This essay examines how Chaucer's Wife of Bath exerts control over her first three husbands through multiple interconnected strategies. Drawing primarily from her Prologue (lines 195-452), the paper identifies and analyzes eight distinct control mechanisms: verbal torment and self-assertive language, cunning and affection-withholding, strategic deception, preemptive accusation, argumentative negation through verbal mirroring, prescriptive rhetoric about trust, sexual manipulation and blackmail, and moral preaching. The analysis demonstrates that the Wife succeeds in dominating her husbands not through physical violence but through superior persuasiveness, psychological acuity, and rhetorical skill, making her one of literature's most compelling examples of power assertion within marriage.
In Chaucer's Canterbury Tales, the Wife of Bath presents herself through an extended autobiographical confession in her Prologue. She is a cunning and profligate woman who openly discusses her past marriages, her sexual frustration, and her licentious tendencies. Unapologetically outspoken, she complains about her husbands' failure to meet their marital obligations: "Now wherewith sholde he make his payement if he ne used his sely instrument?" (Chaucer, 131-132). She wishes her husbands would "pay their debts" more frequently, for she is sensually insatiable. "In wyfhode I wol use myn instrument as frely as my Markere hath it sent" (149-50). When her marriages cannot satisfy her desires, she ventures outside them to take lovers she cannot resist.
Her priority in marriage is the pursuit of mastery and power. She describes herself bluntly as the scourge of marriage, willing to employ any means necessary to secure control over her husbands as "debtors and thralls." Her success is evident: "I governed hem so wel after my lawe that ech of hem ful blissful was and fawe to bringe me gaye things fro the fayre" (219-21). Beyond controlling their wealth, the Wife seeks bodily and sexual dominance: "I have the power during al my lyf upon his proper body, and noght he" (156-57). To understand how she controls her first three husbands, we must examine her rhetoric in lines 195-452 of the Prologue.
The Wife exerts power over her husbands first through tormenting them with aggressive language. She boasts that she would "sette hem so a-werke, by my fey, that many a night they songen 'weilawey'" (215-16), rendering their lives intolerable through self-assertive speech. She casts herself as the "whippe" (175) and claims to "chidde hem spitously" (223), employing brash invective to cow her husbands into submission. Yet she is also capable of subtler tactics. For instance, she deliberately displays pleasantness in one moment and spite in another to confuse her husband into thinking her mad (231-32). This strategy works because she simultaneously withholds affection unless he complies with her demands; he must serve her to win her love.
The Wife describes herself as the "wilde fyr" that "the more it brenneth, the more it hath desyr to consume every thing that brent wol be" (373-75). This self-portrait reveals her consciousness of language as a weapon. Her constant verbal assault is calculated to be psychologically devastating, enough to break the husband's will to resist.
Deceit is integral to her arsenal of control. She believes that lying, like spinning, is a prudent strategy for a wife (223, 401). She uses falsehoods to justify her nighttime wanderings, claiming she is spying on her husband's infidelities when she is actually pursuing her own lovers. "I swoor that al my walkinge out by nighte was for t'espye wenches that he dighte" (397-98). This deception actually endears her to her husband because it falsely suggests she cares about his fidelity. In this way, lying becomes a tool of manipulation, allowing her to maintain her control while concealing her own behavior.
Perhaps her most skillful tactic is preemptive accusation—what she encapsulates in the proverb "Whoso that first to mille comth, first grint" (389), meaning strike first. The Wife claims to "byte," "whyne," and "pleyne" as though she is wounded or offended before her husband can lodge complaints against her (386-87). By attacking first with accusations and criticisms, she creates guilt in him and prevents him from challenging her infidelities. For example, she asks him, "What dostow at my neighebores hous? Is she so fair?" (239-40). After being called a lecher and drunkard (242, 246), how can he dare preach to her when he himself stands accused of shameful acts?
Even more ingeniously, she speaks to her husband using the very words he would use to condemn her. This rhetorical mirroring negates his arguments before he can voice them. As he is about to accuse her of hiding her vices, she preempts him: "Thow seyst we wyves wol oure vyces hyde til we be fast, and thane we wol hem shewe-well may that be a proverb of a shrewe" (282-84). By putting words into his mouth and slurring his intelligence, the Wife simultaneously undermines his authority and defends herself, derailing his suspicion altogether.
The Wife also controls her husband by prescribing how he should treat her. In lines 308-322, she announces that he ought to grant her freedom to "go wher thee liste" rather than lock her away. "We love no man that taketh kepe or charge wher that we goon; we wol ben at oure large" (321-22). This amounts to asking, "Don't you trust me? How can you not trust me?"—a rhetorical trap that forces him to appear trusting or face the accusation of being mistrustful.
She also manipulates sexuality itself as a tool of control. The Wife withholds sexual pleasure to extort compliance: "Namely abedde hadden they meschaunce: there wolde I chide and do hem no plesaunce; I wolde no lenger in the bed abyde . . . til he had maad his raunson unto me; thane wolde I suffer him do his nycetee" (407-12). She yields only after exacting a ransom—a form of coercion. Later, she chides her husband for using her solely for sex: "What eyleth yow to grucche thus and grone? Is it for ye wolde have my queynte allone?" (443-44), turning his sexuality against him as a tool of shame.
Finally, the Wife controls through moral authority. She preaches patience and meekness to her husband as she kisses his cheek (433-35): "Suffreth alwey, sin ye so wel can preche; and but ye do, certain we shal yow teche that it is fair to have a wyf in pees" (438-39). In other words, practice what you preach. She tells him that men, being more rational than women, must bend to her will (441-43). By framing her demands in the language of virtue and reason, she places him in an impossible position: to resist is to appear irrational or immoral.
The Wife of Bath illustrates multiple ways of asserting control over her three husbands. These range from cunning, lying, and preemptive rhetoric to withholding sex and preaching morality. She never resorts to physical violence. Instead, her dominance rests on outwitting her husbands through superior persuasiveness, psychological insight, and mental agility. Her methods are sophisticated precisely because they operate on the plane of language and psychology rather than force, making her one of Chaucer's most complex characters.
Chaucer, Geoffrey. The Canterbury Tales: Fifteen Tales and the General Prologue. Edited by V. A. Kolve and Glending Olson, 2nd ed., Norton Critical Edition, W. W. Norton, 2005.
You’re 97% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.