Role of Vision at Mentor essay

Download this essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from essay:

N.D.). Vision for any organization is linked to change be it planned or unplanned; however, depending on the leadership of management, the vision and change can be either proactive or reactive. For Langeler the constant changes in vision statements represented the inability to act a director of change and instead focused on the caretaker image of change directives. The fundamental difference is the proactivity of the director vs. The reactivity of the caretaker model.

Question V

The vicissitude nature of Mentor's vision statements changes highlights the question of whether change can be managed via models such as the director or navigator or whether inexorable forces shape decisions and change. Clearly Langeler was not able to utilize the director image in which change is influenced by the management team, directive, initiatives, and outcomes are clearly spelled out, and a process of steps for change is laid out. There is a plethora of change models: 7-S, Kotter's eight step, and Burke-Litwin (Burke, W. 2008) however, the underlying principle is that change can be controlled and managed; understanding that "vision is something that is essential to producing successful organizational change; and it should be articulated early on, and it us up to leaders to do this" (Palmer, I. 2008). Mentor's vision statements flow from change which occurs around them and is not capable of being controlled. This is a marked departure from the director model in which vision produces a change dynamic. Vision can certainly help and even define potential organizational change; this is true even with Mentor and the "Beat Daisy" statement. Despite its relevance as more of a rallying slogan the effect was to focus employee and company energies on a specific goal, and as such can be viewed as in part helping to define change for the company. As a proponent of the director image of change there is a favorable bias toward heroic leaders who either through charismatic, transformational, or servant leadership are able to "inspire followers to commit to a shared vision and goals…challenging them to be innovative problem solvers…and achieve extraordinary outcomes" (Hickman, G. 2010).

Question Six

The Mentor case study explicates the differences between intended and unintended change and how leaders are able to construct mission and vision statements in that context. Langeler as posited earlier was the definitive caretaker in regards to change. The concatenation of Porter's Five Forces on Mentor defined how the company would proceed and how it would operate. Succinctly, change beset restructuring of the vision statements over time, absent was any planned change and the incorporation of an overriding vision to push the directive forward. The director model exemplifies the leader as able to confront the changing dynamics of competition, economies, and innovation. Change then flows from a leader's vision for the future direction of the company and how employees can be inspired and motivated to implement change and cement positive outcomes within the organization. The director image for a leader incorporates the "optimistic view that intentional change can be achieved" (Palmer, I. 2008).

Mentor Graphics is an excellent example of an organization that confuses mission and vision statements and compounds the problem with disconnecting core competencies of their business model from their long-term outlook for the company. This problem though is not a unique one as many companies often encounter difficulty in identifying the purposes of why they are in business and the future the company will ultimately achieve. Mentor throughout the case study attached a new vision to the current realities of the moment, and as such the result was an unfocused organization that moved from directive to directive without any clear purpose or vision for the future.


Burke, W. Organization Change: Theory and Practice. 2008. Sage Publications

2nd Edition.

Case Study. (N.D.). Role of Vision at Mentor Graphics

Hickman, G. Leading Organizations. Perspectives for a New Era. 2010. Sage

Publications. 2nd Edition

McNamara, C. Basics for Developing Mission, Vision, and Values Statements.

Free Management Library. (2008) Retrieved January 3, 2011 from.

Palmer, I. Dunford, R. & Akin, G. Managing Organizational Change. 2008.

McGraw-Hill 2nd Edition.

QuickMBA. (N.D.). Porter's Five Forces: A Model for Industry Analysis. Retrieved January 3, 2011 from[continue]

Some Sources Used in Document:


Cite This Essay:

"Role Of Vision At Mentor" (2011, January 03) Retrieved November 28, 2016, from

"Role Of Vision At Mentor" 03 January 2011. Web.28 November. 2016. <>

"Role Of Vision At Mentor", 03 January 2011, Accessed.28 November. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Role of Vision at Mentor

    In other words, the company's vision was not developed based on the right reasons. This means that the entire strategy that Mentor Graphics developed was not a suitable one for the company and the situations in case. The company failed to adapt in due time to the changes produced by the environment partly because the vision was not a suitable one. 5. In the case of a company like Mentor Graphics

  • Vision Statement Discuss the Way Vision Was

    Vision Statement Discuss the way vision was used at Mentor Graphics. At Mentor Graphics Corporation, the created vision had several components, which might be regarded as questionable in terms of effectiveness. First, the vision was "unarticulated," meaning that, at best, the vision was not even a statement as such. Instead, it is likely that most employees and managers were not as such aware of the vision statement, but rather had little more

  • Role of Leadership in Change Management Role

    Role of Leadership in Change Management Role of Leadership in Delivering Change-2 Other factors necessary in delivering Change-5 Arguments for and Against Change Management-6 Perspective towards Change Applications in an Organization-10 Any Topic on Organizational Development The paper will tackle any topic from Organizational Development. The topic in this case that I choose to look at is Leadership Development but I will be narrowing it down to look at 'The Role of leadership in Change Management.

  • Mentor s Responsibility the Purpose of

    Some additional common characteristics of and criteria for selecting mentor teachers are: a clearly articulated vision of teaching and learning, knowledge of content, accomplished curriculum developer, professional interests, expressed educational philosophies, and compatible personalities (1986; Feiman-Nemser, 1996; Tillman, 2000). Awareness and facility with mentoring processes are seldom among selection criteria, but are often handled through mentor training mechanisms." Mullinix, 2002) Orientation is based on the five phrases of Ellen

  • Role of Leadership in Police Management Police

    Role of Leadership in Police Management Police organizations have historically emphasized the use of authoritarian types of administration and Machiavellian leadership practices. Even today, many police organizations have behavioral orientations reflective of dominance, individual achievement and masculinity. However, recent challenges such as developing community-oriented policing and transforming a traditional police culture that typically emphasized operational "efficiencies," to one that promotes team collaboration, innovation, and "effective" processes suggest the need for new leadership

  • Vision and Mission Statement Development

    Ultimately the best mission statements succinctly define what makes an organization unique and relevant, gaining support in the process (Kouzes, Posner, 2003, pp. 135-155). The vision and mission statements for the Principles of Leadership class are as follows: Vision Statement: By creating a learning environment that promotes critical thinking and independent thought, the Principles of Leadership course creates creative, independent-minded and discerning critical thinkers who can apply the concepts learned to

  • Role of Leadership in Strategic Choice

    Leadership The Role of Leadership in Developing and Implementing Strategy The role of a leader is important in the determination and implementation of strategy within an organization. The potential impact of a leadership maybe seen with many examples; one is the return of Steven Jobs to the role as CEO of Apple when the firm was struggling. Jobs returned to this role in Apple in 1997 when the firm was struggling. It

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved