Female Exclusion in Victorian Adventure Novels: Doyle, Wells & Buchan
This paper examines the exclusion of female characters from three canonical Victorian adventure novels: Arthur Conan Doyle's The Lost World, H.G. Wells' The Island of Dr. Moreau, and John Buchan's Greenmantle. Drawing on close readings, authorial biography, and secondary scholarship—including Richard F. Patteson's analysis of the "imperialist romance"—the paper argues that while all three authors created exclusively male narrative spaces, they did so for fundamentally different reasons. Doyle and Buchan reinforced a conservative gender binary rooted in chivalric masculinity and anxieties about the women's rights movement, while Wells used male exclusivity as a critique of so-called civilized manhood, deliberately excluding women because they were not implicated in the novel's indictment of male savagery.
- The Exclusion of Femininity in Victorian Adventure Literature: Introduces female exclusion as a shared Victorian literary trope
- Women's Roles and Gender Anxiety in Victorian Britain: Historical context of Victorian gender roles and anxieties
- Misogyny in Doyle's Work and The Lost World: Doyle's conservatism and misogyny across Holmes and Lost World
- H.G. Wells, Feminism, and The Island of Dr. Moreau: Wells' feminist politics versus his male-only island narrative
- Gender, Masculinity, and Female Characters in Greenmantle: Buchan's two female characters and the battle of the sexes
- Conclusion: Three Authors, Three Agendas: Contrasting ideological purposes behind female exclusion
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper establishes a clear comparative framework early on, using Patteson's concept of the "imperialist romance" as a consistent analytical lens applied across all three novels.
- It strengthens its literary arguments by situating each author's fiction within their documented biographical and political positions—particularly the contrast between Doyle's conservatism and Wells' self-described feminism.
- The paper avoids oversimplification by acknowledging apparent contradictions (e.g., Doyle's support for divorce reform alongside his opposition to women's suffrage) and resolving them through close reasoning.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper models comparative literary analysis across multiple primary texts. Rather than treating each novel in isolation, it uses recurring thematic markers—male exclusivity, the gender binary, and reactions to the women's rights movement—to draw meaningful distinctions between authors who superficially appear to share the same narrative choices. This technique shows how the same literary device (female exclusion) can serve opposite ideological purposes.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a broad framing of Victorian gender ideology and the "imperialist romance" genre, then moves through each author in turn: Doyle (the longest treatment, grounded in Holmes and The Lost World), Wells (positioned as foil to Doyle), and Buchan (analyzed through two contrasting female characters). A synthesis conclusion ties all three back to the paper's central thesis about differing motivations for female exclusion.
The Exclusion of Femininity in Victorian Adventure Literature
Even a casual reader of Victorian adventure novels must arrive at the inescapable conclusion that their authors intended to create enclaves of male exclusivity—places where the novels' protagonists could express their misogynist impulses and fears far from the judgmental gaze of mixed-gender society. Male exclusivity courses through Arthur Conan Doyle's The Lost World, John Buchan's Greenmantle, and H.G. Wells' The Island of Dr. Moreau. Clearly, Robert Louis Stevenson's statement about his own book, Treasure Island—"women were to be excluded"—applies equally well to these three novels, yet each author excludes women for radically different reasons. In other words, the exclusion of femininity from Victorian adventure fiction was a trope that many authors employed, but they employed it for radically different reasons and to achieve very different purposes.
This paper analyzes that tendency by exploring all three novels through close readings of the texts, comparisons to the authors' other works, and a survey of the secondary literature. In Greenmantle and The Lost World, Buchan and Conan Doyle sought to strengthen the eroding social structure by reinforcing the gender binary that formed the basis—in their minds—of civilized society. Both believed that real men were those who were naturally impelled to heroic action and that women should be the passive audience, appreciating male action but not taking part in it. By contrast, Wells' The Island of Dr. Moreau criticized these very values by questioning whether man was truly civilized at all; Wells excluded women because, from his perspective, they were not implicated in man's crimes. Thus, while all three authors excluded women from these particular adventure novels, they did so for radically different reasons.
Women's Roles and Gender Anxiety in Victorian Britain
To fully appreciate the significance of the exclusion of females from The Lost World, The Island of Dr. Moreau, and Greenmantle, it is necessary to make some introductory observations about the role of women in Victorian Great Britain. By the end of the nineteenth century, women's roles in Britain were changing very rapidly, due to a number of factors including national wealth and the emergence of a women's rights movement. Anxiety over these changes—and about the reputed "degradation" of the "white race" through intermarriage with non-whites—manifested itself in an aggressive promotion of various forms of masculinity, which historians James A. Mangan and James Walvin described as "an obsessive commitment to physical activity" (3). According to Mangan and Walvin, the concept of manliness generated its own opposite in the category of femininity, which the historians characterized as "docility, [and a] commitment to domesticity and subservience" (4). In other words, gender relations in Victorian England were dominated by two binary categories that were increasingly idealized representations of a reality that was rapidly disintegrating—if it had ever truly existed at all. The books explored in this paper should therefore be understood as each author's implicit, and sometimes explicit, engagement with the culture changing rapidly around them.
Not surprisingly, this misogyny was expressed throughout the novels of the period. According to professor of English Richard F. Patteson, "imperialist romances"—those novels in which "white men enter a primitive region and ultimately establish a degree of influence among the natives"—are "perhaps more revealing than any [other types of contemporary literature] in [their] portrayal of women" (3). Certainly, The Lost World (white men descend into South America and encounter tribal humans feuding with ape-men), The Island of Dr. Moreau (a white man marooned on an island populated by half-animal, half-human creatures), and Greenmantle (white men living among the Turks) all fit Patteson's description of "imperialist romances," making his analysis a useful broad framework for understanding the genre. According to Patteson, women in these novels are typically described as weak, cowardly, treacherous, and lascivious; at best they are helpless but harmless encumbrances, and at worst they are outright villains. As Patteson notes, "One of the worst dangers frequently faced by the explorers is power in the hands of a woman" (5). Taken together, he concludes that "fear and hatred of women [is] evident everywhere in the imperialist romance" (5).
Bibliography
Buchan, John. Greenmantle. New York: George H. Doran, 1916. Print.
Doyle, Arthur C. Sherlock Holmes: The Complete Novels and Stories. Comp. Loren D. Estleman. Vol. 2. New York: Bantam, 1986. Print.
Doyle, Arthur C. The Lost World. New York: A.L. Burt, 1912. Print.
Frank, Lawrence. "Dreaming the Medusa: Imperialism, Primitivism, and Sexuality in Arthur Conan Doyle's 'The Sign of the Four.'" Signs 22.1 (1996): 52–85. Print.
Mangan, James A., and James Walvin. Manliness and Morality: Middle-Class Masculinity in Britain and America. Manchester, UK: Manchester UP, 1987. Print.
Miller, Russell. The Adventures of Arthur Conan Doyle. New York: Thomas Dunne, 2008. Print.
Patteson, Richard F. "Manhood and Misogyny in the Imperialist Romance." Rocky Mountain Review of Language and Literature 36.1 (1981): 3–12. Print.
Sanger, Margaret. The Pivot of Civilization. Intro. H.G. Wells. New York: Brentano's, 1922. Print.
Wells, H.G. The Island of Dr. Moreau. Garden City, NY: Garden City, 1896. Print.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.