This essay offers a comprehensive review of Francis Lawrence's 2007 film I Am Legend, starring Will Smith as the last human survivor in a zombie-infested Manhattan. The paper traces the film's origins as the third adaptation of Richard Matheson's 1954 novel and analyzes key cinematic elements including the post-apocalyptic setting, layered symbolism (pyramid imagery, the butterfly symbol, Christian allegory), the challenge of sustained monologue dialogue, internal character conflicts, and the film's distinctive tone as a cross between noir and thriller. The analysis emphasizes Smith's acclaimed performance in carrying the narrative with minimal human interaction and highlights how the film explores themes of isolation, redemption, and humanity's hubris in tampering with nature.
I Am Legend is a science fiction thriller about a New York scientist abandoned in Manhattan in the year 2012. The film runs one hour and 40 minutes, stars Will Smith and Alice Braga, and is directed by Francis Lawrence. It is rated PG-13 for violence. The movie offers a stunning view of how the city as we know it today might look in 2012 if it were abandoned in 2009.
Historically, I Am Legend is the third adaptation of Richard Matheson's 1954 novel. In the original novel, the antagonists were vampires rather than zombies. Such films draw upon our deepest fears and therefore hold special interest, particularly when they feature a scientist abandoned in New York struggling to survive a virus that transforms humans into flesh-eating, mechanical-looking zombies.
The novel has been adapted into film three times. The first adaptation was in 1964, starring Vincent Price in The Last Man on Earth. The second came in 1971, starring Charlton Heston in The Omega Man. The third and latest version, released in 2007, stars Will Smith in I Am Legend. It is fair to say that Will Smith has done honor to the material. This version represents a significant improvement over its predecessors, and it may prove difficult for any future adaptation to match the effectiveness of this release. Smith's charismatic presence and the weight of responsibility he conveys—as if the fate of the world depends solely on his shoulders—make this the most compelling version to date.
I Am Legend revolves around Robert Neville, a military scientist who was unable to stop the spread of a deadly, man-made virus for which no cure exists. Neville is the last human survivor in New York City and possibly in the entire world. For three years, he has been broadcasting radio messages in desperate hope of finding any other survivors. However, he is not alone; mutant victims of the plague—infected by a disease originally intended to cure cancer—remain hidden, watching his every move. Neville is driven by a single mission: to find a reverse cure using his own blood, aware that he is vastly outnumbered and time is running out.
In 2012, surrounded only by bloodthirsty zombies, Robert Neville and his faithful dog Samantha attempt to discover a cure for the disease and to locate any other surviving humans. His work is conducted in isolation, with only his dog as companion, as he fights against impossible odds to save what remains of humanity.
I Am Legend presents two distinct temporal frameworks. The stated setting begins in 2009 and proceeds forward from there. However, since there are no technological markers that would anchor the narrative to a specific future extrapolation, the time setting effectively remains in 2009, displaced into a post-plague phase. This is evident from the film's setting, which reflects 2009 America down to the music and records Neville uses, and from its central message: the extinction of New York, America, and the world. The movie articulates the fears and expectations of 2009.
I Am Legend employs a nested set of physical settings, each of which emphasizes and reinforces the American dream—and what the plague of zombies has destroyed. The central setting is Robert Neville's house in Manhattan, which once appeared as a comfortable middle-class home but now resembles a fortress and survivalist cabin, with wooden shuttered windows to keep zombies out and a generator for power. The wider setting is a middle-class suburban neighborhood that appears peaceful until movement occurs and the zombies attack, transforming it into a moral battlefield. There are occasional references to venturing into the city for supplies or escape, but Neville never leaves; instead, his world changes around him.
The physical and chronological settings combine to create a profound emotional weight to Neville's battle against the zombies. The year 2009 marked America's bicentennial; as a patriotic American, Neville should be celebrating his nation's history and values. By every expectation he was raised with, his Manhattan home should represent the ultimate American paradise. Instead, his city has become populated entirely by zombies. His home is no longer his castle, where he can expect privacy and respect for his individuality, but rather a fortified refuge where he must hide to survive. The familiar architecture of home becomes a prison.
Multiple layers of symbolism operate throughout I Am Legend. The most frequently discussed is the "eye of the triangle" theory. On the film's poster, the words are arranged in pyramid formation with the letter "I" at the top, resembling the eye of Horus on the dollar bill. This connects Horus symbolism with Will Smith as the hero attempting to find a cure for the plague that has transformed humanity into zombies.
Further symbolic meaning emerges through the film's use of the character's dog. Throughout the movie, Neville calls the dog "Sam," but when the dog dies, he addresses it by its full name, "Samantha." This shift represents the balance of masculine and feminine energy or principle—a recognition of wholeness in loss.
Christian symbolism also permeates the narrative. The film portrays Neville as a chosen savior—the sole survivor destined to rescue mankind from the zombie plague. His initial loss of faith at the film's beginning and his later recovery of faith when he understands his role as savior constitute a spiritual arc. These symbolic dimensions raise profound philosophical questions about human nature and purpose.
The butterfly symbol carries particular weight, connecting indirectly to Neville's daughter and more broadly to hope. When Neville hears his daughter's voice while confronting the Alpha zombie and its mate, he is reminded of his relationship with her. When the Alpha breaks through glass and assumes the form of a butterfly—the symbol representing his bond with his daughter—Neville recognizes that the Alpha will never stop pursuing him, just as he will never stop fighting to honor his promise to his daughter. This realization leads to his ultimate act of self-sacrifice.
"Will Smith's monologue performance and isolation challenge"
"Neville's internal conflict and denial of mortality"
"Noir-thriller hybrid, flashback sequences, genre distinctiveness"
The thematic message—that humanity meddles with nature without fully considering the consequences—resonates powerfully in contemporary contexts. The struggle to undo such hubris mirrors a personal journey toward redemption. Post-apocalyptic narratives have long grappled with these themes, but I Am Legend approaches them with particular psychological nuance and emotional authenticity, elevating the film beyond simple genre entertainment into a meditation on isolation, duty, and the possibility of salvation.
You’re 63% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.