This paper examines the role of protein in the human body and evaluates how dietary protein requirements differ between sedentary individuals and athletes. Beginning with the biochemistry of proteins and amino acids, the paper explains how protein is digested, how the body uses amino acids for energy and tissue repair, and what happens when protein intake is too low or too high. It then analyzes how variables such as exercise intensity, duration, energy consumption, conditioning level, and gender influence the protein needs of endurance and strength-training athletes. The paper concludes that most athletes' elevated protein requirements are already met by a balanced, calorie-adequate diet, making supplementation largely unnecessary.
The paper uses a funnel structure: it opens with broad biological context, narrows to human dietary needs, and then narrows further to the specialized requirements of different athlete categories. This technique ensures that every claim about athletic performance rests on a well-established scientific foundation, making the argument more persuasive and easier to follow.
The paper opens with protein biology and digestion, establishes the standard RDA for sedentary adults, and then pivots to athletic populations by first surveying historical misconceptions. It identifies five variables affecting athlete protein needs, applies those variables to distinct athlete types (endurance vs. strength), and closes by debunking the widespread belief that protein supplementation is necessary. The conclusion reinforces that a balanced diet typically meets even elevated athlete requirements.
Proteins are often called the building blocks of life. In fact, the very word "protein" implies their importance in the body: it derives from a Greek word meaning "first place." Approximately fifty percent of the dry weight in animal cells is comprised of protein (Campbell 71). Proteins play a role in almost everything the body does and "are used for support, storage, transport of other substances, signaling from one part of the organism to another, movement, and defense against foreign substances" (Campbell 71). Proteins are essential to the proper functioning of every organism known to science.
The human genetic code holds the instructions for making over ten thousand different types of proteins, each with a specific purpose. "Proteins are the most structurally sophisticated molecules known" (Campbell 71). In comparison to other molecules, proteins are enormous and come in nearly every shape imaginable. Despite their variety and size, however, proteins are simply polymers made up of only twenty different amino acids. What makes one protein different from another has to do with the ordering of these amino acids and the shapes they form. "By varying the numbers of different amino acids and their sequences, the body creates proteins of skin, blood, muscle, hair, bone, and nails, as well as enzymes, the catalysts that speed up chemical reactions of cells" (Ronzio 539).
About sixteen percent of protein is nitrogen (Ronzio 539). Accordingly, a rough estimate of protein content in food can be calculated by measuring the amount of nitrogen present. What the body generally obtains from food is not a complete protein — that is broken down during digestion — but the amino acid ingredients needed to build a protein. "Digesting dietary proteins supplies essential amino acids that cannot be made in adequate amounts by the body" (Ronzio 540). The body's DNA holds the information necessary to build any given protein, and dietary amino acids are drawn upon by biological processes to construct the protein being coded for.
If an individual ingests a surplus of amino acids — more than the body requires — they are not converted directly into proteins, but can instead be burned off as energy or stored as fat. It would seem, from a biological standpoint, that the amount of protein consumed should be proportional to a person's amino acid requirements. However, "Most Americans eat more than enough protein to meet their amino acid needs" (Ronzio 540).
Given that proteins are large and complex molecules, it should not be surprising that breaking them down into their amino acid components through digestion is an energy-costly process. "Protein digestion normally begins in the stomach where the strong acid (hydrochloric acid) unfolds protein in food, rendering it more accessible to attack by the digestive enzymes of the stomach. The initial phase of protein digestion yields fragments called peptides, rather than individual amino acids" (Ronzio 540). Further along in the digestive process, the pancreas and then the intestines continue to break down the peptides until, finally, individual amino acids are freed and released into the bloodstream.
Each of these chemical processes requires energy, which ultimately detracts from the net amount of energy acquired from food. This is likely why, over the course of their evolutionary history, humans developed a preference for cooked forms of protein. "Cooking foods denatures and partially breaks down proteins, making them more accessible to digestive enzymes" (Ronzio 540). By cooking food, humans increased the net amount of energy that can be extracted from it.
Over the course of any given day, the proteins that allow our bodies to function gradually wear out and degrade. This is the underlying reason why protein must be included in the diet: degraded proteins need to be rebuilt and replaced. "A steady input of essential amino acids is therefore required even when the body is at a stable weight. The recommended dietary allowance (RDA) of 0.75 g protein per kilogram of body weight for adults was based upon long-term and short-term studies of humans" (Ronzio 541). For example, a 174-pound male requires a protein intake of approximately 63 grams daily. This rate is higher for children because they require more protein to support rapid growth. The RDA has been established as the amount the average adult should ingest each day.
The first risk associated with inadequate protein is protein malnutrition — protein deficiency taken to its extreme. "With inadequate dietary protein, yet with adequate calories, less muscle wasting occurs than with malnutrition due to a lack of both protein and energy sources because protein is not broken down so extensively" (Ronzio 542). With too few amino acids available, the body must borrow them from other sources. In order to maintain normal blood sugar levels and replenish amino acids in the bloodstream, muscle proteins are broken down. As a result, the muscles of the body atrophy and begin to deteriorate.
Other health risks associated with protein malnutrition include atrophy of the intestinal lining, reduced liver function, improper fluid balance, edema, anemia, and reduced antibody levels (Ronzio 542). Clearly, appropriate amounts of protein must be ingested to ensure proper bodily function. Consuming too much protein, however, can result in its own serious health problems.
Although red meat is an abundant source of protein, it is also linked to high levels of saturated fat. Individuals who attempt to maximize their protein intake by eating large amounts of red meat put themselves at risk for health problems associated with high saturated fat consumption; "excessive saturated fat is linked to cardiovascular disease and to problems of overweight" (Ronzio 542). Furthermore, "The surplus waste products from burning excess protein place an extra burden on the kidneys" (Ronzio 542). Additional research has found possible links between protein over-consumption and osteoporosis, liver cancer, elevated blood cholesterol, and stroke. Eating an appropriate amount of protein is therefore important for everyone, since both too much and too little can have adverse effects on the body.
Somewhere between these two extremes is where today's athletes attempt to find protein levels that will boost their performance. Not all athletes fully understand the importance of a varied diet; some even put their health at risk due to inaccurate notions of how to maximize results. Basketball player Charlie Ward recalls, "Back when I was playing college ball, I figured the best way to pack on muscle was to eat a lot of fat. My idea of the food pyramid was to stack a cheeseburger on top of a double cheeseburger" (Schlosberg xxvii). Ward was certainly ingesting a great deal of protein with this diet, but he was also consuming exorbitant amounts of fat, saturated fat, and cholesterol.
"Historically, many athletes believed that consuming large quantities of protein was the key to successful athletic performance" (Berning 45). Much research conducted in the nineteenth century indicated that protein was the primary fuel for strenuous exercise. Subsequent research, however, revealed that carbohydrates and fats were far more efficient sources of energy.
"Beginning in the 1970s, research investigations began to show that athletes might require a greater protein intake than their sedentary counterparts. More recently, information has become available that the protein requirements of athletes may depend upon the type of physical activity they do and that athletes participating in different activities need this enhanced protein intake for varying reasons" (Berning 46). In other words, a world-class weightlifter's protein requirements will differ from those of a world-class marathon runner, and both will differ from those of a world-class sprinter. Given that too little protein can lead to malnutrition and too much can lead to serious health problems, it has become essential in the world of sports to balance these two forces with specific consideration given to the activity an athlete performs.
Considering the long-established RDA, nutritionists have identified several categories of athletes who may require greater levels of protein to reach peak performance. These include "endurance athletes, athletes performing intense strength training programs, teenage athletes with growth as well as exercise requirements, exercisers and athletes following a calorie-restricted weight loss program" (Ryan 70).
"Because nitrogen balance may be affected by the intensity and duration of exercise, energy content of the diet, and the training level of the subject, care should be taken to control these variables when designing an experimental protocol. Gender has also been shown to affect the substrate used for energy production during exercise, and thus nutrient requirements may be different for male and female athletes" (Berning 47).
You’re 53% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 4 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.