Middlemarch and Utilitarianism: Mary Garth's Moral Choice
This essay examines Mary Garth's pivotal moral decision in George Eliot's Middlemarch — her refusal to take Mr. Featherstone's money or burn his will — through the lens of utilitarian philosophy. The paper distinguishes between act utilitarianism, which judges actions by immediate circumstances, and rule utilitarianism, which holds that consistent adherence to a virtuous code best serves personal happiness. Drawing on John Stuart Mill's Utilitarianism, the essay argues that Mary's conduct aligns most closely with rule utilitarianism: her refusal reflects not selfless altruism but a coherent personal standard in which moral virtue is itself a component of happiness. The author also reflects on how they would act in a comparable situation.
- Introduction: Mary Garth's Difficult Choice: Mary refuses Featherstone's money on moral grounds
- Utilitarianism and Human Action: Utilitarianism's core claims and common criticisms
- Act Utilitarianism and Mary's Decision: Act utilitarianism fails to fully explain Mary's refusal
- Rule Utilitarianism and Virtuous Consistency: Rule utilitarianism better accounts for Mary's conduct
- Mary's Own Words and Mill on Happiness: Textual evidence links virtue, money, and happiness
- Conclusion: Rule Utilitarianism as the Most Pertinent Form: Rule utilitarianism best explains consistent virtuous behavior
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds a philosophical argument in a specific literary scene, making abstract utilitarian concepts concrete and testable against narrative evidence.
- It uses direct quotations from both Eliot's novel and Mill's Utilitarianism to anchor claims, preventing the argument from becoming purely speculative.
- It honestly distinguishes between two competing utilitarian frameworks before committing to one, showing genuine analytical rigor rather than a one-sided reading.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative framework analysis: it introduces two versions of a philosophical doctrine (act versus rule utilitarianism), applies both systematically to the same literary case, and argues that one framework better explains the character's behavior. This technique — testing competing theories against the same evidence — is a foundational move in literary-philosophical scholarship.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a close reading of Mary Garth's scene, then introduces utilitarianism as a philosophical lens. It works through act utilitarianism and its limitations for this case, pivots to rule utilitarianism as the more fitting explanation, and reinforces the argument with Mill's own words on money and happiness. The conclusion synthesizes the philosophical and literary threads into a single evaluative claim about rule utilitarianism's broader applicability to human behavior.
Introduction: Mary Garth's Difficult Choice
Mary Garth from George Eliot's Middlemarch is a kind and upright person who follows her own moral principles closely. When Mary is confronted with the difficult decision that Mr. Featherstone presents her with, she does not waver and refuses to touch the old man's money or his testament. Her action is all the more significant because of the complex background surrounding the old man's death. An avaricious, weak, and heartless person, Featherstone attempts vainly to persuade Mary into taking all his money and burning his testaments so as to ensure his family is excluded from gaining anything after his death. This situation scales human dignity and the price of human life against that of material possessions at the same time.
What is interesting is the fact that Mary is not even tempted by the fortune and resists the old man's entreaties with the greatest determination. Her reaction is eloquent precisely because she appears to discard her own interest and happiness, acting with complete disinterest for the sake of respecting her moral principles. From another point of view, however, Mary does act in her own interest — or at least she acts so as to reach personal happiness. This is explicable since one can argue that the immoral act of taking advantage of the old man's death would have constituted an impediment to Mary's happiness.
In a similar situation, I believe I would be bound to act in the same way as Mary. The main reason would be that any immoral act would affect my personal happiness and comfort. Moreover, people act in disinterested ways not necessarily because they follow the sole principle of happiness, but for virtue in itself as well. Virtue can be an end in itself, since it is a necessary ingredient in what people generally term happiness. I would make my decision based on my personal comfort in this case, since the interests of others are not directly at stake here.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.