Marbury V Madison Case Essay

PAGES
3
WORDS
931
Cite

Legal Issues Presented

With regard to deciding the Marbury v. Madison case, Chief Justice John Marshall faced the following three legal challenges. Firstly, was the petitioner entitled to the said writ? Secondly, did American laws permit the granting of this sort of writ to Marbury? Lastly, if the answer to the second question was in the affirmative, could this sort of writ be issued by the US Supreme Court?

With respect to the very first issue raised, the Chief Justice held that the petitioner had been appointed appropriately according to legally-set down procedures, thus being entitled to this writ. Furthermore, owing to the petitioner's legal entitlement to the commission, he should be offered a remedy by the law. Marshall further stated that the courts were especially duty-bound to safeguard citizens' rights -- even if it was against the nation's president himself. At that time, his ill-disguised reprimanding of President Thomas Jefferson regarding the rule of law proved a lot more controversial compared to his proclamation regarding judicial review (a doctrine that was commonly accepted).

When it came to resolving the last question (i.e., was it the right remedy for the US Supreme Court to issue the 'mandamus' writ?), the Chief Justice tackled the judicial review issue. He held that it wasn't permissible for the US Supreme Court to grant this writ as the 1789 Judiciary Act's 13th section, which authorizes this, was unconstitutional to the extent...
...

Original jurisdiction or the authority of directly bringing cases to the US Supreme Court represented the sole jurisdictional issue the American Constitution itself addressed. Article III ordains that it is only applicable to cases wherein the government is a party and that impact public ministers such as consuls and ambassadors. By broadening the original jurisdiction of the Court for incorporating Marbury v. Madison and similar cases, the Congress had gone above its authority. The Chief Justice claimed that when a Congressional decision contradicted the Constitution, the Court was duty-bound to support the Constitution as the 6th Article establishes that it is America's "supreme law."

How this Case Essentially Created the Supreme Court of the United States



The act of establishing America's judicial courts permits issuance of mandamus writs by the US Supreme Court, in instances that are warranted by law usage and principles, to all courts established, or individuals with authority, by US governmental permission (Marbury v. Madison, 1803).

Absolute judicial power in America is constitutionally granted to the Supreme Court, as well as other lower courts ordained and established by the Congress occasionally. This authority is specifically extended to every case that arises under American laws, and hence can, in a way, be exerted over the current case, as the claimed right is accorded by an American…

Cite this Document:

"Marbury V Madison Case" (2017, January 19) Retrieved April 25, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/marbury-v-madison-case-essay-2167925

"Marbury V Madison Case" 19 January 2017. Web.25 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/marbury-v-madison-case-essay-2167925>

"Marbury V Madison Case", 19 January 2017, Accessed.25 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/marbury-v-madison-case-essay-2167925

Related Documents
Marbury Vs Madison 1803
PAGES 2 WORDS 855

Marbury v. Madison case is a Supreme Court case that is studied due to its legal and historical significance. In the United States, this is the pioneering as well as most influential legal proceedings ever experienced. The case was the first one of that kind as it looked into the administrative that has been classified given that the law involves all interactions involving the Federal Government (Law.com, 2015). A Federalist, President

Marbury v. Madison legal case involved a divergence between William Marbury and James Madison on account of how the latter did not act in agreement with former (he finished his term before Madison was appointed Secretary of State) President John Adams' command to deliver several appointments naming Federal circuit judges and Federalist justices. Madison did not act on this command because he was under the power of the newly

Marbury v. Madison Facts of the case What were the circumstances of Marbury v. Madison in 1803? Why do some scholars and historians refer to Marbury v. Madison as among the most important cases to ever come before the United States Supreme Court? This paper covers the issues surrounding this case, presenting the facts and scholarship relating to the case as well. Facts of the case This was the first case to reach the

Chief Justice Marshall uses the Marbury decision to make a landmark case on the power of the courts, and does so based not on specific articles within the Constitution, but on his perception of what his belief and perception of the power of the Courts and thus the Constitution should be. He believes that the character of the Constitution in this case is defining the right of the Supreme Court to judicially review federal legislation

Marbury V. Madison Is an
PAGES 8 WORDS 2297

The Constitution gave the Supreme Court the responsibility to uphold the Constitution as the "Supreme Law of the Land," that is, supreme against Federal laws and State laws. Although each State had its own State Constitution and a Judiciary tasked with upholding the Constitution, State laws that violated the Federal Constitution could be overturned by a Federal court. The Power of the Judiciary Relative the Legislative and Executive Branches The Framers

Marbury v. Madison was a case between William Marbury and James Madison in 1803, which sparked one of the most important decisions made in American history. The case itself has actually enabled the Supreme Court to declare an act of law unconstitutional. Marbury v. Madison also further established the idea of judicial review within the United States, allowing the courts some power in nullifying the decisions of one branch of