Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 2,042 words

Should Canada Become a Republic? The Case for Change

~11 min read 7 sections Politics · Comparative Politics
Abstract

This paper argues that Canada should abandon its constitutional monarchy and become a republic, contending that such a transition is both politically feasible and culturally necessary. Drawing on Canadian political history, the paper examines how Canada has incrementally distanced itself from British rule since before Confederation, tracing key milestones such as the 1946 Citizenship Act and the 1982 patriation of the constitution. The paper considers how republicanism could ease Quebec separatist tensions, better reflect Canada's diverse population, and clarify the nation's identity independent of Britain. It also surveys several possible republican governance models and addresses the misconception that becoming a republic would require Canada to leave the Commonwealth.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Canada's Monarchical Question: Framing the republic vs. monarchy debate in Canada
  • Historical Path Toward Independence: Canada's incremental legislative independence from Britain
  • The Case Against the Monarchy: Arguments that monarchy is outdated and symbolic
  • Government Structure Under a Republic: How Governor-General role could evolve under republicanism
  • Quebec Separatism and Republican Identity: Republicanism as solution to Quebec sovereignty tensions
  • Models for a Canadian Republic: Comparative republican governance models for Canada
  • Conclusion: Cutting Ties with the Crown: Identity, decolonization, and Canada's republican future
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper builds its argument incrementally, moving from historical context to practical governance proposals, which gives the position-based thesis a logical, layered foundation.
  • It anticipates and directly refutes counterarguments — particularly the "tradition" defense of monarchy — strengthening its overall persuasive force.
  • The use of multiple academic and primary sources (Trudeau, Mackey, Cannadine) lends scholarly credibility to what could otherwise read as purely opinion-driven advocacy.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates effective use of comparative evidence: it references Ireland, South Africa, Germany, and Australia as case studies to support the feasibility of Canada's republican transition. Rather than treating the Canadian question in isolation, the author situates it within a broader post-colonial context, lending weight to the argument that republicanism is a natural and well-precedented evolution.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a framing of the central debate, then provides historical background on Canadian independence. It moves into normative arguments against the monarchy before addressing practical governance questions — specifically how the Governor-General's role could evolve. It then links republicanism to Quebec separatism, surveys concrete republican models, and closes with a call to action framed around national identity and decolonization.

Essay 2,042 words

Introduction: Canada's Monarchical Question

Canada is a nation comprised of ten provinces and three territories. Those provinces and territories span five regions: the Atlantic (Maritime region), Central Canada, the Prairies, the West Coast, and the North (DeRocco 2009, 61). Every province in Canada works with the federal government to ensure the country progresses effectively; however, each province has its own government as well. One question plagues Canadian society and politics: Should Canada become a republic, or should it retain its constitutional monarchy?

While there are many arguments for keeping the status quo, there are just as many that can debunk pro-monarchy assertions. For example, most developed nations have moved past the archaic concepts of nobles and inherited rights in government and society (CCCR 2010). Moreover, alongside Canada's economic and cultural development, how Canada defines itself — and how its people define themselves — is a significant part of national life. Creating a republic is necessary for Canada: it will change the way other nations view the country, sever ancient and passé symbolic ties, and help calm the crisis between English and French solitudes.

Historical Path Toward Independence

The first element to consider is that republicanism is not new to Canada. Historically, Canada led the former British colonies in legislating independence and democratic reform, incrementally keeping itself on the road to a republic since before Confederation. Therefore, many believe that Canada should do away with the final vestiges of British colonialism, eliminate the monarchy, and become a republic. Others think Canada should remain part of the British Commonwealth, and groups such as the Monarchist League of Canada exist to support that loyalty to England.

However, keeping Canada as a Commonwealth country is passé, and making Canada a republic could resolve the problem of Quebec separatism. Trudeau (1958, 300) asserts that "democracy will be thwarted in Canada so long as one-third of the people hardly believe in it — and that because to no small extent the remaining two-thirds provide them with ample grounds for distrusting it." The British monarchy is simply outdated in the Canadian context, and it makes little sense for the nation, since Canada is already a republic in everything but name. There is a head of state, and supreme power lies in the body of its citizens. Canada's constitution allows Canadians to remove the monarchy through its own legislation — though that would be a challenge — and to significantly limit the power of the Crown (CCCR 2010).

Perhaps the persistence of monarchy is due to a sense of loyalty "deeply rooted in Canadian soil" (Appadurai 2009, 2). When the thirteen American colonies rebelled against the British Empire, a groundbreaking event occurred. For many years, Canadians — as well as New Zealanders and Australians — saw little need to define themselves through a separate citizenship; they identified as British subjects. In 1935, the Irish Free State became the first Dominion to declare and define its own citizenship when it passed the Irish Nationality and Citizenship Act, which classified all non-Irish subjects, including British citizens, as aliens (Bridge & Fedorawich 2003, 8). The real revolution, however, began in 1946 when Canada introduced its own Citizenship Act, under which Canadians were still to be considered British subjects, but only by virtue of being Canadian citizens first. "The 'indivisibility of subjecthood,' which had long helped to underpin the British world, was now irrevocably severed. Australia, New Zealand and South Africa followed suit in 1948–49" (2003, 8).

5 Sections Hidden · 1,095 words
The Case Against the Monarchy280 words
If republicanism happened tomorrow, what would change? Many Canadians are split on this issue, and some are simply…
Government Structure Under a Republic195 words
The government would change only slightly if Canada were to do away with its constitutional monarchy. The Governor-General, who is technically the head of state, holds a…
Quebec Separatism and Republican Identity155 words
There is a strong argument that if Canada became a republic, it would weaken — if not completely eradicate — the impulse toward Quebec sovereignty. The idea that a republican Canada might make Quebec feel more…
Models for a Canadian Republic280 words
Canada would need to determine which republican system to adopt in the event of severing ties with England. There are many different types of heads of state, each with…
Conclusion: Cutting Ties with the Crown185 words
The bottom line, when it comes to Canada and whether or not it should break free from Great Britain, is about identity. Canada has no reason to identify itself with England any longer.…
Key Concepts in This Paper
Constitutional Monarchy Canadian Republic Governor-General Quebec Separatism Commonwealth Membership Westminster Parliament Canadian Identity Decolonization Citizenship Act Statute of Westminster
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Should Canada Become a Republic? The Case for Change. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/canada-republic-vs-constitutional-monarchy-10002

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.