Non-Modular And Modular Views Of Essay

PAGES
1
WORDS
372
Cite
Related Topics:

Non-Modular and Modular Views of Language

Whether language is modular is a debate for a lot of people. The two schools of thought say that (a) language is modular in that it is separate from other cognitive processes, and (b) language is non-modular in that it is a product of various cognitive processes (Robinson-Riegler & Robinson, Riegler, 2008). It cannot really be both, however, so determining which one it is seems to be very important. Unfortunately for the people who want the issue resolved, there is no definitive test or experiment that can be done to clear the matter up. It remains opinion. Personally, I think that the modular opinion is the most accurate, although I'm not sure that either option is 100% correct. The experiments that were done with music, though, showed that there were two different issues appearing when it came to whether people noticed a wrong word, a wrong note, or both (Robinson-Riegler & Robinson, Riegler, 2008). Because two different indicators appeared when there was both a wrong note and a wrong word, it would be difficult to say that there was nothing modular going on.

If language was not modular, it would be expected that there would have been a blending of the 'wrongness' of the music and the words, instead of having such a definite, noticeable difference between the two of them. That does not guarantee that language is modular, of course, but it sheds light on the issue and gives me the impression that there is more to it than many people realize. There are some concerns with both sides of the coin, though, so I have not completely decided that I am convinced that either side has everything figured out. The answer to the question probably lies somewhere in the middle, in that some components of learning language might be modular while other components might not be. Language is very complex in itself, and the human mind is even more complex, so it would be very unlikely that we would understand all of it no matter how many tests we do or how many opinions we form.

Bibliography

Robinson-Riegler, G., & Robinson-Riegler, B. (2008). Cognitive psychology: Applying the science of the mind. 2nd ed. New York: Allyn & Bacon.

Cite this Document:

"Non-Modular And Modular Views Of" (2009, August 21) Retrieved April 27, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/non-modular-and-modular-views-of-19846

"Non-Modular And Modular Views Of" 21 August 2009. Web.27 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/non-modular-and-modular-views-of-19846>

"Non-Modular And Modular Views Of", 21 August 2009, Accessed.27 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/non-modular-and-modular-views-of-19846

Related Documents

The panels could also be assembled quickly often within a day. Some panels have an in-built wiring in them making the housing construction to be faster. The panelized off-site building technologies could also involve exterior wall of building designed to provide the load bearing structural support, and the panelized building system could be made of light gauge steel, timber, structural insulated panels (SIPs), non-structural or concrete, which could be

Fodor Since the Beginning of
PAGES 20 WORDS 6299

This sort of outlook fits well into Fodor's driving point regarding psychology: human behaviors can be understood as valid arguments relating intentional states of mind. In physics, when observable phenomena disagree with our understanding of the rules governing the physical world, it is not assumed that some other mystical force is at work -- merely that our observations or concepts concerning physics must somehow be mistaken in that specific

2002). This paper's focus will be on the CPM and PERT methodologies. The Rockfest event has 26 tasks, each conveniently denoted by a letter in the alphabet. Having drawn up the Critical Path and analyzed it, I found the following. The Critical Path starts with task A, continues with B, D, E, F, G, and finally O. The time it takes to complete these tasks is 34 weeks. That is

Change This study analyzes outsourcing trends in the next decade. The study assesses this by focusing on the past and current trends, problems and issues in outsourcing via semi-structured interviews. Major trends and processes will be revealed and assessed for their relevancy, depth and breadth. Companies belonging to most industries are very much considered to be the units that are vertically integrated, or so-called usual industrial firms (Stigler, 1951), where activities

Business Cycles The Keynesian approach to recessionary gaps is to increase government spending and lower taxes -- run a deficit -- in order to spur aggregate demand. In the Keynesian model, aggregate demand is affected by a number of different factors -- consumer consumption, business investment, government spending and net exports. During a recessionary gap, consumer spending and business investment are probably both down, which leaves the other two factors to

Cross Platform Mobile and Web
PAGES 63 WORDS 17284

82). Both desktop and Web widgets have the same basic components. Fundamentally, they use Web compatible formats, even if intended to run in a desktop environment. This means that the core of the widget is HTML and CSS code which contains the actual content of the widget, namely text, linked images/video or content pulled from a server of Web service. Alternatively, the widget content can be created using Flash, although