This paper examines twelve common second language acquisition (SLA) classroom activities and assigns each to one of four instructional approaches drawn from Lightbrown and Spada's (2013) framework: "Get It Right in the Beginning," "Get It Right in the End," "Just Listen and Read," "Let's Talk," "Teach What Is Teachable," and "Two for One." Each activity is briefly analyzed to justify its categorization, with attention to whether the activity prioritizes accuracy, communicative interaction, passive input, or a blend of these goals. The paper concludes by reflecting on the author's personal teaching preference for the "Let's Talk" approach as the most effective method for encouraging student communication.
The following analysis examines twelve common second language acquisition (SLA) classroom activities, assigning each to an instructional approach based on the framework presented in Lightbrown and Spada (2013). The approaches used include "Get It Right in the Beginning," "Get It Right in the End," "Just Listen and Read," "Let's Talk," "Teach What Is Teachable," and "Two for One."
1. Role-play a conversation between a travel agent and a tourist — Get It Right in the End. Ultimately, the tourist wants correct information, and that may be difficult due to language barriers, so some struggle is expected before arriving at an accurate outcome.
2. Memorize a dialogue about buying airline tickets — Get It Right in the End. The key goal is to get the dialogue memorized correctly, with accuracy as the final target.
3. Underline the past tense verbs while reading a story — Get It Right in the Beginning, because this exercise should be completed correctly in the first attempt. It could also be categorized as Just Listen and Read, since it focuses on reading and visual recognition of grammatical forms.
4. Arrange illustrations in the correct sequence after listening to a story — Just Listen and Read, because the activity focuses on listening to a story and then organizing visual depictions in the correct order.
5. Work with a partner to write a story based on a cartoon strip — Let's Talk, because this activity focuses on two partners communicating to collaboratively construct a story after viewing a cartoon; they must negotiate meaning together to arrive at the right narrative.
6. Rearrange a set of scrambled words to form correct questions — Get It Right in the End, with the key goal being for students to pay careful attention to correct word order and arrangement.
7. Debate or discuss a topic featured in a newspaper article — Let's Talk, because the focus is on students discussing the issue with one another in an open, communicative format.
8. Watch an episode of Sesame Street — Teach What Is Teachable, because the activity focuses not on measurable results but rather on the absorption of language material through meaningful, comprehensible input.
9. Demonstrate and describe the steps in a science experiment — Teach What Is Teachable, because, like the previous activity, the emphasis is on communicating content to students rather than on achieving a specific linguistic outcome.
10. Interview a mystery guest and try to discover his or her occupation — Let's Talk, because the activity is centered on communicating with another person to arrive at information through interactive negotiation.
11. Play a game of "Simon Says" — Get It Right in the End, because the game is fundamentally about following instructions correctly.
12. Work in small groups to choose the ideal candidate for a job — Two for One, because this activity is a combination of talking collaboratively and arriving at a correct, justified conclusion — blending communicative interaction with accuracy-oriented decision-making.
"Author's personal preference for the Let's Talk method"
You’re 84% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.