This paper examines the impact of the global economic recession on the shipping industry, tracing historical patterns of volatility from the 1970s oil shock to the post-2008 downturn. Using industry sources from the Economist, Wall Street Journal, and trade publications, the paper assesses the oversupply of vessels, declining freight demand, and route-specific recovery trends. It then focuses on Taiwan-based Evergreen Group — the world's fourth largest shipping firm — analyzing its strategic decisions to cancel, scrap, and eventually reorder ships in response to shifting market conditions. The paper concludes with a forward-looking assessment of growth opportunities, including U.S. waterway freight initiatives and the influence of oil price volatility on long-term shipping profitability.
This study guide is drawn from PaperDue's library of 130,000+ paper examples across 47 subjects.
The paper skillfully uses historical analogy — comparing the 1970s oil shock overcapacity crisis to the post-2008 shipping glut — to contextualize current industry dynamics. This technique strengthens the argument by showing that the pattern is structural rather than anomalous, lending credibility to both the diagnosis and the recommended strategic response.
The paper opens with an industry-wide overview, establishing historical context and the current downturn. It then narrows to a specific firm (Evergreen Group), tracing its strategic pivots in response to market conditions. The final section broadens the lens again to consider external growth drivers and risk factors, closing with a measured strategic recommendation. This funnel-and-expand structure — broad, narrow, broad — is effective for business research papers that blend industry analysis with firm-level case study.
The shipping industry has a long history of volatility, owing largely to the time that elapses between the ordering of ships and containers and their completion and delivery. This cyclical pattern — in which companies order vessels during periods of high demand only to receive them during downturns — has played out repeatedly across decades, with significant consequences for firms of all sizes. Understanding this dynamic is essential for evaluating both the current state of the industry and the strategic options available to major players such as Taiwan's Evergreen Group.
According to an industry analysis published in The Economist, the 1970s saw shipping companies dramatically increase orders for VLCCs (very large crude carriers) from manufacturers immediately prior to that decade's oil shock, leaving many companies with unnecessarily large fleets (2009, p. 56). A similar situation has emerged in the current economy: a large number of new ships were already ordered and in either the planning or construction phases, with some ready for delivery despite the fact that distribution and shipping companies no longer needed the vessels, due to the marked decrease in demand for goods and materials of all kinds during the recent global recession (2009, pp. 55–57).
There is some indication, however, according to the same article, that this issue will be mitigated by the backlog of orders that shipping vessel and container manufacturers are experiencing — allowing for timely cancellations — as well as plans to phase out many older vessels for both environmental and economic reasons (2009, p. 56).
The problem of an overabundance of shipping vessels is itself merely indicative, according to industry analyst Ainsley Thomson writing in the Wall Street Journal, of the major downturn in overall global shipping that the industry has experienced since the latter half of 2008 (2009, p. B4). Though raw materials shipping saw a rebound in the latter half of 2009, the shipping of manufactured goods had yet to experience such a recovery, and Thomson reported that the industry was likely to continue experiencing losses for some time to come (2009, p. B4).
As the world's fourth largest shipping firm, the Taiwan-based Evergreen Group of subsidiaries has certainly not been immune to the woes of the shipping industry during this downturn. Industry reporter Ben Shen, writing in the state-sponsored China Economic News Service, noted significant losses for the company beginning in the second half of 2008 and continuing into the present period (2010).
Earlier in the present decade, the Evergreen Group had begun to expand its capacity through the ordering of a total of forty-nine new ships to be completed between 2003 and 2013. Jason Dean of the Wall Street Journal quoted company chairman Chang Yung-Fa as saying, "The demand increase is far exceeding the capacity" of the company's shipping capabilities — a situation that was true at the time but that has almost entirely reversed (2003, p. A2).
There are internal indications from the company, however, that its situation could be changing. Shen reports that the company, having scrapped plans for many of the unbuilt ships in recent years, will again be ordering newer and larger vessels as trade increases (2010). This represents a dramatic turnaround from Chang's statements to The Economist only six months prior, in which he indicated that the company was preparing to scrap part of its large fleet in addition to halting orders for new ships (2009, p. 57).
The reason for this reversal, according to Shen, is the rather rapid return to profitability that the company has seen on its Asia–Europe shipping routes, and an expected similar return to profits on Asia–Americas routes in the coming quarters (2010). As trade once again increases, the new ships will contribute to a more modern, more environmentally sound, and more economically efficient fleet for the Evergreen Group.
Measured and careful growth are suggested as means for capitalizing on the current economic situation. With the recession nearing an end, the Evergreen Group must resume its growth strategy — but if it again outstrips true demand or its own ability to generate profits, the company could face serious financial consequences. The historical pattern of boom-and-bust cycles in maritime shipping underscores the importance of disciplined, demand-driven expansion rather than speculative fleet accumulation. By aligning new vessel orders with verified route profitability and monitoring oil price trends, the Evergreen Group can position itself to lead the industry's recovery while avoiding the overcapacity pitfalls of the past.
You’re 66% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.