This essay examines how Dante portrays himself as a poet of emerging greatness in the Inferno, rather than merely a naive pilgrim. Through Virgil's guidance, encounters with condemned souls such as Francesca and Paolo, and compassion for figures like Brunetto Latini, Dante the character undergoes moral and artistic instruction. The essay argues that Dante the poet deliberately separates himself from his pilgrim persona — using the pilgrim's sympathy for sinners to dramatize spiritual growth, while the constructing intelligence behind the poem demonstrates a purified, authoritative understanding of sin, justice, and poetic vocation.
On the surface, it may seem as if Dante in the Inferno conceives of himself as a naïve man. In the middle of his life, he is found in a dark wood, wandering — symbolizing his uncertain sense of poetic and personal mission. He is confronted by a poetic guide who will lead him through the underworld and teach him about the nature of sin: "For the straightforward pathway had been lost" (I.3). But the fact that the greatest of classical poets, Virgil, comes to greet Dante in his lost and fallen state is itself an indication of Dante's high esteem of himself as a poet. Dante characterizes himself as a great poet in progress, not simply a naïve pilgrim. After all, Dante is important enough that the great Latin author will tend to his spiritual needs and ensure that he does not go astray.
Virgil's presence is a way of suggesting that Dante is following in Virgil's footsteps as a writer without stating so overtly, which might seem arrogant. Francesca herself calls Virgil Dante's teacher in the underworld. Yet there may be an implication that Dante is even greater than Virgil, because Dante — unlike Virgil — is a Christian. Virgil could only ever be a great pagan poet; Dante aspires to be a great Christian poet, achieving something his predecessor could not.
In the Inferno, Dante encounters people from classical mythology and contemporary history. Virgil presents these individuals as a teaching device, illustrating the way sins are punished through contrapasso — a hellish punishment that fits the crime. Lovers who sinned in life are forever fused together in the underworld, unable to see God, and instead condemned to see only one another for all eternity. One of these condemned lovers, Francesca, says: "There is no greater sorrow / Than to be mindful of the happy time / In misery, and that thy Teacher knows" (V.121–123). The presence of her lover Paolo reminds her of earthly, sensual joy, but in hell the lovers can never recreate the brief period of happiness for which they risked and sacrificed their immortal souls.
"God tailors hell's tour to Dante's spiritual needs"
"Dante mourns his teacher yet the poem condemns him"
Dante the pilgrim in the poem might be compassionate, but the poetic intelligence constructing the Inferno damns all of these sympathetic sinners. The older, wiser poet constructing the poem is no longer lost, and as a result of what he has learned in hell, he now understands the errors of his earlier perceptions of sin. His soul and his spiritual art are purified by experience.
You’re 50% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.