Policy Initiatives Suggesting the Use of Rehabilitation in Corrections The President of the United States has just scheduled a town hall meeting entitled, "Criminal Justice Ethics: Today's News and Tomorrow's Solutions." Many of the country's most interested individuals in the field of criminal justice's present ethical issues are attending the meeting and expect to be informed on the status of some of

  • Age Discrimination the Face of

    " (DiCesera, 2002) WHAT SHOULD BE DONE by FIRMS Now that we understand what discrimination is and what are some of its various prevalent faces and forms, we need to understand what an organization can do to minimize discriminatory practices. Secondly we also need to determine the role played by HRM in discrimination. Diversity of workforce is one of the unique features of American corporate world. In addition, human resource managers are

  • Age of Reason Age

    You can't just issue degrees without having the use of force lurking in the background to make sure those degrees have some "teeth" so to speak. But Rousseau rejected that idea. Rousseau also rejected the notion that ties between family members were an appropriate model for relationships between the state and its citizens. In using precepts from what Aristotle had written two thousand years earlier (in Aristotle's Politics), Rousseau -

  • Counterterror and Organized Crime as Competing Goals for Law Enforcement...

    Organized Crime / Counterterrorism AL CAPONE OR AL QAEDA?: ORGANIZED CRIME AND COUNTERTERRORISM AS LAW ENFORCEMENT PRIORITIES IN 2014 Should law enforcement in America prioritize fighting counter-terrorism or fighting organized crime? A full examination of the history and issues involved with both will, I would argue, make the answer clear: with the proper definitions involved of both terror and organized crime, it is the latter which genuinely deserves the attention of law enforcement, and

  • Juvenile Justice Juvenile Delinquency Is the Misdemeanors

    Juvenile Justice Juvenile delinquency is the misdemeanors or the breach of law that is committed by an American or a person living in America but still under the age of 18 years old. This is the common age limit that exists across most states except in Wyoming where the age is 19 years or younger (Whitehead & Lab, 1999). It is worth noting that by 2006, there were 92,854 juvenile delinquents

  • Women Representation in Law Enforcement

    In this regard, Lott points out, "Between 70% and 80% of police departments explicitly use norming of physical standards in their hiring practices. However, most of the departments that use objective standards do not enforce these rules. Women who fail to meet the absolute standards during academy training are unlikely to be failed out of the program" (p. 276). This lack of consistency in how these standards are applied

Read Full Term Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved