Problems With Random Assignment Experiments On Principals Essay

PAGES
2
WORDS
637
Cite

In “An Examination of the Benefits, Limitations, and Challenges of Conducting Randomized Experiments with Principals,” the researchers use a case study method to show why a professional development program for principals failed to achieve its desired outcomes. Focusing on one school district with 48 principals, the authors state, “We developed and understanding of why the program failed to achieve its intended goals,” (p. 188). The District Professional Development (DPD) program was designed to improve leadership capacities among principals with the ultimate goal of improving school outcomes. Based on interviews with district officials, a systematic review of the DPD materials, observations of the actual DPD training sessions, attendance records, and the principals’ personal logs and journals, the researchers collected substantive qualitative evidence that can be used to supplement their quantitative experimental research on the DPD. In other words, this study is a classic mixed-methods research design that uses both qualitative and quantitative methods judiciously. The qualitative methods are needed to illustrate why the program did not work, which is not something the data from the quantitative study could ever reveal. As it turned out the reason why the program failed to achieve its intended goals...

...

The researchers outline several main challenges to implementing a professional development program as ambitious as the DPD. One challenge was the effects of changes to educational policy on the professional identity and roles of principals during the delivery of the DPD. Another was the fact that true random assignment was not even possible, due to what they call “subversion,” or not showing up when they said they would or showing up to the DPD training even when not registered (p. 201). The third challenge was reduced program delivery, and the decline in attendance over the duration of the course. Although there were some notable outcomes in the DPD experimental group, such as increased time spent on planning and goal setting, the authors nevertheless brand the intervention a failure due to low attendance and poor compliance.
The qualitative aspects of the case study help the researchers to unearth the core assumptions that guided the experimental intervention in the first place. Theoretical orientation, worldview, values, and other guiding principles may need to be changed in order to design more effective professional development programs. Due to the complex array of variables involved in leadership,…

Cite this Document:

"Problems With Random Assignment Experiments On Principals" (2018, August 02) Retrieved April 16, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/problems-with-random-assignment-experiments-on-principals-essay-2172653

"Problems With Random Assignment Experiments On Principals" 02 August 2018. Web.16 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/problems-with-random-assignment-experiments-on-principals-essay-2172653>

"Problems With Random Assignment Experiments On Principals", 02 August 2018, Accessed.16 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/problems-with-random-assignment-experiments-on-principals-essay-2172653

Related Documents

Leadership Styles Among Male and Female Principal It is the intention of this research to study the leadership and cognitive styles of teachers and instructors of both genders within the educational system and their preference for types of leadership in a principal of that institution. The research will include teachers and educators from all levels of the educational system from grade school to high school. The study will also include teachers and

Size/Cooperative Learning & it's effects on participation Action Research Question Will cooperative learning have a significantly positive impact on smaller or larger classes? The purpose of this study was to investigate if cooperative learning will have a significantly positive impact on smaller or larger classes. In order to have valid results, I used both my largest and smallest classes as my sampling. I also incorporated a variety of teaching styles with cooperative

Reforming Urban Schools
PAGES 49 WORDS 13440

School Choice Program This study aimed to determine the impact of school choice through a comparative study of two private schools, which serve primarily, or exclusively African-American students, and a public school. Data in student achievement in math and reading and data on student attendance were used to determine the impact of choosing a school. Qualitative data derived from interviews with administrators and faculty as well as classroom observation were used to

Middle School and School
PAGES 20 WORDS 6761

Expectations of Advisory Program Validity threats Foundation supporting this study design Explain How Statement Meets the Criteria Greenlee, B. J. (2010). School advisory council demography: Birds of a feather. Planning and changing, 41(1/2), 3-17 Adolescence is believed to be a stage in which people form their identity as well as develop the skills required for one to be academically successful. Benson &Poliner (2013) state that the failure of schools in involving most students due

The exam though it's validity as a barometer for academic preparedness for higher learning is contested, is a means of examining the factors which have been shown to be directly related to the outcomes seen with this strategy. Block scheduling has been shown to correlate directly to mathematics, language, and critical thinking in terms of improving scores. Also, the application of this evaluative comparison across a variety of students

However, as criminals become more aware of undercover tactics, the covert officer is required to provide more and more proof that he is indeed a criminal- which leads to the officer committing acts that compromise his or her integrity for the sake of maintaining cover. By understanding the often conflicting nature of these goals, deception and integrity, we can see how an undercover officer can become confused, lost, and