This paper examines the gap between early impressions of the teaching profession and the realities teachers encounter in practice. Drawing on scholarship by Barr (1945), Brouwer and Korthagen (2005), and others, the paper traces how student-stage perceptions — shaped by the "apprenticeship of observation" and idealized education textbooks — lead new teachers to underestimate the demands of the classroom. It explores the personal and situational causes of false assumptions, contrasts positive and negative adjustment experiences, and considers how staffing pressures compound the challenge. The paper concludes with recommendations for improved practical training and early career guidance to better align expectations with professional reality.
The teaching profession is one of the oldest in existence and has experienced considerable growth over the years as a result of the dynamic nature of the teacher's role in the education system. Teachers are assuming new dimensions as the ways in which children learn change, alongside shifts in the broader learning environment. The early impression of the teaching profession was that it simply involved imparting knowledge to students, with very little consideration of individual academic capability or need. Over the years, this approach has been evaluated as ineffective — it has caused many children to drop out of school by finding it too difficult, and has left others feeling alienated. Additional negative effects include antisocial behavior resulting from insufficient individual attention, as well as increased incidents of violence, aggression, and bullying within schools.
These outcomes prompted a transformation in the teaching profession, one that incorporates strategies for including children in the learning process and providing solutions customized to each child's needs. This shift has led to greater development of pro-social behavior and a more wholesome education, rather than the purely academic knowledge transmission that characterized earlier conceptions of teaching.
Teachers often assume that a classroom is made up of students with equal learning capabilities, and that each classroom is essentially the same. These are among the false assumptions identified by Barr (1945). It is argued that such assumptions arise from teachers having difficulty translating theoretical learning into the practical environment. This sentiment is echoed by McAlpine, Weston, Berthiaume, and Fairbank-Roch (2006), who note that teachers are often undertrained for the demands their work places on them. Without adequate practical experience, many find teaching to be an extremely challenging profession.
Hourcade and Bauwens (2001) identified that personal causes are the main contributors to these false assumptions. These personal causes include a lack of the proper attitude, an inappropriate career choice, and a lack of suitable personal characteristics. Situational causes also play a role — among them loneliness in the teaching environment, difficulty relating to parents and students, heavy workloads, and inadequate training. Brouwer and Korthagen (2005) further note that teachers often feel pressure to appear confident and competent, which creates a dilemma when they are confronted with the real challenges of the classroom. This pressure can prevent new teachers from seeking help or acknowledging their difficulties, compounding the problem.
Heafford (1962) argues that initial impressions of teaching are formed while the teacher is still a student — a phenomenon referred to as the apprenticeship of observation. Simply put, this describes how students observe and admire their teachers as knowledgeable figures who make a significant impact on their lives. This admiration leads students to aspire to the profession without honestly assessing their own capabilities or considering the practical demands teaching involves. The result is a romanticized view of education that does not reflect the day-to-day complexity of classroom work.
Education textbooks and courses share some responsibility for perpetuating these impressions. They often convey the notion that learning proceeds smoothly as long as specified methods are applied correctly, leaving prospective teachers unaware of the inevitable challenges they will face in practice. Teachers are also frequently encouraged to develop their own teaching style — a sound principle in theory, but one that fails to prepare them for the extra effort required to help slower learners or manage disruptive classroom dynamics. Generally, teachers are not made aware of the true challenges of their profession until they encounter them firsthand.
"First-hand challenges new teachers face on the job"
On the other hand, a teacher who holds the notion that respect comes automatically with the role may find it difficult to manage a class containing rowdy or disengaged students. This places the teacher in a vulnerable position: if they fail to engage and respond constructively to those challenges, their career can suffer significant setbacks. Research on teacher preparation consistently shows that classroom management is among the skills new teachers feel least prepared for upon entering the profession.
A further reality involves institutional pressures. School administrations frequently employ different strategies to manage staffing shortages, which often results in teachers being asked to take on extra classes without additional compensation, or to assume administrative duties outside their areas of expertise. These demands are unlikely to match any early impression of the profession and can cause significant difficulty in coping. The combined weight of these pressures helps explain why teacher retention remains a persistent concern in education systems worldwide.
Teachers usually hold early impressions of the teaching profession that differ considerably from the reality they encounter. This gap exists largely because of inherent deficiencies in education textbooks and courses, which do not adequately expose student teachers to the challenges they will face once they begin teaching. As a result, many teachers find it difficult to cope with the profession, and this difficulty frequently has a negative effect on their productivity, their engagement with students, and their long-term commitment to teaching.
To reduce the gap between early impressions and professional reality, teacher education programs should place greater emphasis on the diversity of classroom environments and the unique needs of individual students. Practical exercises that offer genuine experience in varied classroom settings should be a core component of training. At an earlier stage, career guidance sessions for young students could present an honest picture of what teaching involves, helping to prevent the formation of false assumptions before they take root. Such measures, taken together, would better equip future teachers to meet the demands of a profession that is both challenging and profoundly important.
Barr, A. S. (1945). Impressions, trends, and further research. The Journal of Experimental Education, 14(2), 200–206.
Brouwer, N., & Korthagen, F. (2005). Can teacher education make a difference? American Educational Research Journal, 42(1), 153–224.
Heafford, P. E. (1962). Impressions of science teaching in Pakistan. International Review of Education / Internationale Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft / Revue Internationale de l'Éducation, 8(1), 85–89.
Hourcade, J. J., & Bauwens, J. (2001). Cooperative teaching: The renewal of teachers. The Clearing House, 74(5), 242–247.
McAlpine, L., Weston, C., Berthiaume, D., & Fairbank-Roch, G. (2006). How do instructors explain their thinking when planning and teaching? Higher Education, 51(1), 125–155.
You’re 88% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.