The 13th Warrior (1999): Film Review and Analysis
This paper offers a critical review of director John McTiernan's 1999 historical action film The 13th Warrior, starring Antonio Banderas as Arab ambassador Ahmed Ibn Fadlan among a band of Norse warriors. The review evaluates the film's key strengths — including Peter Menzies Jr.'s atmospheric cinematography, its moody and suspenseful tone, graphically realistic fight scenes, and a strong supporting cast — while also acknowledging weaknesses such as choppy editing, slow pacing, and extreme violence. The paper concludes that, despite its imperfections, the film succeeds as an entertaining and visually compelling medieval adventure.
- Introduction: Thesis overview of film's key strengths
- Plot and Storyline: Linear plot suits the film's action focus
- Atmosphere and Tone: Creepy Wendol creatures establish dark mood
- Cinematography and Musical Score: Menzies and Goldsmith create visual spectacle
- Fight Scenes and Action: Gritty, graphic battles captivate viewers
- Supporting Cast: Character actors outshine lead Banderas
- Weaknesses and Overall Assessment: Flaws noted but strengths ultimately prevail
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The review is well-organized, dedicating a focused paragraph to each evaluative criterion — plot, tone, cinematography, fight scenes, and cast — making the argument easy to follow.
- The writer balances praise with honest criticism, acknowledging choppy editing, slow pacing, and graphic violence before concluding that the film's strengths outweigh its flaws.
- Specific details, such as naming cinematographer Peter Menzies Jr., composer Jerry Goldsmith, and individual supporting actors, lend credibility and depth to the evaluation.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates evaluative writing structured around explicit criteria. Rather than simply summarizing the film's plot, the writer identifies distinct categories of cinematic merit — cinematography, atmosphere, action choreography, and ensemble performance — and assesses each on its own terms before synthesizing a holistic judgment. This criterion-based evaluation is a foundational technique in arts and media criticism.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a thesis-driven introduction that previews the criteria of evaluation. Each body paragraph then addresses one cinematic element in turn. A dedicated weaknesses paragraph provides balance before a brief conclusion restates the overall verdict. The Works Cited entry follows MLA format, citing the film as the primary source.
Introduction
Director John McTiernan's 1999 film The 13th Warrior is a competent movie made entertaining by its tight storyline, moody tone, masterful cinematography, realistic and often graphic fight scenes, and the strength of its supporting cast. A great deal of the film's success comes from the cinematography of Peter Menzies Jr., who creates an almost supernatural mood through his shooting of well-choreographed battle scenes in a dark, silent mist. Overall, the movie could never be described as Oscar-worthy material, yet its many strengths make it a watchable and enjoyable film.
Plot and Storyline
The movie's main storyline is tightly plotted and concise. This is not a film with a preponderance of plot twists and turns; the storyline is largely self-evident and linear. There are a couple of exceptions — such as a brief love interest between Banderas' character and a Norse princess — but they are short and do not distract from the main plot. As a result of this linearity, it is easy to follow the action and events in The 13th Warrior.
While some critics take the view that plot intricacies and subplots make a movie more worthwhile viewing, this is not the case here. The film is clearly a simplistic tale of the adventures of an Arab poet in the land of the Norse. In The 13th Warrior, the simplicity of the plot is perfectly suited for a straightforward medieval action movie that focuses closely on atmosphere and swordsmanship. The end result is a strangely effective amalgamation of a swashbuckling adventure with deeply moody and almost supernatural undertones.
Atmosphere and Tone
Another of the movie's main attractions is its atmospheric, moody tone. The Vikings' foes are the disturbingly creepy Wendol — a creature that is half-man and half-bear. We are introduced to the Wendol as "mist-monsters" and flesh eaters who appear only in the mist and carry off soldiers. Battle scenes occur in the dark and mist, and blood is spilled copiously and with great graphic detail, creating a deeply disturbing atmosphere of terror and evil that permeates the movie.
A great deal of the film is shot in near darkness, and the battle scenes are carried out in an atmosphere evocative of a suspenseful horror movie. Overall, the effect is spooky and engaging.
Cinematography and Musical Score
The cinematography of Peter Menzies Jr. is one of the best features of the film. The movie is lavish and spectacular in its visual presentation, and much of its enjoyment comes simply from appreciating that presentation. The cinematography is essential in creating the gloomy, dark atmosphere of the film, and Menzies is highly capable in his filming of the dark, gory battle scenes. Above and beyond the action, however, is the visual spectacle of the film itself. Menzies masterfully captures stunning scenery — dark and beautiful forests, brooding seascapes, and towering, profound mountains. As the thirteen warriors travel across the ocean, Menzies captures their foreboding and anticipation in the choppy, crashing waves of their ocean crossing.
The musical score by Jerry Goldsmith adds a fine touch to the cinematography, with his orchestral and classical arrangements deepening the suspenseful and dark mood of the film.
Works Cited
The 13th Warrior. Dir. John McTiernan. Perf. Antonio Banderas, Diane Venora, Omar Sharif, Vladimir Kulich, Dennis Storhoi, Maria Bonnevie, Mischa Hausserman, Sven Wollter, John DeSantis, Asbjorn Riis. Touchstone Pictures, 1999.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.