Authentic Manhood in Wright's and Updike's Short Fiction
This essay compares Richard Wright's "The Man Who Was Almost a Man" and John Updike's "A&P" to examine how each story portrays adolescent boys who misunderstand what authentic manhood requires. Through close readings of tone, imagery, and language, the essay argues that Dave and Sammy pursue misguided symbols of maturity — a gun and the approval of girls, respectively — and that their impulsive actions ultimately set them further back on the path to adulthood. By the end of each story, neither boy achieves his goal, though both gain a modest degree of self-awareness about how much they still have to learn.
- Introduction: Misguided Paths to Manhood: Thesis introduces Dave, Sammy, and misguided manhood
- Tone and Irony in Each Story: Ironic tone exposes each boy's childishness
- Imagery and the Limits of Each Boy's World: Imagery reveals boys' unreadiness for adulthood
- Language as a Window into Immaturity: Dialect and diction show each boy's immaturity
- Conclusion: Manhood as a Fleeting Dream: Both boys grow slightly despite foolish actions
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay establishes a clear, parallel thesis — Dave and Sammy pursue different but equally misguided symbols of manhood — and sustains that comparison across every body paragraph.
- Each analytical section addresses both stories in turn, giving the comparison a balanced, organized structure that is easy to follow.
- Direct quotations from primary texts are integrated smoothly and used as evidence, not decoration, with brief explanatory commentary following each citation.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates sustained parallel analysis: rather than treating each story separately, it consistently pairs the two texts within a single interpretive framework. Each literary device — tone, imagery, language — becomes a shared lens through which both protagonists are evaluated simultaneously, reinforcing the comparative thesis throughout.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thesis paragraph that introduces both stories and the central argument. Three body paragraphs follow, each organized around a single literary element (tone, imagery, language) applied to both texts. A transitional paragraph synthesizes the boys' shared misconceptions before a brief conclusion acknowledges their limited but real growth. Works Cited entries close the paper in MLA format.
Introduction: Misguided Paths to Manhood
Authentic manhood is something that cannot be bought or achieved through a string of mindless actions. Two stories that emphasize this concept are Richard Wright's The Man Who Was Almost a Man and John Updike's A&P. Through tone, imagery, and language, each author demonstrates how his protagonist cannot yet be a man because he still has so many lessons to learn. Dave and Sammy are both under the impression that manhood can be reached through a series of rather senseless actions. For Dave, that action is possessing a gun; for Sammy, it is receiving the approval of girls. At the end of each story, neither boy achieves his goal — instead, each only sets himself back in his journey toward manhood, because there are consequences for every action.
Works Cited
Updike, John. "A&P." The Norton Anthology of Short Fiction. New York: W.W. Norton and Company, 1981. pp. 1416–21.
Wright, Richard. "The Man Who Was Almost a Man." The Norton Anthology of Short Fiction. New York: W.W. Norton and Company, 1981. pp. 1470–80.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.