Functional Illiteracy and Public Sector HR Policy Research
This paper examines a landmark 1993 study by Anderson and Ricks on functional illiteracy within public sector human resource management. The study surveyed 1,215 local government offices to determine how frequently agencies knowingly hired basic-skills deficient (BSD) workers, what factors predicted such hiring practices, and what consequences followed in the workplace. This report reviews the study's quantitative research methods, including its use of chi-square tests and one-way ANOVA, evaluates the appropriateness of those statistical choices, summarizes key findings on geographic and labor market predictors of BSD hiring, and discusses implications for worker stratification — including the potential emergence of a worker caste system in certain government agencies.
- Introduction: Background on illiteracy and worker stratification study
- Methods: Survey design, sample, and instrument description
- Results: Statistical findings on BSD worker hiring prevalence
- Discussion: Methodological evaluation and worker caste system implications
- Conclusion and Historical Context: Great Migration and geographic HR attitude patterns
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Closely follows the original study's structure, making it easy for readers to trace the research from design through interpretation.
- Clearly evaluates the appropriateness of statistical methods (chi-square and one-way ANOVA) by explicitly checking the assumptions each requires, demonstrating methodological awareness.
- Connects empirical findings to a broader sociological claim — the possibility of a worker caste system — without overstating what the data can support.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates critical appraisal of quantitative research methods. Rather than simply restating findings, it interrogates whether the statistical tools chosen (chi-square for categorical/ordinal comparisons, one-way ANOVA for group differences) were justified given the data's nature, the sampling strategy, and potential sources of bias. This is a core skill in research methods coursework at the graduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper is organized into four substantive sections mirroring a standard research report: an introduction establishing the study's significance, a methods section describing the survey instrument and sample, a results section reporting key statistical findings, and a discussion section evaluating methodological choices and broader implications. A brief concluding paragraph connects the findings to historical context — the Great Migration — adding interpretive depth without introducing unsupported claims.
Introduction
Anderson and Ricks (1993) examined the role of illiteracy in determining worker status within the public sector, in part because it had not been done before. They were interested in understanding how worker stratification was determined, after scholars had raised the possibility of a worker caste system within government agencies. This issue remains relevant today, given an increasingly diverse workforce — both ethnically and linguistically. This report analyzes the research methods used by Anderson and Ricks (1993) and summarizes their findings.
Methods
The sample studied by Anderson and Ricks (1993) consisted of human resource professionals currently engaged in managing employees in the public sector. A 41-item questionnaire was used to assess the level of functional literacy these managers were observing on the job, with functional literacy defined as having the basic English reading, writing, and comprehension skills necessary to perform a specific job. Survey respondents were also queried about problems caused in the workplace by illiteracy and whether remedial actions were being taken to address deficiencies. The survey instruments were mailed to a random sample of 1,215 local government offices, representing 922 cities, 263 counties, and 30 special districts.
References
Anderson, Claire J., and Ricks, Betty Roper. (1993). Illiteracy — The neglected enemy in public service. Public Personnel Management, 22(1), 137–152.
History Channel. (2013). Great migration. History.com. Retrieved February 13, 2013, from
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.