This paper examines four major nursing theoretical frameworks and their philosophical underpinnings. It begins with Margaret Newman's Health as Expanding Consciousness, which reframes illness as an opportunity for personal growth and self-awareness. It then explores Zderad's Humanistic Nursing Theory, which centers the nurse's role and interpersonal commitment in patient care. Two additional frameworks—Martha Rogers's Science of Unitary Human Beings and Travelbee's Human-to-Human Relationship Model—are introduced for comparative purposes. The paper identifies key similarities and differences among all four theories, ultimately arguing that nursing practice is grounded in care, self-awareness, and the cultivation of meaningful interpersonal relationships between nurses and patients.
The paper demonstrates comparative analysis across multiple theoretical frameworks. Rather than treating each theory as a standalone topic, the author identifies shared philosophical roots—particularly the emphasis on self-awareness, acceptance of illness, and the nurse-patient bond—while carefully delineating how each theory weights these elements differently. This technique shows the reader how scholarly frameworks can illuminate one another through contrast and alignment.
The paper opens with a general introduction to nursing theories, then dedicates focused sections to Newman's and Zderad's theories. A two-part comparative section follows, first identifying similarities and then differences. Two additional theories (Rogers and Travelbee) are introduced as supporting comparisons. A concise conclusion synthesizes all four frameworks around the themes of care, self-awareness, and interpersonal relationships.
Numerous nursing theories guide the field of healthcare within the nursing realm. The underlying idea is that by following structured frameworks, a healthcare provider will be better able to serve its designated population. Nursing theories serve as principles that nurses live by. In their chosen field or specialty, healthcare professionals encounter an array of physical and psychological states in their patients, and being able to fully grasp the severity of each situation enables the nurse to manage patient care more efficiently (Alligood & Marriner-Tomey, 2010). These nursing principles also serve as a guide for nurses in handling their own emotions. Such is the case with the theory of Health as Expanding Consciousness.
Margaret Newman established the nursing theory of Health as Expanding Consciousness. This theory emerged from concern for individual patients in whom chronic illness and severe disease had taken over their lives. In cases where living a healthy life was not remotely possible, this theory helped to explain and guide the appropriate behavior that would aid in addressing such challenges (Newman, Smith, & Pharris, 2008). As situations arose in which patients felt lost, hopeless, and uncertain about their disability or unresolved health problems, resignation eventually took hold. Patients give up when they feel they have no control over what is occurring within their own bodies.
Through this nursing theory, however, the idea of illness as an entirely detrimental factor is challenged. In fact, health — whether fair or poor — is seen as a means by which an individual can expand his or her level of consciousness (Picard & Jones, 2005). This means that individuals who experience illness or disability must learn to accept that occurrence as part of learning and understanding oneself more deeply. This nursing theory emphasizes that in acquiring illness and disease, one may find a greater meaning and higher purpose for living (Newman, Smith, & Pharris, 2008).
Health as Expanding Consciousness also emphasizes the need to reach out to other individuals who may be experiencing similar afflictions, or who may be able to play a supportive role. This theory has been expanded to encompass all forms of health, not just the severe and chronic illness that formed its original focus (Alligood & Marriner-Tomey, 2010). Health, whether negative or positive, affects the way that one views and experiences the world. This theory enables that concept to be understood and fully implemented. Health as Expanding Consciousness also implies that nurses must follow these principles for their own emotional development (Newman, Smith, & Pharris, 2008). Once healthcare providers recognize themselves within these theories and understand that their own state of health shapes how they perceive the world, they are better able to allocate their resources in the best interest of their patients.
Nursing theories define nursing practice. Unlike the Health as Expanding Consciousness model, the Humanistic Nursing Theory emphasizes the role of the nurse in providing healthcare. Zderad developed the idea that a patient's care depends on the nurse's ability not only to relate to the patient but also to understand the patient's psychological and emotional position (McCamant, 2006). In this theory, the person afflicted by illness becomes the central component, rather than the understanding of the illness itself.
Zderad recognized that patients see nurses as those capable of providing them with relief and comfort. Because it was the nurse's own decision to enter the art of healing, and because the nurse consciously chose to devote herself to the betterment of others, the responsibility of providing patients with comfort rests with the nurse. The theory emphasizes that both the patient and the nurse hold their own versions of what it means to be whole — that is, to be healthy and well (Alligood & Marriner-Tomey, 2010). From this perspective, the concept of unity is achieved. The nurse and the patient share a humanistic bond forged through illness and the nurse's capacity for healing. The healing the nurse provides is not merely a job but a dedicated choice he or she has consciously made (McCamant, 2006). By engaging with patients on a consistent basis, the nurse becomes more aware of him or herself as well.
In all, the varying nursing theoretical frameworks define how a healthcare professional approaches disease and illness. Nurses are essential to patient care and ultimately shape the degree to which a patient is able to heal. Through Health as Expanding Consciousness, Newman taught that how health is perceived defines how deeply one becomes aware of one's own existence. The Humanistic Nursing Theory, by contrast, foregrounds the role of the nurse in the patient's disease — by providing comfort and assistance, the nurse is not merely performing a job but pledging to dedicate his or her professional existence to that calling. Two additional nursing models — the Science of Unitary Human Beings and the Human-to-Human Interaction Model — were introduced for comparative purposes. Both of these frameworks support and expand upon the philosophical foundations that the primary theories also express, affirming that nursing is a field built upon care, self-awareness, and the cultivation of meaningful interpersonal relationships.
Alligood, M. R., & Marriner-Tomey, A. (2010). Nursing theorists and their work. Mosby/Elsevier.
Duffy, J. R., & Hoskins, L. M. (2003). The Quality-Caring Model©: Blending dual paradigms. Advances in Nursing Science, 26(1), 77–88.
Malinski, V. M. (2006). Rogerian science-based nursing theories. Nursing Science Quarterly, 19(1), 7–12.
McCamant, K. L. (2006). Humanistic nursing, interpersonal relations theory, and the empathy-altruism hypothesis. Nursing Science Quarterly, 19(4), 334–338.
Newman, M. A., Smith, M. C., Pharris, M. D., & Jones, D. (2008). The focus of the discipline revisited. Advances in Nursing Science, 31(1), E16–E27.
Parker, M. E., & Smith, M. C. (2001). Nursing theories and nursing practice. FA Davis.
Picard, C., & Jones, D. A. (2005). Giving voice to what we know: Margaret Newman's theory of Health as Expanding Consciousness in nursing practice, research, and education. Jones & Bartlett Learning.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.