Magic in A Midsummer Night's Dream and The Tempest
This paper examines the use of magic and enchantment in William Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream and The Tempest, analyzing how magic functions within each play and how it would have been received by contemporary audiences. The paper traces the mythological legitimacy granted to magic in each work — classical Cupid mythology in A Midsummer Night's Dream and a more modern sorcery framework in The Tempest — and argues that both plays ultimately repudiate magic in their closing appeals to the audience. Drawing on criticism by Bill Bryson and Peggy Simonds, the paper concludes that the degree of repudiation in each play reflects the cultural anxiety surrounding witchcraft in late Elizabethan and early Jacobean England.
- Introduction: Magic in Two Shakespearean Plays: Thesis on magic's function and audience reception
- Magic and Mythology in A Midsummer Night's Dream: Love-in-idleness flower, Puck, and classical mythology
- Prospero, Ariel, and the Nature of Magic in The Tempest: Ariel as primary magic agent; Prospero's unreliability
- Audience Appeals and the Repudiation of Magic: Closing speeches and the rejection of magic in both plays
- Critical Perspectives on Magic's Cultural Function: Bryson and Simonds on magic's political and cultural meaning
- Conclusion: Synthesis of comparative argument and cultural context
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper establishes a clear comparative framework early on, identifying both a shared function of magic (farcical confusion and eventual repudiation) and meaningful differences in how each play executes that function.
- Textual evidence is used carefully and specifically: direct quotations are analyzed in context, and the paper even identifies internal contradictions within Prospero's character to argue that he is an unreliable narrator.
- The paper successfully integrates secondary criticism (Bryson and Simonds) not merely to agree or disagree, but to refine and complicate its own argument about historical audience reception.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative close reading across two texts. Rather than treating each play in isolation, the author consistently moves between them to show how differences in magical scope and mythological grounding produce different rhetorical outcomes — specifically in the closing audience addresses. This technique allows the thesis about Elizabethan attitudes toward witchcraft to emerge from the texts themselves rather than being imposed from outside.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a thesis that identifies both a shared function and a meaningful difference in magic's use across the two plays. It then surveys magic in each play individually (with the A Midsummer Night's Dream section focusing on the love-in-idleness flower and Puck, and the Tempest section focusing on Ariel and Prospero's unreliability). The two strands converge in a section analyzing the closing audience appeals, after which secondary criticism is introduced to contextualize the argument historically. The conclusion synthesizes the comparison and situates both plays within late Elizabethan and early Jacobean cultural attitudes toward magic.
Introduction: Magic in Two Shakespearean Plays
By examining the use of magic in William Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream and The Tempest, one can see not only how magic functions within the context of the plays, but also how the use of magic and enchantment would have been received by their historical audiences. Though instigated with differing motives and applied with differing levels of expertise in either play, magic primarily functions to instigate a farcical confusion on the part of the characters. And even though magic is deployed by central, "good" characters, it is ultimately repudiated by the end of each play — in both cases with a direct appeal to the audience. The use of magic to confuse and control characters, as well as this direct repudiation present in an appeal to the audience, reveals that although magic is a central theme of both plays, that centrality was nonetheless tempered in light of the audience of the time.
Before approaching what the use of magic in A Midsummer Night's Dream and The Tempest reveals about their historical and contemporary audiences, it will be useful to briefly examine the major instances of magic and enchantment in either play. In both plays, the specific magic and enchantments used are given some kind of mythical legitimacy due to a related history connecting them to an earlier mythology — whether that is a connection to Cupid in A Midsummer Night's Dream or an invented history for Ariel, Caliban, and Sycorax in The Tempest. In addition, The Tempest features Roman goddesses, but as will be seen, they are less directly related to the central magical devices than in A Midsummer Night's Dream. Furthermore, both plays feature a direct appeal to the audience containing a repudiation of the very magic that constitutes the core of each play. Depending on the amount of historical legitimacy lent by these in-text appeals to earlier mythologies, the repudiations are more or less explicit and the appeals are more or less direct.
As will be seen, A Midsummer Night's Dream's connection to classical Greek mythology allows it to be less total in its repudiation of magic and less direct in its appeal for the audience's praise, whereas The Tempest's more general use of sorcery and magic requires the eventual abandonment of that magic to be all the more explicit and complete. Furthermore, the final appeal to the audience in The Tempest is more direct, with the central character's fate resting on the audience's inclinations.
Works Cited
Bryson, B. (2009). Shakespeare. New York, NY: Harper Collins.
Shakespeare, William. (2007). A Midsummer Night's Dream. Retrieved from http://www.shakespeare-navigators.com/dream/index.html
Shakespeare, William. (2008). The Tempest. Retrieved from http://www.shakespeare-navigators.com/tempest/index.html
Simonds, P. M. (1995). "Sweet power of music": The political magic of "the miraculous harp" in Shakespeare's The Tempest. Comparative Drama, 29(1), 61.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.