This paper analyzes Lillian Hellman's 1934 play The Children's Hour, focusing on the catastrophic consequences that unfold when a manipulative student, Mary Tilford, spreads a false rumor of a lesbian relationship between the two founders of a girls' boarding school. The paper traces how Mary's compulsive lying exploits social homophobia and her grandmother Amelia's prejudices, triggering a cascade of slander that ruins Karen Wright and Martha Dobie financially and socially. It also examines how the women's firm denial of the accusations inadvertently reinforces heteronormative social structures, and explores Martha's private emotional reckoning with her own feelings before the play reaches its tragic conclusion.
Lillian Hellman's The Children's Hour takes place in an all-girls' boarding school. The play was written and produced in the early twentieth century and is set either in that era or within a few generations prior. Two friends, Karen Wright and Martha Dobie, have poured their life's energy and savings into a rural farmhouse they converted into a school they named the Wright-Dobie School.
Clearly, Martha and Karen enjoy what they do and pursue it out of love for their students and a passion for teaching, rather than for financial gain, political status, or religious purpose — the school is secular and not sponsored by any religious organization. The school is moderately successful and retains a good number of girls, but as is common in any school, Karen and Martha must contend with students who have behavioral problems, most notably Mary Tilford. Mary acts out in class and outside it, well beyond what would normally be considered innocent mischief. She is spoiled, repeatedly gets her schoolmates in trouble, has no respect for authority or discipline, and compulsively lies. Karen and Martha struggle to discipline her effectively.
One day, Mary claims to be ill and is examined by the local doctor, Joe, who happens to be Karen's fiancé. While the doctor examines Mary, Martha and her aunt Lily — described in the stage directions as a "plump, florid woman of forty-five with obviously touched-up hair" and clothes that are "too fancy for a classroom" — get into a petty argument that reveals the underlying tension between them concerning finances and differing points of view (I, i). As headmistresses and sole teachers of the small school, Karen and Martha depend on a few relatives for financial support, including Martha's aunt Lily as well as Mary's grandmother and caregiver, Amelia. The relationship between Martha and Lily is visibly strained, and Lily displays a strong narcissistic streak throughout the play.
The doctor confirms that Mary was lying about her illness, but Mary is determined to leave the boarding school and resolves to convince her grandmother to withdraw her. She asks Amelia directly if she can avoid returning, but Amelia refuses. Not accepting no for an answer, Mary spins a web of lies that ends up destroying the lives of nearly everyone around her. Specifically, Mary tells her grandmother that Karen and Martha are having a lesbian affair. The word "lesbian" is never spoken aloud, but it is unmistakably clear what Mary means when she describes their relationship to Amelia. Mary has recently become aware that lesbianism is considered taboo, based on a book she and her friends have been reading secretly at school. She knows that this particular lie will provoke moral outrage in her grandmother and cause her to pull Mary from the school.
Mary's calculation proves correct. Amelia is livid upon hearing the story. Her prejudices and homophobia surface immediately, leading her to believe her granddaughter despite Mary's well-established history of compulsive lying. Amelia's decision to remove Mary then sets off a wave of slander, as her gossipy nature leads her to telephone every parent she can reach, spreading the rumor and encouraging them to withdraw their daughters as well. Within a day, nearly all the girls have been pulled from the school, and Martha and Karen face total financial and social ruin.
Martha and Karen vehemently deny the accusations, though notably they do not challenge the social premise that makes the accusation so damaging — that is, they do not challenge the stigma of homosexuality itself. In their firm denial, Martha and Karen are in fact complicit in the perpetuation of heteronormativity, implicitly affirming the very norms that have been weaponized against them.
In the meantime, Mary has befriended Rosalie, described in the stage directions as a "fattish girl with glasses," who is meek and socially vulnerable (I, i). Rosalie has no family to stay with and so remains with Mary, who manipulates and bullies her into lying and covering for Mary's fabrications. Karen and Martha eventually decide to sue Amelia after discovering inconsistencies in Mary's story. However, with Lily out of the country, they have no supporting testimony and no one to corroborate their account. They lose the case.
Joe, Karen's fiancé, urges both Karen and Martha to leave the boarding school behind and move away with him. Karen instead breaks off the engagement, telling him she is under too much stress to continue the relationship after everything that has happened. Joe is devastated, and as they work through their feelings, Karen insists she has never had any romantic or physical relationship with Martha and does not have lesbian feelings for her.
"Lawsuit fails; Karen ends her engagement to Joe"
"Martha confronts her feelings and takes her own life"
You’re 69% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.