Constitutional Legitimacy: Reflecting on the Place of the US Constitution
According to Chau (2012), the concept of constitutional legitimacy refers to “the acceptance that an exercise in power is justified and therefore authorized, either implicitly or explicitly, by society at large” by a constitution (par.1). This is different from the concept of legality. Rather, constitutional legitimacy refers to how the legitimacy of laws are derived. In stark contrast to many European systems of government (because the US does not even have a figurehead of a monarch), the people, states, and the democratic process itself supports the legitimacy of the constitution. It is worth noting, however, as increasingly institutions which have been taken for granted in the United States as legitimate are being questioned, such as the Electoral College or the fairness of the voting process. “Establishing this legitimacy is arguably more important than the substantive provisions of the constitution, as a constitution that is substantively flawed but perceived as legitimate may yet endure, but a model constitution deemed illegitimate in the eyes of the people will never”...
According to Barnett (2003), even if the constitution does not derive legitimacy from uniform consent, if the constitution contains reasonable precautions to ensure that imposed laws are just, the constitution therefore has legitimacy if consented to by the majority of the populace. For example, the US Constitution contains certain provisions for a fair trial, the electoral process, and obtaining consent...…of the populace. Of course, the justices can also substantially alter in their opinion over the course of their lifetime tenures, further isolating them from the immediacy of
public opinion.
Still, although there is substantial questioning of specific aspects of the US Constitution spanning from the Electoral College to the current interpretation of the Second Amendment, to create an entirely new system of constitutional law for as complex and sprawling nation as the US would be extremely challenging. Although this was possible in the early days of the US, as manifested in the shift from the Articles of Confederation to the current US Constitution, and there have been many additions and changes to the territory to the US, the Constitution has remained one steady, uniting force, for all of its problems.
References
Barnett, R. (2003).…
