This essay examines James Baldwin's use of mood in "Sonny's Blues" to illuminate the narrator's journey from emotional distance and judgment toward his brother Sonny to genuine understanding and love. The paper traces how Baldwin shifts the mood from one of autopilot numbness and routine—characterized by the narrator's disconnection from both his students and his brother—to one of awakening and redemption following the narrator's attendance at Sonny's jazz performance. Through careful analysis of Baldwin's descriptive language, the essay demonstrates how the story's reflective tone and increasingly vital imagery parallel the narrator's transformation, ultimately revealing that true brotherly love requires abandoning rigid expectations and embracing the complexity and beauty of another person's lived experience.
"Sonny's Blues" by James Baldwin is a story about a man—the nameless narrator—who doesn't truly know his brother. In the literal sense, of course, he knows his brother: his brother is Sonny. But in the actual sense, the narrator does not "know" his brother; in other words, his brother has not been part of his life, has been dead to him for a long time, and only re-enters his life when a story about Sonny's troubles lands in the newspaper the narrator happens to be reading. The story uses mood to great effect in establishing the way the narrator has blocked out Sonny from his life, as he has never really been willing to accept Sonny on terms other than his own. This paper will discuss how Baldwin uses mood to explore the theme of brotherly love in "Sonny's Blues."
The mood of the story is reflective: memories brought on by a cold shock to the system, which stirs up recollections in the narrator that he rarely ponders within himself. His life is consistent, routine, regimented, without deviation from the norm—in short, everything that Sonny is not. They are polar opposites and this, the reader senses, is the reason they have grown apart. However, a more important reason for their separation lies in the willfulness of the narrator himself: his disposition is not one that will allow Sonny to pursue his own interests, his own dreams, and make use of his own talents.
His disposition is reflected in the mood in which he situates the story at the beginning: it is as though his life were on autopilot. It begins in the belly of the subway, where he zips to and from work. His life occurs between snatches of light, sensed in his description of the way the "swinging lights of the subway car" illuminate his reading, and in the way his high school algebra classes follow one after another in allotted schedules of time—a little bit here, followed by another little bit, snippets of human interaction. Yet he admits he does not even know his students. Perhaps they are in the same predicament his brother is in, "popping off needles every time they went to the head" (123). The narrator, admittedly, passes through life without ever really connecting with anyone. The mood is muted, the spirit diffuse.
It is as though the narrator were waking up for the first time, as though he had been in a deep slumber and now were suddenly jarred awake by news of his brother, which breaks over him like a dam collapsing, allowing a flood of memories, thoughts, emotions, and a new mood to run over him. He recognizes sounds and sights—his students, their movements and their laughter—as never before: he sees his brother and himself in them.
The sense of how the mood of the story is shifting from one synonymous with a coffin to one synonymous with rising from the dead is revealed in the way the narrator describes the students as he looks out the window at them in the courtyard below. One is whistling a tune that is like a breath of fresh air, confident and sublime; others are full of spring, their "sap rising" (Baldwin 123-24). A teacher moves through the crowd of boys as though he cannot wait to get away. The narrator does not say so, but the reader feels that this teacher might just as easily have been himself a day before. But now something has changed.
He is thinking of Sonny, and the youthfulness of the boys is making the thought alter his mood in such a deep and personal way that the story is going to be almost totally reflective, immersed in the past and the consequences of actions. The narrator, who has viewed life in a formulaic way—he teaches algebra, after all—is realizing that life is not formulaic, that it is more "simple and complex" (Baldwin 123) than he can even begin to imagine. And it is this simplicity and complexity that Sonny represents when he plays his jazz on the piano.
"Jazz performance breaks narrator's judgment, awakens brotherly compassion"
Now, he has finally understood what it means to love his brother—and the mood of the story is exalted, alive and full of feeling—just like the music pouring out of Sonny. The music pours through the narrator and fills him with more visions of his past, his father, his mother—and yet the visions are different, as though no longer imprisoned within him, as he had been within his routine at the beginning of the story. Now they are free to "be given back" to eternity (Baldwin 148). Through mood, Baldwin transforms the narrator's journey from one of emotional isolation and rigid judgment into one of spiritual awakening, demonstrating that true understanding between brothers requires the willingness to surrender one's predetermined expectations and embrace the full humanity of another person.
You’re 74% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.