This essay examines whether the protagonist of Miguel de Cervantes' Don Quixote is genuinely mad or a willful daydreamer who consciously retreats from an unsatisfying reality. Drawing on close textual evidence, the essay traces Don Quixote's methodical preparation for adventure, his progressive immersion in chivalric fantasy, and his ultimate destruction by his own self-deception. It also considers the novel's narrative form — Cervantes' own ironic entry into the story — and the historical context of a rapidly changing value system in early modern Spain. The essay concludes that Don Quixote's fantasies reflect intelligent, chosen escapism rather than involuntary psychosis, making his tragedy both a personal and political warning.
The essay demonstrates close reading combined with contextual analysis. It moves from specific textual details — Don Quixote fashioning his helmet, his organized recruitment of Sancho Panza — to larger interpretive claims about the nature of his condition, then situates those claims within Cervantes' own narrative form and early modern historical context. This layered approach strengthens the thesis by testing it on multiple levels simultaneously.
The paper opens with a thesis about chosen fantasy versus involuntary madness, then works chronologically through the novel's two parts while building the argument. A pivot occurs midway when the essay shifts from plot summary to metafictional and contextual analysis, examining Cervantes' own role as storyteller. The conclusion synthesizes the personal and political implications, returning to the opening thesis with added weight.
Don Quixote by Miguel de Cervantes is the story of a middle-aged man from La Mancha who, as a result of reading books, becomes obsessed with the chivalric code. This causes him to lose his hold on reality, and he embarks on a number of delusional adventures. The question is whether these delusions are the result of genuine madness or merely an intensified form of daydreaming. Evidence from both the text itself and elements of form and context appear to suggest the latter. Don Quixote becomes obsessed with an ideal that is outdated. His problem is that he is unable to relate to the ideals of his time, and thus chooses to enter the world of what he perceives as a "glorious" past. As will be seen, this is a process of choice rather than an involuntary submission to psychosis.
At the start of the book, Don Quixote is portrayed as a middle-aged man. He is at a stage in his life where there is little to hope for in the future, and most accomplishments lie in the past. To substitute his lost youth, the main character buries himself in stories of the past. He does this to such an intense degree that he feels the need to bring his fantasies into the context of his physical world. This is then the catalyst for his apparent madness.
The ordered and relatively logical way in which Don Quixote goes about preparing for and finding adventure furthermore suggests that his fantasies are chosen rather than imposed upon him:
"The first thing he did was to scour a suit of armour that had belonged to his great-grandfather… when he had cleaned and repaired it as well as he could, he perceived there… was only a single head-piece…. with some pasteboard he made a kind of… vizor, which being fitted to the head-piece, made it look like an entire helmet." (Cervantes 5)
He fashions his fantasy world exactly according to the ideals in his books, and Cervantes frequently suggests that he "lost his understanding" (Cervantes 4). He decides, for example, to defend the helpless and destroy the wicked. In order to do this, he engages a laborer, Sancho Panza, to be his "faithful squire." In keeping with the main character's fantasy of glory and wealth, Sancho is promised the governorship of an isle. Other elements of the fantasy include Rocinante, Don Quixote's ancient barn horse, and Dulcinea del Toboso, a peasant woman. The main character sees the horse as a beautiful, muscular animal, and the peasant woman as a beautiful princess.
It is evident then that Don Quixote's fantasies are based on a fundamental dichotomy between the way things are and the way the main character wishes they were. He is on his way to old age, as is his horse. His "squire" is a simple, befuddled man, and the "princess" is an unremarkable woman. Another dichotomy related to this is the world in which Don Quixote attempts to have his glorious adventures. He finds the reality of his social context unappealing, and thus chooses to enter a fantasy where the world views him as a great and chivalrous knight, and where chivalrous ideals are appreciated. Indeed, he seems to take great satisfaction from the idea that the world needs him:
"These preparations being made, he found his designs ripe for action, and thought it now a crime to deny himself any longer to the injured world, that wanted such a deliverer." (Cervantes 7)
While Don Quixote becomes more and more deeply enmeshed in the romance of his adventures, his grip on reality progressively loosens.
This loosened hold on reality is evident in Don Quixote's second adventure. Here his concern has moved from protecting the weak to attacking and stealing from innocent citizens in the name of his ideals. He abandons a boy to an evil farmer, for example, taking in good faith the man's word that no harm will come to the boy. He also steals a barber's basin under the belief that it is a mythic helmet, and makes himself ill for the sake of his mistaken belief in the healing powers of the Balsam of Fierbras. Throughout everything, Sancho remains faithful to his calling as squire, despite the fact that he is often the victim of the consequences arising from his master's actions.
The first part of the novel ends with Don Quixote's friends — the priest and the barber — arriving to take him home. Even the sight of his old friends does not remove Don Quixote's self-deception, and he believes himself to be under the force of enchantment. Unable to resist, he accompanies his friends to the end of his second expedition.
It thus appears that an argument for Don Quixote's willful rejection of reality in favor of his own fantasy has a firmer basis than one in favor of true madness. Despite the fact that Cervantes suggests madness, the way in which Don Quixote goes about being mad suggests organization and intelligence, whereas madness is chaos (Serrano-Plaja 26). The middle-aged main character is looking for excitement, and finds it through his fantasies. When he dies, however, he realizes that such a turn away from reality is ultimately destructive, and exhorts his friends not to fall into the same trap.
You’re 49% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.