"
The reality is that most jurisdictions have, in effect, changed this requirement by designating specific courts as small claims courts, where disputes are not settled by juries. Moreover, even in federal-level litigation, the amount in controversy required for most suits means that many litigants lack standing to proceed in a federal court, much less have a jury trial. What this amendment demonstrates is that the process for amending the Constitution has failed to keep up with the changes that are warranted by that process. To work around the fact that the modern court system would grind to a halt if every person with a twenty dollar dispute were entitled to a jury trial, the Courts have interpreted this amendment to mean that people are entitled to a jury trial if they would have been entitled to one under the common law. However, that is clearly not adhering to the text of the amendment. Inflation has dramatically changed what this amendment would mean. Rather than allowing judges to attempt to place a modern interpretation on the amendment, it would be far better to eliminate it and draft a new amendment to the Constitution that would specifically address the circumstances that give rise to the right to trial by jury and perhaps institute guidelines for when those circumstances should be reconsidered.
References
93:1 (2008), available at http://www.minnesotalawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Balkin_MLR.pdf
Allen Clifton, a Reality Many Americans Don't Want to Admit: Our Constitution is Outdated
and Broken, Forward Progressives, (Jul. 20, 2013), http://www.forwardprogressives.com/a-reality-many-americans-dont-want-to-admit-our-constitution-is-outdated-and-broken/
Louis Michael Seidman, Let's Give Up on the Constitution, the New York Times, (Dec. 30,
2012), http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/31/opinion/lets-give-up-on-the-constitution.html?_r=1&
U.S. Const. Amend. II.
U.S. Const. Amend. VII.
U.S. Const. Amend. II.
Allen Clifton, a Reality Many Americans Don't Want to Admit: Our Constitution is Outdated
and Broken, Forward Progressives, (Jul. 20, 2013), http://www.forwardprogressives.com/a-reality-many-americans-dont-want-to-admit-our-constitution-is-outdated-and-broken/
Louis Michael Seidman, Let's Give Up on the Constitution, the New York Times, (Dec. 30,
2012), http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/31/opinion/lets-give-up-on-the-constitution.html?_r=1&
(U.S. Const. Amend. VII).
The only way, it would seem, to affect the kind of change that supporters of the initiative want is to amend the state constitution, effectively changing the law of the land. Supporters argue that this is the only viable option left, especially in light of the fact that marijuana is less dangerous the alcohol -- a legal drug -- and that the war on drugs has netted no significant
. But it is a shame that the ERA -- an amendment that is fair, appropriate, and necessary -- is attacked by right wing organizations using phony, absurd arguments to shoot down this amendment. Nevertheless, the procedure that Congress and the states must go through to amend the Constitution has stood the test of time. And in any event, the U.S. Supreme Court has had the authority -- and has
The final determinant of the union's competence in any matter lies with the European Court of Justice. This makes the European Court of Justice the highest constitutional forum in Europe dealing with matters of dispute inter-se the national states and the Union itself. The end product is an elegant scheme which allows for maximum sovereignty and sense of participation to the individual citizen and which minimizes the impact of
Constitutional government Creating a system of checks and balances A constitutional government places limits upon the exercise of power in writing. Power is invested in institutions, not simply in people or customs. According to President Woodrow Wilson: "A constitutional government is one whose powers have been adapted to the interests of its people and to the maintenance of individual liberty. That, in brief, is the conception we constantly make use of,
Fourth, a small but significant controversy surrounds the timing of the proposed amendment and its inevitable link to "the Governator." The first issue, regarding the sacrosanct nature of the constitution, is one of the easiest to address. While amending the constitution should not be taken lightly or respond merely to the fluctuating passions of a rapidly changing society, many constitutional amendments are necessary to preserve and enforce the specific liberties
Articles of Confederation and Constitution Constitution addressed a number of complaints listed in the Declaration of Independence against Great Britain's King. In addition, the Constitution cured a number of weaknesses in the Articles of Confederation by giving powers, rights and divisions to the federal government, as well as providing a different method of amending the Constitution. At times, the Constitution was developed through compromises such as the Great Compromise, which set
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now