This paper examines Hugh Whelchel's non-fiction manuscript "How Then Should We Work" and its relevance to the counseling profession. The author argues that Whelchel's doctrine of vocation—the concept that work should be meaningful and aligned with one's calling—is particularly important for counselors, whose professional influence directly shapes clients' lives. The paper traces Whelchel's historical reconstruction of vocation doctrine from Biblical times to the present, explores how religious foundations both strengthen and potentially limit his argument's appeal to secular audiences, and reflects on the manuscript's personal significance to counseling practice. The analysis concludes that while Whelchel's insights are universally applicable, expanding his evidence base beyond Christian theology would enhance accessibility and academic credibility for non-religious readers.
Hugh Whelchel's non-fiction manuscript How Then Should We Work addresses a critical issue in modern occupational life: the widespread dissatisfaction many workers experience in their jobs. The author identifies a significant gap between the average employee and their position, noting that many people do not seek—nor find—the sense of fulfillment and meaning in their work that could inform how they approach their responsibilities and achieve their professional goals. This concept directly relates to the importance of esteem found in Maslow's hierarchy of needs (Bull, 2014, p. 53–54). Beyond merely identifying this problem, Whelchel offers concrete ideas about how to rectify this situation and help individuals find greater fulfillment at work.
The relevance of Whelchel's manuscript is particularly acute for the counseling profession. Whereas many occupations involve routine transactions with clients or customers, counselors play a profound role in shaping the lives and accomplishments of those they serve. A manager at a fast-food restaurant focuses on ensuring instant customer gratification; a counselor has the potential to significantly influence their clients' long-term well-being and growth. For this reason, it is vital that counselors feel a genuine sense of purpose in their work, take pride in their profession, and recognize significance beyond their paychecks. Without such intrinsic valuation, counselors risk what Alderfer's ERG theory identifies as frustration regression—a state in which individuals become discontent from not fulfilling their needs (Arnold and Boshoff, 2013, p. 698). Whelchel's advice on achieving meaningful work can implicitly make counselors more effective and better able to serve their clients. From this perspective, his book is essential reading for those in the counseling profession, as it helps them develop a sense of self-worth about their positions and their influence on those they are meant to help.
What distinguishes Whelchel's work is that his approach to meaningful work is rooted in Christianity. The sense of fulfillment he advocates stems from a longstanding Biblical tradition (Whelchel, 2012, p. 30). Notably, however, the author's principles are applicable to a wide variety of workplace settings, including secular environments. His thesis rests on the belief that work is a form of ministry for the devoted Christian—a concept that extends naturally to those of other faiths or no faith who wish to make the world a better place through their labor.
The core of Whelchel's career theory is the doctrine of vocation: the principle that people's work should be animated by a sense of calling, regardless of their specific occupation. To establish the significance of this doctrine, Whelchel reconstructs its history, showing how it has been understood across time and cultures. The foundation of the doctrine is the belief that a person's job should be linked to their calling—their purpose. Whelchel traces this concept through the New Testament and explores how various cultures and societies have understood it from Biblical times to the 21st century. Throughout this history, he demonstrates that periods of respect for work and personal calling have alternated with periods of decline. He argues that while this doctrine has lost popularity in contemporary times, many Christians and people of other denominations struggle with work in ways that could be addressed by embracing this principle of vocation.
"Analysis of how Christian foundations strengthen but limit appeal"
To expand his appeal to non-Christian readers, Whelchel might strengthen his argument by relying less on Christianity as the sole foundation for the idea of meaningful work. The concept of finding meaning in one's work is universal, transcending religious conviction. The author could subtly revise the manuscript to emphasize this universality without incorporating as much religious dogma. This might involve abbreviating the historical account of work as ministry to include only the most salient points, or incorporating fewer references to the kingdom of God. Additionally, integrating more evidence from psychological sources regarding the effects of satisfying work on laborers would strengthen the secular credibility of his thesis.
The primary aspect of Whelchel's work that resonates most deeply for counselors is the role he attributes to people and creation. From a Christian perspective, God exemplifies mankind's charge to create, having created all existence. As a counselor, this principle carries profound professional meaning: one has the means and ability to create positive change in the lives of clients. Effective counseling requires attending carefully to both what clients say and what remains unspoken, then utilizing knowledge and experience to formulate plans that help them improve their lives. In doing so, counselors help clients develop the power to become creators themselves—to engage in work aligned with purpose and to continue the legacy of purposeful creation that reflects deep calling and meaning.
Whelchel's doctrine of vocation is thus not merely a philosophical concept but a practical framework for counseling excellence. When counselors embrace their work as calling rather than mere employment, they bring heightened intentionality, presence, and commitment to their client relationships. This sense of purpose directly impacts the quality and effectiveness of counseling outcomes, making Whelchel's insights invaluable for the profession.
"Personal integration of vocation doctrine into counseling identity"
You’re 67% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.