Term Paper Undergraduate 6,537 words Human Written

Guns, Germs, and Steel: The

Last reviewed: ~30 min read Arts › Jared Diamond
80% visible
Read full paper →
Paper Overview

Guns, Germs, And Steel: The Fates of Human Societies Jared Diamond's book - Guns, Germs and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies won the Pulitzer Prize, the Phi Beta Kappa Award in Science, the Rhone-Poulenc Prize and the Commonwealth club of California's Gold Medal. (Editorial Reviews: Amazon.com) Only some are more extensively competent to mark history...

Writing Guide
Mastering the Rhetorical Analysis Essay: A Comprehensive Guide

Introduction Want to know how to write a rhetorical analysis essay that impresses? You have to understand the power of persuasion. The power of persuasion lies in the ability to influence others' thoughts, feelings, or actions through effective communication. In everyday life, it...

Related Writing Guide

Read full writing guide

Related Writing Guides

Read Full Writing Guide

Full Paper Example 6,537 words · 80% shown · Sign up to read all

Guns, Germs, And Steel: The Fates of Human Societies Jared Diamond's book - Guns, Germs and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies won the Pulitzer Prize, the Phi Beta Kappa Award in Science, the Rhone-Poulenc Prize and the Commonwealth club of California's Gold Medal. (Editorial Reviews: Amazon.com) Only some are more extensively competent to mark history with regard to geography and sociobiology. Jared Diamond who is a molecular physiologist at UCLA is an evolutionary biologist as well in the discipline.

He was interested in bird watching and for 33 years he was in New Guinea which was a seat of learning of the 1000 languages out of the 6000 languages existent in the universe. This made him to come in contact with an amazing diversity of people. Diamond's writing for the common readers was amazingly less before his stunning book published in 1992; the Third Chimpanzee: The Evolution and Future of the Human Animal. (the Clash of Continents) In the exact meaning of the term, Prof Diamond is an environmentalist.

Unlike hereditarians, who generally ascribe diversity in groups to genetic and environmental causes, Diamond takes into account environmental aspects only - primarily plants, wildlife and geography. According to him, genes are not responsible for any variation in technology, literacy and victory in military or other facet of different cultures. Prof Diamond thus gave himself an overwhelming responsibility: occurrences as complicated as cultural difference are fitting to possess intricate reasons, hence the lesser variables a hypothesis of discrepancy allows, the less credible it is liable to be.

It will be fascinating to witness if Prof Diamond's attention on geography fascinates the terror brand "reductionist" so frequently imposed on hereditarians. (Squaring the Circle) as against that kaleidoscopic exciting-read, Guns, Germs and Steel emphasizes at a sole notion, at times over and over again. Nevertheless, it compensates the endeavors. (the Clash of Continents) Jared Diamond in his book Guns, Germs & Steel gives a persuasive account for the deviation in technological growth among Eurasian people and those of Africa, Oceania and the Americas.

His vital theory stated that environmental issues were the chief propelling power in societal fruition. This theory has come into being through the assessment of a veer of ecological factors like the diverse presence of plant and animal varieties appropriate for keeping it for domestic purposes as also geographical factors like size of the continent and direction, and ease of relocation. Diamond's impetus is to demystify a racist elucidation of history.

It appears enough for that to refer the various ethnic groups within Eurasia which have at some period of time or another piloted in technological and political development in a time interval which is very short for genetic transformation to be the reason. (Guns, Germs, and Steel- the Fates of Human Societies: (www.actionismyreward.com) Also frequently in the past, people believed to be intellectuals have presented bigoted hypothesis based on supposed biological and genetic variation among the ethnic groups.

Diamond's deeply serious book which won the Pulitzer destroys the racialist myth and substitutes it with a clarification based mainly on geography. In brief, Diamond debates that numerous factors that was existent in Europe kicked off the development of agriculture and the domestication of animals from an initial stage. This in turn was the cause for increased concentration of population that resulted to more and more expertise among the members of the community as well as growth of scribes, religious leaders, military personnel, inventor, bureaucrats, and so on.

Greater concentration of population gave way to increased immunity to infections. (Guns, Germs, and Steel- the Fates of Human Societies: proudestmonkeys.com) Hence Jared Diamond in this crafty, revealing and enjoyable publication, Guns, Germs, and Steel gives a presentation of the biologist's solution: geography, demography, and ecological coincidence.

What was the reason behind Christendom's eagerly and lastingly embracing the wheel, the chief constituent in a majority of machinery, whereas the Islamic societies mostly eschewed it? When syphilis broke out for the first time what happened in contrast to what is happening at present with the outbreak of AIDS? What are the events taking place in highlands of Diamond's second home, Papua New Guinea where communities have plunged a full circle right from the technology of the stone axe to computer in a lifetime's time frame? Diamond has a lesson to offer: Dream big similar to our astronomers, who launch their guidance by not attempting to comprehend the panicky rotations of the elements of the asteroid region, but the easy and majestic rotations of the important planets since time immemorial.

"Guns, Germs and Steel" is a challenging beginning. (Editorial Reviews: Amazon.com) The publication is regarding the societies who have ruled the universe and the reason for it. A significant lead in our realization of human societies, Guns, Germs and Steel archives the manner in which the present world came into being and strikingly dismembers ethnic-based premises of history of the humans.

In its totality, Guns, Germs and Steel cover the growth of agriculture, technology, writing, government, and religion presenting an integrated hypothesis of human history as fascinating as the history of the glaciers and dinosaurs.

What was the reason behind emergence of disparity within communities? Why was Europe not captured by the natives of Australians, Americans, or Africans? (Editorial Reviews: Amazon.com) What was the cause that Europeans resulted in colonizing a greater portion of the universe? What was the cause behind Europeans colonizing Peru, Mexico, Ghana, and Australia? Why didn't it occur to the Incas, Aztecs, Ashanti, or Australians defeat Eurasians? (Bradford, Review of Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel) To put it differently, one of Diamond's friends from New Guinea- Yali interrogated him as to what was the reason for them to possess the entire 'load'? (Yee, a book review) Diamond states he was so moved by Yali's astuteness and appeal, he was aware that the reason behind the technological backwardness of New Guinea is something else apart from dearth of intelligence.

He possessed this feeling prior to seeing Yali, however their meeting aided to concretize this feeling in the mind of Diamond. (Guns, Germs and Steel- search.barnesandnoble.com) the Fates of Human Societies: This publication tries to provide an answer to Yali's doubts. Regardless of different corroborations from anthropology and biology, a lot adhere to ascribing the opposing political and economic triumphs of the population of the world to biological, "ethnic" disparities. Others attribute to cultural disparities or to historical possibility.

However, Diamond views the basic reasons as due to the environment, keeping eventually on ecological disparities between the continents. (Yee, a book review) the reply of Diamond to Yali can be summarized in a single phrase: "seeds, germs, size, and guns." The communities of Eurasia gained a primary edge compared to other societies in their fight to germs.

Moreover, the comparatively beneficial biological gift of Eurasian societies was subsequently strengthened as the geographical spread of Eurasia and the comparative advantage had by European societies was at that time enlarged to awesome size by guns. (Bradford, Review of Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel) Three principal causes have been analyzed by Diamond: The continent's shape, the allocation of wild plants and animals which can be domesticated; and the geographical obstacles preventing the dispersal of domesticated plants and animals.

(Guns, Germs, and Steel- the Fates of Human Societies: (www.actionismyreward.com) Therefore, instead of racist or devout causes, he holds some superb environmental and cultural factors. Diamond narrates that the drive for penning the book came from a New Guinea native friend, Yali, who questioned him" What is reason that you whites made up a great deal of load and carried it to New Guinea, whereas we black people owned a small amount of load?." The sum and substance lies in the biogeography.

History charted diverse streams for diverse people due to the diversity of the environment of the people and not due to biological diversity within the people's themselves. (Winner of the Pulitzer Prize National Bestseller) Among the weird sequence of the book, Diamond appears to realize that varied ethnic grouping may possess really conflicting intellectual potential.

Actually, he contends that an inhabitant of New Guinea should be more mentally advanced compared to a contemporary western European since when we sit around viewing TV and consuming fast food, they are attempting to unravel the manner in which to place dinner on the table or grass mat or whatever. Let us overlook, for the time being, the issue of who is comparatively intelligent.

The peculiar aspect, taking into consideration the framework of the remaining part of the book, is that following the brawl that there are these disparities, Diamond at no point even admits the probability that such disparities possessed any impact on the growth of the human societies thereafter. On the contrary, he holds that societies grew about solely in keeping with the geographical environment and the simplicity of the domestication of the plants and animals situated close to the place.

(Pulitzer Prize: Nonfiction) The episode unfolds when the hunter-gatherers of the Stone Age comprised the total human population. Till the period up to 11,000 BC every individuals remained Stone Age hunters/gatherers. Nearly that time, the roads of growth of human societies on various continents started to move away in a large scale. (Guns, Germs, and Steel- the Fates of Human Societies: (www.2think.org) During that period, when Stone Age hunter-gatherers comprised the total human population, a big segregation happened in the proportion that the human societies progressed.

In Eurasia, several regions of Americas, and Africa, agriculture started to be the existing pattern of livelihood when domestication of aboriginal wild plants and animals were done by the prehistoric planters and herders. Diamond fairly examines the human history on each continent starting from the Ice Age at a proportion that stresses just the widest traversals of people and concepts.

However, his assessment is symmetrical: one eye has rather long-term view of the evolutionary biologist, whereas the other eye and his spirit resides in the inhabitants of New Guinea, where he was engaged in field work for more than 30 years.

(Winner of the Pulitzer Prize National Bestseller) With the culmination of the last Ice Age, there remained a region of the universe better gifted with the plants and animals which would result in the progression towards civilization: that valley of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers which is popularly known as the Fertile Crescent. In that area was available natural stocks which came to be domesticated crops of wheat and barley. For the development of fabrics there was Flax.

Also available were an overwhelming number of large mammals which could be domesticated: sheep, goats, cattle. While agriculture took birth and animals were domesticated, a type of encouraging feedback propels the growth in the direction of civilization. Humans started living; excess supply of food can be stocked hence population grows. This results in the division of labor, the surfacing of a privileged category of people, the systemization of rules, and languages.

(Winner of the Pulitzer Prize National Bestseller) as is showed intensely by Jared Diamond, the same people who were made initiation in food production will clash with preliterate cultures, forming the present universe by way of invasion, dislocation, and mass killings. Societies which were the initiators in the production of food progressed beyond the hunter-gatherer phase, and thereafter made inroads in religion - as also malicious microbes and powerful arsenal of battle and made adventure on the sea and land to overcome and devastate preliterate cultures.

(Editorial Reviews: Amazon.com) Initial domestication of wild plants and animals in the Fertile Crescent, China, Mesoamerica and the southeastern U.S., and other regions, gave individuals of those areas a first mover advantage. The reason why wheat and corn, cattle and pigs, and the present universe's other 'hit' crops and livestock grew in those specific areas and not in other places was till this time, however barely comprehended.

Societies which progressed beyond the hunter-gatherer phase had increased chances to develop writing, technology, government, established religions as also vicious microbes and powerful arsenals of war. (Guns, Germs, and Steel- the Fates of Human Societies: (www.2think.org) But in the opinion of Diamond initial domestication of wild plants and animals in China and other regions, rendered people of these areas a first mover advantage.

China of the 15th Century BC was barred from developing its military and technological strength by the reality that there were no land blockade to thwart the supremacy of the singe-power group. Therefore, while the prevailing Imperial group moved against expansion of the naval forces and technological progression, there was not any scope for protesters to locate some sheltered mini-state and go on as earlier.

More commonly, European states had the liberty to be engaged in competition against one another; means of social organization that resulted in military, economic or technological flaw were liable to be shoved out by better customs, however there was a lot of flexibility for diverse manner of performing things. (Bradford, Review of Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel) Diamond even familiarized Polynesia as a "natural experiment," an example on a lesser extent of his total hypothesis.

In the discovery of Polynesia and habitation of the Pacific, colonizers belonging to one cultural and racial background settled in greatly diverse settings, starting from continental New Zealand, through volcanic islands of different sizes, to desolate islands and distant Easter Islands. Hunter-gatherer communities eventuated on some islands and better states and proto-nations on others. As a paradigm between various communities, Diamond prefers the summit of the Spanish conquistador Pizarroo and the Inca Atahuallpa at Cajamarca in 1532.

The outcome was the winning of Pizarro, despite that his armies were lesser in number and the imprisonment of Atahuallpa. The immediate reasons of this were germs, technology, domesticated animals, and writing. (Yee, a book review) Moreover, Diamond contends that the widest facet of present world - viz. North America's control by whites were mainly caused by disparate natural resources of the continent's domesticatable flora and fauna. The areas which had an overwhelming quantity of these could sustain the changeover from hunter-gatherer to farmer-lender, permitting increased concentration of population.

Further those societies that were able to vacate the majority of the manpower from agriculture to concentrate in technology and war were able to defeat their neighbors. A few regions like the Middle East were the abode of a lot of domesticated foods: wild grains like wheat as well as bigger mammals such as cows and sheep. Other regions of Eurasia like Europe were sufficiently proximal to the Fertile Crescent for quick dispersal of these crops and livestock.

As against this, greater regions of the Planet, as well as supposedly affable landscapes such as California, have a dearth of originally native plants which would be more beneficial to grow compared to gather. (Editorial Reviews: Amazon.com) The valuable plants of New World, the corn of Mexico to illustrate, was migrated rather slowly to the north and south to America since the crop growth are very dependent upon the latitude. Moreover the New World was quite deficient in large domestic mammals.

Presently only 14 species of mammals are being domesticated those are over 100 pounds except for commercial purposes. Out of these only the llama/alpaca is originally considered local to the Americas. However, prior to 13000 years the New World tamed the prospective beasts like horses and camels considered useful. According to Diamond, the American Indians after their arrival began to devour them. Such selfishness resulted in military impotency of the descendants of Aztec and Inca and found to be prone to the dangerous Conquistador's diseases.

Contrary to this the Spaniards were found to be immune to the germs being successors of the foods and technologies of Eurasia as well as to the Chinese inventions of paper, gunpowder, and the, compass. As the worst endemics are consequence of the diseases of farm animals, to illustrate, small-pox from cows, no diseases appeared to have inherent to the local Americans to fight back. The geo-historical strategies of Diamond definitely made clear the continental scale history.

The Eurasian history comprises much of the World history and Diamond could not make it clear as to the reasons for eventual overcoming of the East and South Eurasians by the West Eurasians. (the Clash of Continents) While much of these arguments have been heard before Diamond has represented them combined more realistically.

(Editorial Reviews: Amazon.com) Since its insights are observed to be brighter and its facts are very new and fascinating it is the testimony of the ways the well-educated citizens of the Western world visualize the most significant forces of human history. (Winner of the Pulitzer Prize National Bestseller) Diamond thus took apart the destructive racial theorems detecting societal disparities as the biological disparities. He combined the persuasive evidences connecting germs to taming of animals, germs that the Eurasians propagated in large scales in their work of discovery.

Agriculture had been revolutionized six times all over the world: in New Guinea, in China, in the Middle East, in North America, in Mexico, in the Andes along with the other places. The humans residing in the Middle East were found to be fortunate. The plants those were readily available to them were found to be tamable; their growth was quick and they had the largest seeds.

The agriculture practiced in the Middle Eastern region was based on wheat and its cousins and had the prospects of safeguarding higher population densities. The founders of agriculture in the Middle East were found to be fortunate in another field. Eurasia possessed many large of animals like aurochs, boar, ancestral sheep and goats, horses those can be domesticated. Effective taming of large animals infuses a further impetus to the Middle Eastern productivity and made it possible still higher population densities.

(Bradford, Review of Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel) Besides residing with closeness of animals fetched the Eurasians both the epidemic diseases those were to ravage the populations of the Americas, Oceana and Australia when contact took place and also immune to such diseases. The technologies found out in the Middle East and other parts of Asia then spread over the entire continent. Almost similar climates are confronted by moving east or west from the Middle East for long distances.

Thus a model of agricultural technology considered good and productive in the Indus Valley had a good chance of being useful in Spain. The size of Eurasia implies that there were many varied groups of people that could invent new technologies. The long east-west axis of Eurasia implied the extensive spread of invented technologies. Contrary to this the technologies invented in other places faced difficulties in spreading across the ocean or through the ecological barriers within which the technologies stopped to be of use.

(Bradford, Review of Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel) The corn had to take many thousand years for spreading from Mexico to the Mississippi Valley across the desert mostly due to its selective-bred for Mexico germinates at the earliest and takes too long to grow for it to be of any use in Missouri. The llama could not make it north from the Andes to the Valley of Mexico. The residents of New Guinea and of Australia could find out the technologies they could invent themselves on their own.

The progress of their technologies is considered very low since their population was low and one head was considered less than two. In consideration to the technological developments Africa was found it self to be quite largely on its own.

The performance of the Middle Eastern agriculture is found to be pretty good on the north coast of Africa however, could not spread across the Sahara desert and is considered not feasible even if it had spread across due to the fact that the temperate agriculture does not flourish near the equator. The Indian Ocean traders become unsuccessful in discharging Eurasian agriculture to the highlands of Kenya and the grasslands of South Africa remaining to be a mystery. The better agriculture of Eurasia gave rise to higher population densities.

The larger population and high population densities of Eurasia fetched it the awe-some bulk of world population. The large portion of population implied the contribution of Eurasia to the world of inventions and innovations. The simplicity of communication that spread across Eurasia implied that inventions in one portion spread within centuries to other portions. China could not retain the silkworm for itself for long nor could India retain 'zero' for a long time.

The Eurasians could attain, wheel, sophisticated textiles, advanced metalworking, shipbuilding, the state and the gun with quick and widespread technological advancement. The Eurasian cultures had significant benefits over others: devastated by diseases against which they had no resistance, and being out organized and without guns, the other cultures could find themselves subjugated and dominated by those that emerged in their lands to serve the king, to serve God, to win glory and to get rich.

(Bradford, Review of Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel) Jared Diamond attempted to record the evolution of agriculture in his book. He narrated the time and locality of origin of food production and the way it propagated with increase in population and by emulation and the way it never started off in some regions. He also covers the much unconscious co-evolutionary processes inherent in domestication, the evolutionary process of some particular crops, and the symptoms that made some plants more favorable than the others for domestication.

(Yee, a book review) Later Diamond thinks and rejects the theme that some people became unsuccessful in adopting agriculture, or adopted little later as a result of their cultural features. The hunter gatherers have fairly well awareness of the prospective of the plants in their environment and while some groups are more conservative and defying changes some people also exist all over those are observed to be ever ready to innovate.

The climate of Fertile Crescent seen to be conducive for annual plants and a species that blend with critical, large seeded, self-pollinating grasses. The consequence was swag of crops inclusive of protein-rich cereals and pulses; other regions like New Guinea and the eastern United States are deficient of such crop suite. Similar analysis has been made with regard to the taming of large mammals. In this context also Eurasia was seen to have favorable environment for some particular species.

Whereas some other species could be tamed only in the African environments, they have behavioral features that revolted against it. With their availability the natives of other countries quickly adopted Eurasian domestic animals. The quick mastery of the horse by some Amerindian groups is considered to be a remarkable illustration. Moreover, Diamond predicts a crucial dissimilarity between the continents. He found that the primary axis of Eurasia extends from east-west while the axes of Africa and the Americas are north-south.

Since the crops are climate dependent and climate differs much with latitude, crops and domestic animals possible extend across Eurasia more convincingly. (Yee, a book review) Diamond points out that continents having north-south axis such as Africa and the Americas could not provide favorable environment for the spread of Agriculture since plants had to go through varied climatic zones. There is however no narration about the adaptability of plants irrespective of the fact of the presence of essential elements of domestic ability.

The omnipresent potato presently is adopted in many areas considered foreign with reference to its place of origination. The theory of Diamond built on the edifice of the concept of domestication of wild animals is considered to be a little stronger. (Guns, Germs, and Steel- the Fates of Human Societies: (www.actionismyreward.com) Coming back to the possible reasons covered earlier, Diamond concentrated more on diseases, writing technology, and centralized government.

The contagious diseases resulted in high levels of mortality in populations throughout the New World and Australia, often much prior to having direct contact with European settlers. (Yee, a book review) Contrary to this the European Penetration into the tropics was rather decelerated by Old World tropical diseases to which they could not have any resistance. The question arose as to the origin of such diseases and the reason behind traveling of so few in other direction.

The higher population densities in Eurasia generated a niche for new diseases, the existence of domestic animals that provided a pool of suitable candidates, and their propagation was favored by fair cross-continental communications. Then after, Diamond demonstrates a capsule history of the origins of writing, finding out the limited uses of early writing systems and their evolutionary refinements their propagation through emulation and copying. After this there is a chapter on more general technological innovations emphasizing its reliance on population size, the easy diffusion of ideas, and auto catalytic feedback.

However, the single most prominent consequence of food production was that by generating reliable food surpluses it permitted huge, dense, sedentary and stratified societies to originate. Applying a simple band/tribe/chiefdom/state typology Diamond attempted to exemplify the relationship between population density and social structure and the transition from egalitarian societies to redistributive 'kleptocracies'. (Yee, a book review) Diamond also covered the share of religion and ideology to the political organizations.

Part Four of his book concentrated on the case studies from different regions, representations of archaeological and linguistic evidence to regenerate their history in the circumstances developed earlier. Diamond particularly concentrated at the methods of good communications and early political unification generated by the unusual linguistic and cultural unity of China. He also emphasizes on the clash of the Old and New Worlds while comparing the dates for the adoption of agriculture, metallurgy, states, and writing in various regions.

He also provided ample scope for a quick glance at the New World linguistics and the brief Norse contacts with North America. Irrespective of the geographical proximity, Australia and Papua New Guinea had quite different histories. Australia consistently projected to be a land of hunter gatherers, while the New Guinea was considered one of the original centers of food production. However, New Guinea never devised centralized states and the transition of agriculture is not seen across the Torres Strait. This is attributed to the environmental differences and ecological barriers.

When the Europeans could construct an industrialized state in Australia, they had to fetch the key elements, the crops and technology, from outside. The expansion of Austronesia into the Southeast Asia and the Pacific, beginning from Taiwan and the Southern China as early as 3000 BC, was considered to be one of the important transitions in the human history.

Being armed with outrigger canoes, domestic animals and agriculture the Austronesian speaking people were observed to overthrow and replace the hunter gather population of Indonesia and the Philippines and gradually extended into the Pacific in the Polynesian Diaspora. However, the Austronesians strived to infuse far into the New Guinea or to have any considerable impact on Australia. Ecology is also seen as a major factor behind the complex demographic geography of sub-Saharan Africa.

The evolution of Iron-working and agriculture motorized the Bantu expansion into the southern Africa, dislodging the pygmies and the Khoi-San. The features of their crops could demonstrate the reason of their settlement at the Fly River, leaving for the European settlers with appropriate crops to commence agriculture in South Africa. The amazing settlements of Austronesians at Madagascar are covered all by itself.

(Yee, a book review) Moreover, Diamond advocated that the contiguous nature of the countries in the east-west axis, along with their temperate environments, give rise to rapid dispersion of plants and the domestication of animals. Practically, there appeared many inhospitable obstacles within Eurasia that as per the theory of Diamond would give rise to ban of its propagation. However, Diamond could not effectively deal with such elements.

Diamond also was unsuccessful in explaining, sufficiently, as to the reasons behind the failure of Australia to initiate farming until much later irrespective of having similar climates as prevails in the mid-lateral region of Eurasia. Thus Diamond points out that Eurasia was destined to be successful in the global historical competition as a result of its geographical and environmental benefits. Europe could surpass China and began to dominate ever since about 500 years before. The success of Europe in this regard is attributed to the deficiency of competition within homogeneous China.

(Guns, Germs, and Steel- the Fates of Human Societies: (www.actionismyreward.com) Diamond is not satisfied with only writing the history of preceding 13000 years. He also advocated his work to have large political significance since it visualizes that no ethnic group is considered mediocre to any other; each tried to make the most of its local food resources to the fullest extent possible.

To illustrate, with the completion of the stock of Eurasian-based food supplied of the Australian Outback explorers like Burke and Wills, they had to rely on the pity and expertise of the local Stone Age hunter-gatherers at least for three times. Such Aborigines observed to be the least technically progressed of all people may not have domesticated a single Australian plant in 40,000 years. However, in last 200 years under the influence of scientific whites they have domesticated merely the macadamia nut.

The agriculture in Australia only thrived with the application of imported crops and livestock. The question arises whether the native people are inferior. In reality, considering the attributes and parameters the local ethnic groups are considered to be somewhat superior genetically to the outsiders. (the Clash of Continents) Diamond demonstrated the environmental disparities as the compelling factors to make us understand the fact of the adaptation of humans to the native lands by way of natural selection.

Practically, Diamond himself cites several illustrations briefly with regard to the genetic disparities influencing history. Irrespective of the military superiority, Europeans frequently failed to settle equatorial West Africa, partly due to fact that they lacked the malaria resistance bestowed on many natives by the sickle cell gene. Moreover, the biological deficiencies deterred the whites from escaping the Andes. The question still arises whether this make Diamond a loathsome racist. The answer is an emphatic NO.

However, it indicates that scientific observer like Diamond should not dogmatically condemn genetic explanations since he is liable to get tarred with his own brush. The unreliability of human bio-diversity does not entail sufficient facts that we also differ somewhat mentally but it is hard to imagine as to the reason behind the variation of the brain from the rest of the body. It is worth considering the story of the grasshopper and the ant.

The personality attributes of ants with regard to its foresight and caution made it fit to go through the harsh winters of the region which is predictable. However, the strength of grasshopper, the improvisation and spontaneity entails it the attributes of Darwinian superiority in a tropical land where the threats are quite unpredictable. As with many, Diamond appears to puzzle the concepts of genetic superiorities and genetic supremacy. The first one depends upon the circumstances.

To illustrate a slim, heat-shedding Somalian-style body is considered inferior to a typically stocky, heat conserving Eskimo physique in Nome. However, it is considered superior in Mogadishu. Contrary to this the genetic supremacy is observed to be a threatened fantasy that one group is best at everything. Prior to initiation of the European explosion in the 15th Century, it appeared apparent that no race could be supreme. Even the proud Chinese were seen to have surpassed periodically by less cultured barbarians. The recent European.

1308 words remaining — Conclusions

You're 80% through this paper

The remaining sections cover Conclusions. Subscribe for $1 to unlock the full paper, plus 130,000+ paper examples and the PaperDue AI writing assistant — all included.

$1 full access trial
130,000+ paper examples AI writing assistant included Citation generator Cancel anytime
Sources Used in This Paper
source cited in this paper
12 sources cited in this paper
Sign up to view the full reference list — includes live links and archived copies where available.
Cite This Paper
"Guns Germs And Steel The" (2005, March 03) Retrieved April 21, 2026, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/guns-germs-and-steel-the-62780

Always verify citation format against your institution's current style guide.

80% of this paper shown 1308 words remaining