Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
¶ … Love Expressed in Shakespeare's "Sonnet 116" and Dryden's "Why Should a Foolish Marriage Vow"
Love means different things to different people. Two poems that illustrate how opinions change depending on the stages of love are William Shakespeare's "Sonnet 116" and John Dryden's "Why Should a Foolish Marriage Vow."
These poems are love poems but they express two different attitudes toward love. "Sonnet 116" expresses the positive side of love, focusing on its strength and importance. On the other hand, "Why Should a Foolish Marriage Vow" conveys the "other" side of love - the side of love that feels old and stale. While both poets believe in love, they are at opposite ends of the spectrum in regards to how love affects them.
Both poems explore the idea of marriage but the similarities end there. In "Sonnet 116," the poet speaks positively of love, introducing us to a metaphor or marriage stating that it is a "marriage of true minds" (Shakespeare 1), indicating that the poet believes he has found his soul mate. The poet also refers to love as an "ever-fixed mark" (5), meaning that his love never waxes or wanes. In addition, it is the "star to every wandering bark" (7). In "Why Should a Foolish Marriage Vow," the poet claims that marriage is "foolish" (Dryden 1). He also wonders why two people should honor a vow that was made "long ago" (2). In addition, the poet wonders why two people should remain married "When passion is decay'd" (4). Here we see two very different points-of-view regarding love. Love may seem strong to the poet in "Sonnet 116" but it far from that in "Why Should a Foolish Marriage Vow." While the poet in "Sonnet 116" experiences a love that is "never shaken" (Shakespeare 6) and is not "Time's fool" (9), the poet in "Why Should a Foolish Marriage Vow" declares that love and marriage are nothing more than "madness" (Dryden 13). Love is real but love can change.
Sonnet 116" and "Why Should a Foolish Marriage Vow" offers different points-of-view when it comes to love. One poet is happy in love and one poet is unhappy and bound to the ties of marriage.
Works Cited
Shakespeare, William. "Sonnet 116." Shakespeare for Lovers. New York: Carol Publishing Group. 1995.
Dryden, John. "Why Should a Foolish Marriage Vow." Poets.org. Online. http://www.poets.org/viewmedia.php/prmMID/16824Site Accessed March 09, 2008.
The ironic twist is the play of what is to be expected to be said and what is actually said (or, going back to the argument, what is expected from love and what actually occurs): It begins: "My mistress' eyes are nothing like the sun; / Coral is far more red than her lips' red" From here the sonnet continues with a much less pleasing list of the qualities about
Of all Shakepeare's works, sonnets seem best to portray this word marriage from past and present. Not only do the words and style of the sonnet show this transition of time, but the era in which it was created was a great transitory time as well. Gutenberg had invented the printing press over a hundred years previous, but the full benefits of that marvelous invention had just begun to be felt
..come kiss me, sweet and twenty,/Youth's a stuff will not endure." Although the singer of "O Mistress Mine" is equally aware as the author of Sonnet 18 that life is not forever, and we must love while we can, his attitude is not to make sense of this by trying to create something permanent in the form of a poem, but to entertain and achieve an objective of a kiss! Life
Thus, Shakespeare's poems have shown that they deal with timeless topics, topics that have proved their worth over time, such as love, passion, and writing. Throughout time, however, Shakespeare's reputation of a writer did, indeed, change. While he was known as a businessman and patron of the arts during his life, it is suspected that he was not celebrated for his masterful writing until after his death ("Shakespeare Biography"). Today,
Greeenblatt also points out that to truly grasp the meaning of the poem and the transience alluded to therein, readers must consider the social code for homosexual love. The Church did not tolerate sodomy and it would make sense that men would be attracted to other men considering how women were often treated as lower-class citizens. Through this "seesaw game of acknowledgment and denial" (253), Shakespeare "stages his sexual
Shakespeare's Sonnets 18, 73, 97 Poets have often looked to nature for inspiration and as a vehicle for self-expression. Throughout his lifetime, William Shakespeare is known to have written 154 sonnets, which cover various topics such as love, mortality, and the passage of time. Of these sonnets, sonnet numbers 18, 73, and 97 incorporate seasonal symbols that allow Shakespeare to express his love, the passage of time and its effect on