This paper examines the thematic and tonal parallels between Emily Brontë's poem "Remembrance" and the final chapter of her novel Wuthering Heights, focusing on the portrayal of obsessive, enduring love after death. Both works feature characters who cannot move beyond their attachment to a lost beloved, yet the overall tone is bittersweet rather than purely tragic. Through analysis of Heathcliff's deteriorating physical state, his visions of Catherine's ghost, and the poem's exploration of memory's pain, the paper argues that Brontë presents a unique vision of star-crossed love—one that differs from conventional tragic treatments like Romeo and Juliet by allowing both characters a kind of liberation and peace, even as they remain consumed by longing.
Emily Brontë's poem "Remembrance" and the final chapter of Wuthering Heights contain numerous similarities in tone. The poem is clearly an elegy spoken by a person—like Heathcliff—who remains obsessively in love with the departed. The question posed by the poem's final verse summarizes the struggle Heathcliff has faced since Catherine's untimely passing. Both characters must ask themselves: "How can I seek the empty world again?" What incentive do they have to continue living in a world that offers them no hope for happiness?
Without friends, family, or faith, Heathcliff's only reason to live was Catherine. Unlike the stories of other star-crossed lovers, such as Romeo and Juliet, the ending is not completely tragic. The tone and content of both pieces is not depressing, but bittersweet. This distinction matters: Brontë does not offer her characters the clean catharsis of conventional tragedy, but rather a more complex emotional resolution.
Nelly Dean observes that for Heathcliff, eating once in twenty-four hours seemed sufficient sustenance for him. This observation is significant because it shows that Heathcliff no longer cares for the delights the world has to offer. Survival itself is no longer a priority for him. His physical deterioration mirrors the depth of his emotional suffering, a visible manifestation of his withdrawal from ordinary life.
His longing for Catherine is so deep that he begins to believe he will be reunited with her. Whether this is a belief in an afterlife or simply a metaphor for being together in death is not known, but in either case it demonstrates that his affections are unwavering. Despite the ravages of time and emotional anguish, his devotion remains constant. This unwillingness to abandon his love—even unto death—becomes the defining feature of his character in the novel's final movement.
The verse in "Remembrance" that reads "I dare not indulge in memory's rapturous pain" is parallel to the scene in which Heathcliff sees—or hallucinates—Catherine's ghost. This vision communicates to the emaciated Heathcliff pleasure and pain in exquisite extremes. The ghost that Heathcliff envisions is his subconscious mind's way of indulging in the pleasure that now brings him pain: a distant memory of something he can never regain.
Memory becomes both a source of comfort and torment. The act of remembering Catherine allows him to maintain their connection, yet each recalled moment reinforces the finality of their separation. The elegiac form of "Remembrance" captures this paradox perfectly—the speaker must simultaneously celebrate and mourn, finding beauty in the very pain of recollection.
"Liberation and peace redefine star-crossed lover archetype"
You’re 63% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.