This paper examines the concept of ethical leadership within the nursing profession, focusing on the national nursing shortage as a central challenge. It argues that strong, ethically grounded leadership is essential to reducing nurse turnover, maintaining favorable patient-to-nurse ratios, and sustaining quality healthcare outcomes. Drawing on the American Nurses Association Code of Ethics and the World Health Organization's definition of health, the paper contends that a nurse leader's ethical orientation is inseparable from the operational performance of a healthcare facility. The discussion outlines key strategies for addressing systemic staffing pressures—particularly those driven by an aging Baby Boomer population—and concludes that ethical leadership is a critical resource for building stable, patient-centered nursing environments.
Nursing leadership is uniquely challenging because of the practical, physical, and philosophical demands placed on nursing professionals. When one considers the ethical implications that must also apply to this role, it becomes clear that the occupation requires a uniquely qualified individual. Indeed, as this discussion will show, in light of current challenges in the field, the achievement of ethical leadership in nursing is quite a demanding feat.
Leadership is a complex discipline. While it is critical that an effective leader understands the importance of commanding respect, delegating effectively, and conducting oneself in a manner befitting an organization's internal culture, these practical demands may say little about one's ethical orientation. Ethicality in leadership is a feature equally as important as the practical demands that define day-to-day responsibilities.
Indeed, there is a close connection between ethical performance and high standards of operational quality. This is most especially true in the healthcare context, where positive ethical behavior is tantamount to humane treatment of those in need. Therefore, as this discussion proceeds, it will be with an interest in demonstrating the importance of ethical leadership in the nursing profession. Specifically, by articulating a key issue facing the nursing profession, the discussion will demonstrate that strong ethical leadership is one of our best resources in working toward improvements.
The key issue under discussion is the national nursing shortage. There has been much discussion in recent years about the impact that high rates of professional turnover are having on the field of nursing. Specifically, this is resulting in long working hours, lowered morale, and poor nurse-to-patient ratios in many healthcare settings. According to Cullen et al. (2010), "in 2008, the American Health Care Association's report of vacancies in long-term facilities and the American Hospital Association's report of hospital vacancies combined relayed an even larger shortage of 8.1%. By 2025, the shortage in RNs is projected to grow to an estimated 260,000 FTEs, twice as high as any U.S. nursing shortage since the 1960s" (Cullen et al., 2010).
The result of this shortage is a potentially diminished quality of healthcare. Researchers have long traced a connection between better nurse-to-patient ratios and positive treatment outcomes. This connection is what makes the nursing shortage both an ethical concern and a leadership challenge. To manage the shortage, improve conditions in healthcare settings, and strengthen efforts at recruiting and — most especially — retaining high-quality nursing staff, strong leadership is required. This applies both to nursing managers and to registered nurses who have the opportunity to emerge as cultural leaders within a given facility.
This is a considerable challenge with systemic implications. In reality, there is little that nurses can do to prevent the impact of demographic realities on the current healthcare equation. As the Baby Boomer population ages into retirement and its healthcare needs grow, the number of Medicare recipients will actually outnumber the population of America's working adults. This means an especially troublesome burden for nurses and the healthcare system as a whole.
However, one key strategy is informed by the belief that there are opportunities to prepare for this reality. Ethical internal leadership combined with a patient-centered treatment strategy can help sustain the coming population change. According to Schreiber (2004), it is incumbent upon nursing leaders to play a role in reducing the risk of turnover. Schreiber asserts that "of particular interest in the assessment of turnover risk is the importance of leadership . . . due to the reliance of the team on that person. There is a large requirement for this person to apply their knowledge to many tasks" (Schreiber, p. 5).
Thus, a key strategy is the reduction in nurse turnover through strong, compassionate, and respected leadership. Improved leadership means a more nuanced distribution of labor and a clearer recognition of how best to balance nursing needs, patient needs, and institutional conditions in the pursuit of favorable treatment outcomes. If a direct connection exists between a positive healthcare environment and its ethical orientation, that change must be realized through the retention of caring and qualified nurses.
"ANA and WHO frameworks define ethical nursing obligations"
"Ethics and competence are directly interrelated"
This is why it should be considered the ethical responsibility of nursing leadership to create an environment that fosters long-term career development, that works to discourage turnover, and that ultimately conveys a clear and positive value system to other nurses through action and example.
You’re 56% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.