This paper examines the concept of transcendence as it appears in western monotheistic religions, arguing that belief in the divine is fundamentally reinforced by recognizing the limits of human understanding. The paper identifies three types of transcendence — formal subordination, the impossibility of deciphering divine will, and the radical "otherness" of God — and illustrates each through specific religious examples. The kabbalistic concept of En Sof is used to demonstrate how the divine operates at a deep cosmic level beyond human comprehension, while the mystic view of Ra'bia illustrates the reverential distance believers maintain from God. Together, these examples show that transcendence, far from being a barrier to faith, is the very foundation of it.
Religious beliefs are concepts that people hold about divine existence. Because these concepts developed ages ago, it is difficult to criticize them given the time frame within which they emerged. One cannot fully understand the reasons why individuals in the past did certain things, since contemporary people have a very different mindset compared to those in earlier times. However, in this rational world one cannot simply choose to ignore religious beliefs. Believers in divine existence assert that certain characteristics of the divine are beyond human perception and understanding — a reality captured by the concept of transcendence.
According to religious belief, transcendence always serves to reinforce and secure belief in the divine. It is because of transcendence that individuals may come to understand the existence of a divine God. There are three types of transcendence. The first is a formal or official transcendence, which encourages a feeling of humility and subordination on the part of human beings. It is through this type of transcendence that certain religions insist on the utmost respect for the divine.
The second type of transcendence involves realizing how impossible it truly is to understand what the divine wants of human beings. Human beings cannot decipher the way in which the divine thinks or plans. The third type of transcendence is the recognition of the radical "otherness" of the divine. Human beings cannot really know what the divine being is like, and in no way can one begin to compare or assume similarity between humans and the divine.
The kabbalistic idea of En Sof relates to the second and third types of transcendence. It considers the nature of the divine as something that operates at a deep cosmic level, focused on the very structure of the world. This understanding holds that human beings cannot really decipher God's form, but can only know that He exists and that the world is a result of His actions. The divine, in the kabbalistic conception, is infinite and utterly beyond the grasp of human reason or imagination.
"Islamic mysticism and reverential distance from God"
The forms of transcendence found in western religions explain that human beings cannot really know what lies beyond human perception. It is the distance — the transcendence — that human beings recognize between themselves and the divine that leads them to understand and affirm the existence of the divine. This also reinforces the view that it is futile to dispute the existence of the divine, because transcendence places such questions beyond the reach of ordinary rationalization. As explored through both the kabbalistic tradition and the mystic practice of Ra'bia, transcendence is not an obstacle to religious belief but rather its very foundation.
Reference
Corrigan, J., Denny, F., Eire, C., & Jaffee, M. Jews, Christians, Muslims: A Comparative Introduction to Monotheistic Religions.
You’re 82% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.