Does George Orwell's 1984 Apply to Modern Government?
This essay examines whether the themes of George Orwell's 1984 remain relevant to contemporary government behavior. Drawing on the novel's core concepts — Reality Control, the rewriting of history, surveillance, and the manipulation of public fear — the author argues that parallels exist between Orwell's fictional totalitarian state and real-world U.S. government actions. The paper considers how shifting national enemies, the "Myth of Concern," government monitoring of citizens, and the possibility of manufactured crises echo the world Winston Smith inhabits. The essay ultimately raises unsettling questions about the relationship between state power, public compliance, and events like 9/11 and the Iraq War.
- Introduction: Orwell's Vision and Today's Government: Orwell's 1984 as a lens on modern government
- Individuality, Class, and Control in 1984: Class structure and Winston Smith's hidden resistance
- Shifting Enemies and the Rewriting of History: Cold War to Gulf War: enemies constantly redefined
- The Myth of Concern and the Gulf Wars: Fabricated justifications for military intervention
- Surveillance and Government Monitoring: Government monitoring of its own citizens
- The Most Chilling Parallel: Manufactured Crisis: Could governments manufacture attacks to control populations?
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The author grounds abstract literary analysis in concrete historical events — the Cold War, the Gulf Wars, and 9/11 — making Orwell's themes feel immediate and relevant rather than purely academic.
- The paper demonstrates intellectual honesty by openly distinguishing personal political terminology (e.g., refusing to call the administration "conservative") before proceeding with the argument.
- A well-chosen direct quotation from 1984 is used at a pivotal moment to anchor the essay's most provocative claim, letting Orwell's own words do rhetorical work.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The essay uses literary-to-real-world analogy effectively: it identifies a specific concept or scene in 1984, then maps it onto a documented historical or political event. This technique — often called "application analysis" — is a strong model for literary response essays that ask students to evaluate a text's contemporary relevance.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with context about Orwell's world and the author's political framing, then moves through the novel's class structure, its treatment of history and enemies, and the concept of the Myth of Concern as an external theoretical lens. It closes with the essay's boldest claim — that governments may manufacture crises — supported by a direct passage from the novel. The argument builds progressively from established history to speculative political critique.
Introduction: Orwell's Vision and Today's Government
George Orwell wrote 1984 in 1949. The world had been through two world wars, the Spanish Civil War, and the horrors of the Holocaust. Although he was writing about England, like Machiavelli's The Prince, it is possible to see his vision in the workings of almost any government — especially one that is quite determined to do as it wishes, irrespective of what the people want.
I have not called the present administration conservative because I don't believe that term applies to it. To me, "conservative" means to conserve the founding ideals of the Declaration of Independence, the Bill of Rights, and the Constitution. The people who wrote those documents and founded this country were not far removed from the monarchies and hereditary dictatorships of the Old World. Their intention was very clearly to protect the new country from the kinds of abuses their families had experienced in Europe.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.