First Article Testing Misapplication and DLA Acquisition Costs
This study examines whether First Article Testing (FAT) requirements are frequently misapplied to Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) contracts, resulting in excessive acquisition costs. Guided by three objectives and two research questions, the study employs a mixed methodology combining a qualitative review of secondary governmental and scholarly literature with a survey of thirteen DLA engineers and acquisition employees. The literature review covers DLA's mission, global logistics scope, and the regulatory framework governing FAT under the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) and the Defense Logistics Acquisition Directive (DLAD). Survey findings indicate that a large majority of practitioners believe FAT requirements are frequently misapplied, and the study concludes with recommendations to consolidate regulatory guidance, develop best practices, and reduce acquisition waste.
- Introduction and Problem Statement: Research objectives, hypothesis, and key definitions
- Overview of the Defense Logistics Agency: DLA mission, scope, and global logistics role
- First Article Testing: Regulatory Framework: FAR and DLAD clauses governing FAT requirements
- Methodology and Data Collection: Mixed methods: literature review and practitioner survey
- Data Analysis and Survey Results: Regulatory provisions, case law, and survey findings
- Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations: Findings synthesis and policy improvement recommendations
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper clearly articulates a testable hypothesis and corresponding null hypothesis, giving the research a disciplined logical structure from the outset.
- The mixed-methods design—combining a systematic literature review with a practitioner survey—adds both breadth and practical grounding to the findings.
- Regulatory provisions (FAR clauses, DLAD requirements) are reproduced and contextualized, making abstract policy language accessible and directly tied to the central argument.
- Tabular presentation of survey results with frequency counts and Likert-scale breakdowns allows readers to evaluate evidence transparently.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates the effective use of primary and secondary data triangulation. By combining a qualitative review of governmental regulations and case law with quantitative survey data from active DLA practitioners, the author strengthens the credibility of the central claim—that FAT requirements are frequently misapplied—beyond what either method alone could support. The reciprocal interpretation synthesis technique (Noblit and Hare, 1988) is explicitly identified, showing awareness of methodological precedent.
Structure breakdown
The paper follows a formal five-chapter research structure: Chapter 1 defines the problem, hypothesis, research questions, and key terms; Chapter 2 reviews secondary literature on the DLA and FAT regulatory framework; Chapter 3 explains the mixed methodology; Chapter 4 presents data analysis in three parts—regulatory documents, case law summaries, and survey results; and Chapter 5 synthesizes findings and provides actionable recommendations. Appendices supply the survey instrument, case summaries, and a process flowchart reference, supporting replication and transparency.
Introduction and Problem Statement
The Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) Acquisition (J7) Directorate is tasked with the management, establishment, and oversight of overall procurement policy for DLA's approximately 5.2 million managed items (DLA mission, 2014). According to the DLA's website, "With nearly $35 billion in annual sales, DLA buys, stores and distributes food, fuel, uniform apparel, pharmaceutical, medical and surgical products and equipment and weapons system repair parts for the military services and other customers worldwide" (DLA mission, 2014, para. 3). The Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition, Technology, and Logistics (OUSD [AT&L]) Guide for Performance-Based Service Acquisition and the Seven Step Process (ACQ 265) (2009) describes the first article testing requirements for the DLA: "Production testing is planned, conducted, and monitored by the materiel developer. FAT includes preproduction and initial production testing conducted to ensure that the contractor can furnish a product that meets the established technical criteria" (p. 120).
In sum, first article testing and approval ensures that the contractor can furnish a product that conforms to all contract requirements for acceptance (First article testing and approval, 2014). Defense Logistics Agency (DLA) acquisition costs, however, are often excessive because First Article Testing (FAT) requirements are frequently misapplied to DLA contracts. This problem is investigated through a systematic review of the secondary peer-reviewed, scholarly, and governmental literature based on the research objectives and hypothesis outlined below.
Research Objectives
The overarching objectives of this study were three-fold:
1. To determine the frequency of misapplication of First Article Testing requirements to Defense Logistics Agency contracts;
2. To determine Engineering Support Agency and Defense Logistics Agency employee interpretations of First Article Testing requirements; and
3. To provide Engineering Support and Defense Logistics Agency employees with First Article test requirement discriminators that will assist with appropriate First Article Test requirement application to Defense Logistics Agency contracts.
Research Hypothesis and Research Questions
This study's hypothesis was that first article test requirements are not appropriately applied to Defense Logistics Agency contracts. The corresponding null hypothesis was that first article test requirements are appropriately applied to Defense Logistics Agency contracts. This study was also guided by the following research questions:
1. What major factors do engineers and Defense Logistics Agency employees consider prior to applying First Article Test requirements to contracts?
2. What specific discriminators can be applied to the First Article Test requirement decision-making process?
Assumptions
For the purposes of this study, it was assumed that the surveys completed by the respondents were truthful, that the secondary data reviewed was accurate, and that the findings emerging from the literature review were sufficient to confirm or refute the study's guiding hypothesis.
Definitions of Terms
DoD: This acronym refers to the U.S. Department of Defense (DLA at a glance, 2014).
DLA: This acronym stands for "Defense Logistics Agency" (DLA at a glance, 2014).
DLAD: This acronym stands for "Defense Logistics Acquisition Directive" (DLA at a glance, 2014).
FAR: This acronym stands for "federal acquisition regulation" (Gourley, 2009).
FAT: This acronym stands for "first article testing" (Gourley, 2009).
First Article: This term includes preproduction models, initial production samples, test samples, first lots, pilot models, and pilot lots. Approval involves testing and evaluating the first article for conformance with specified contract requirements before or during the initial stage of production under a contract (Guide for performance-based acquisition, 2009).
Limitations and Delimitations
This study was limited by the fact that, although the Department of Defense is mentioned frequently in the secondary literature, there remains a paucity of timely and relevant studies concerning first article testing requirements and their corresponding effects on the costs of DoD acquisitions. The findings that emerged from this study are delimited to DoD acquisitions.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.