This paper examines cloud computing adoption strategies for Tullow Oil, a multinational oil and gas exploration company. Rather than advocating a complete shift to cloud-based solutions, the analysis evaluates hybrid delivery models that balance cost efficiency with infrastructure control. The study explores critical technical and operational variables—including data portability, application portability, platform portability, and application interoperability—to determine which cloud service models (SaaS, PaaS, IaaS) best suit the company's data management and operational needs. The paper concludes that Tullow Oil should establish structured change management protocols to ensure effective interoperability across cloud and on-premise systems.
Tullow Oil is a multinational company specializing in oil and gas exploration, headquartered in London, United Kingdom. The company maintains investment interests across 150 licenses in 25 countries and operates 67 producing fields. In 2012, Tullow Oil produced an average of 79,200 barrels per day. The company's primary activities are concentrated in the Atlantic Margins and Africa, particularly in Uganda, Kenya, French Guiana, and Ghana. Major production operations span six African countries and the Southern North Sea. The Jubilee oil field, discovered offshore in Ghana in 2007 with production beginning in 2010, represents the company's largest discovery to date.
As storage and bandwidth costs continue to decline, cloud-based service solutions have become increasingly attractive to small and medium-sized businesses seeking reduced licensing expenses and operational overhead. This case analysis examines how Tullow Oil can satisfy its data management needs through strategic cloud adoption while evaluating platform-as-a-service (PaaS) cloud computing alternatives (Marinescu, 2013).
Cloud solutions offer Tullow Oil significant advantages, including the ability to avoid recruiting additional IT staff and the opportunity to focus organizational resources on core business functions and growth initiatives. However, adopting a comprehensive "all-Cloud" approach presents risks that warrant careful consideration. No single cloud model can satisfy all organizational needs. A hasty transition to PaaS solutions without thorough evaluation may prevent Tullow Oil from maximizing benefits from existing infrastructure and complicate vendor negotiations for cloud-based services (Furht & Escalante, 2010).
Hybrid delivery models represent a more balanced strategy. They allow Tullow Oil to combine the most appropriate long-term commitments with cost reductions and enable leadership to identify and address inefficiencies in both on-premise and hosted environments. The company currently faces a critical decision: whether to migrate to online hosting solutions or maintain on-premise infrastructure for certain operations (Marinescu, 2013).
Each alternative presents distinct positive and negative impacts. Companies must thoroughly assess their business needs and infrastructure foundation before making such decisions. While most solutions function effectively within either cloud or on-premise environments, the platform selection requires careful trade-off analysis between costs and security to optimize organizational returns. Tullow Oil must identify numerous advantages and disadvantages associated with PaaS deployment, paying particular attention to the classification of software and service types (Bahga & Madisetti, 2013).
Data portability represents a critical variable in the cloud versus on-premise comparison. In on-site storage solutions, organizations retain complete control over content and infrastructure mobility. Cloud-based data portability, by contrast, enables firms to reuse data components across different applications, creating operational flexibility (Rhoton, 2009).
Consider a scenario where Tullow Oil adopts Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) products for Customer Relationship Management (CRM). Commercial terms associated with one SaaS vendor may prove less attractive than alternative SaaS products or in-site CRM solutions. Customer data retained within the SaaS platform remains accessible for the enterprise's internal operations, and data portability simplifies removal from legacy CRM systems.
However, this transition frequently presents significant challenges. Data structures are often designed to fit specific application processing models, requiring substantial transformation when migrating data to different products. This complexity mirrors challenges in traditional enterprise environments, where customers can maintain previous product versions to avoid expensive upgrades. In contrast, SaaS vendors can easily force customers to adopt newer versions or risk service discontinuation, creating vendor lock-in scenarios. These technical problems, compounded by commercial arrangements, can escalate operational risks for organizations like Tullow Oil.
Application portability constitutes a second critical variable in cloud decision-making (Marinescu, 2013). In-house storage mechanisms allow increased customization of data, but this approach risks creating data incompatible with different application platforms used across the industry. Application portability enables the reuse of application components across cloud PaaS services and traditional computing platforms.
For Tullow Oil, applications built on specific cloud PaaS services may face barriers to migration due to performance considerations, cost structures, or other technical constraints. Movement to alternative PaaS services or in-house systems depends on ease of transition, which correlates with time and resource requirements. Applications using platform-specific features or non-standard interfaces encounter significant portability challenges (Bahga & Madisetti, 2013).
Application Interoperability can be achieved through standardized interfaces and industry-standard protocols. Tullow Oil can implement Application Interoperability by enabling industry-standard application environments using standard information communication and service discovery protocols (Barry, 2012). This approach provides direct platform access and supports diverse application management. Cloud PaaS platforms that run on cloud IaaS services permit applications to manage underlying resources flexibly.
One significant challenge involves portability between development and operational environments. Cloud PaaS offers particular financial advantages for development environments, avoiding investment in expensive systems that remain unused once development concludes. When different environments support runtime operations—in-house systems for some functions and cloud services for others—Tullow Oil must design applications that function across both contexts. This represents a shift from traditional approaches where development and operational environments remain identical.
Cloud computing accelerates development cycles and strengthens integrated development practices. Component-based architectures work effectively when development and operational environments employ the same platforms, and Tullow Oil implements consistent information development and processing protocols across both contexts.
Platform portability addresses the difficulty of establishing compatibility between in-house computing and data management systems. Platform portability is facilitated through reuse of platform components across cloud IaaS services and non-cloud infrastructure via platform source portability. Tullow Oil can reuse application and data bundles from supporting platforms using machine image portability approaches (Bahga & Madisetti, 2013).
UNIX operating systems illustrate platform source portability principles, exemplified by the C programming language. Establishing a system across different hardware requires recompilation and rewriting small hardware-dependent code sections. Alternative operating systems undergo similar porting processes. However, this traditional approach to platform portability introduces substantial challenges for Tullow Oil.
Machine image portability offers a more efficient alternative. This approach permits application vendors and enterprises to achieve application portability through new mechanisms. Tullow Oil can bundle applications with their supporting platform and port bundled outcomes using the Machine Image Portability model. The company requires standardized programs to represent deployed differences across IaaS services in comparable environments (Barry, 2012).
Application interoperability ensures smooth operation of components deployed across SaaS, PaaS, and IaaS platforms. In traditional enterprise models, IT environments focused primarily on client devices and monolithic application architectures. Modern interoperability requires balancing diverse components while ensuring identical components function across different clouds (Erl, Puttini & Mahmood, 2013).
Hybrid cloud solutions exemplify this requirement. Tullow Oil might deploy application components on a private cloud with copies running on public clouds to address traffic peaks. These components must operate coordinatively to achieve efficiency. Data synchronization emerges as a critical challenge when components across different clouds and internal resources interact, regardless of similarity levels. Components maintain consistent data copies while establishing synchronized states (Furht & Escalante, 2010).
Communication across clouds typically experiences high latency rates, complicating synchronization efforts. Different cloud access control regimes further complicate data movement across segments. The overall system design must address management of systems and record sources, enabling Tullow Oil to evaluate transitioning labels and domains destined for cloud service provider or consumer control (Barry, 2012).
Data visibility and transparency are achieved through dynamic composition and discovery mechanisms. Service discovery capabilities enable runtime combination of application components with alternative components, allowing Tullow Oil to acquire newer application capabilities while reducing integration costs. Cloud SaaS services become interoperable through standardized protocols enabling platform communication.
Platform interoperability requires standard protocols for information exchange and service discovery. Standard protocols enable platforms to achieve direct interoperability. Service discovery protocols supported by service registries and applications can operate on various platforms. Information exchange protocols establish sequential sessions and transfer session information, including user identity, authorization levels, and localization preferences (Bahga & Madisetti, 2013).
Management Interoperability addresses the flexibility of cloud services such as SaaS or IaaS against programs implementing on-demand self-services. Cloud computing capabilities grow organizations by managing cloud services alongside in-house systems. Generic systems management advances the association of off-the-shelf services and products (Furht & Escalante, 2010) through standard interfaces. Management interoperability interfaces provide consistent functionality across application and platform contexts, enabling unified oversight of heterogeneous environments.
"Governance structures for cloud marketplace and app store integration"
You’re 89% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.