This paper examines the writing style and literary philosophy of Edgar Allan Poe, one of the nineteenth century's most celebrated American Romantic authors. Focusing primarily on "The Tell-Tale Heart," the essay investigates the debate between psychological and moralistic interpretations of Poe's fiction. Drawing on scholarship by Dan Shen, Magdalen Wing-chi Ki, and Laurence Senelick, the paper argues that Poe's work is defined less by didactic moral messaging than by a fascination with subjective psychological states and moral unpredictability. The paper also traces Poe's biography, editorial career, and his departure from the symbolic and moralistic conventions practiced by contemporaries such as Hawthorne, Melville, and Harriet Beecher Stowe.
The paper demonstrates scholarly synthesis: it presents a competing argument (Shen's moralist reading), takes it seriously, then refutes it using a different critical source (Wing-chi Ki) and textual evidence. This "argue against the counterargument" structure is a hallmark of effective academic writing and shows the student can handle nuanced critical debate rather than simply asserting one position.
The essay opens with biographical context establishing Poe's life and career, then transitions to his aesthetic philosophy. The central body weighs the moralist interpretation against the psychological reading, using "The Tell-Tale Heart" as the primary case study. A final section broadens the argument by introducing Poe's debt to Dickens and concluding that moral unpredictability — not moral instruction — defines his fiction. The works cited section follows MLA format.
The American poet and short story writer Edgar Allan Poe is one of the most celebrated mystery and horror writers of the nineteenth century. Contrary to many of his contemporaries, Poe is remembered as a virtuoso prose stylist and a student of human psychology. Poe rejected the obvious symbolism and didacticism exhibited by contemporaries such as Melville and Hawthorne.
Poe was born on January 19, 1809, in Boston, Massachusetts, to professional actors, but was orphaned at the age of three. He moved to the South, where he was fostered by John and Frances Allan ("Edgar Allan Poe," Academy of American Poets, 2013). A Southern gothic sensibility would infuse all of Poe's later work. Poe excelled as a student but was forced to drop out of the University of Virginia because of mounting unpaid gambling debts. In 1827, he returned to Boston and enlisted in the Army ("Edgar Allan Poe," Academy of American Poets, 2013). He published his first volumes of poetry soon afterward, but only began to gain wider recognition as a writer after moving back to the South.
Poe became the editor of the Southern Literary Messenger and later Burton's Gentleman's Magazine and Graham's Magazine in Philadelphia, and the Broadway Journal in New York City ("Edgar Allan Poe," Academy of American Poets, 2013). "It was during these years that he established himself as a poet, a short-story writer, and an editor" and wrote many of his greatest works, including "The Fall of the House of Usher," "The Tell-Tale Heart," "The Murders in the Rue Morgue," and "The Raven" ("Edgar Allan Poe," Academy of American Poets, 2013). Poe struggled throughout his life with depression and alcoholism, and his condition worsened after the death of his beloved cousin Virginia, whom he had married when she was still a teenager and who was the inspiration for his poem "Annabel Lee." Poe died on October 3, 1849, from "acute congestion of the brain," which some speculate was caused by rabies ("Edgar Allan Poe," Academy of American Poets, 2013).
Poe's work encompasses many major achievements, including his contribution to the creation of the modern detective story in "The Murders in the Rue Morgue," as well as poems such as "The Raven." He is often praised as a prose stylist — a writer for whom the effect upon the reader, rather than a moral message, was paramount. Poe has been characterized as the quintessential American Romantic: unlike Hawthorne and Melville, there is no obvious moral symbolism in his writings, and there is an absence of the didactic, moralistic prose characteristic of writers such as Harriet Beecher Stowe.
You’re 39% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.