Obtaining Informed Consent In Ontario Essay

Length: 7 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Medical  (general) Type: Essay Paper: #57228042
Excerpt from Essay :

Latha (2010) notes, "Legally, treatment without consent is permissible only where common law or statute provides such authority" (p. 96) and in the case of the schizophrenic patient who refuses to take the prescribed medication the question comes down to whether the person is legally capable of making a decision. If so, then he has every right to refuse treatment; if not, treatment may be given him. This is the essence of the Health Care Consent Act, which is used to determine whether such a person as the schizophrenic patient is capable of deciding for himself (Downie, Caulfield, Flood, 2011).

The two questions that must be asked with regards to the Health Care Consent Act are: 1) Is the person capable or able of understanding the data that is relevant to his making a decision regarding treatment? 2) Is the person capable or able of appreciating the likely consequences of refusing or accepting treatment? (Health Care Consent Act, 1996).

If the person is able of doing both then that person is deemed capable of making a decision on his own and the state or hospital may not give him treatment against his will. Thus, in the case of the schizophrenic patient who refuses treatment, the measure of whether treatment can be forcefully given him depends on how these two questions are answered. To give him treatment against his will if he is able to understand the information and appreciate the consequences of actions would be to violate the Health Care Consent Act.

However, if the patient is unable to process the information given him about how to make a decision regarding information or if the patient fails to appreciate the consequences of refusing or taking treatment, then the person may be deemed incompetent and treatment may be given him against his will. In these cases, even if the patient has decided in the past to not take the treatment, his incompetence will allow medical professionals the right to administer treatment if they deem that it is for his own and for society's safety.

Thus, the issue at the heart of this process is the matter of whether the patient is deemed competent to understand the issues regarding his illness and potential treatment. The Health Care Consent Act provides the framework by which this assessment may be made and the law is required to stand by that assessment. To the extent that the patient is able to make an informed decision, the law must respect that right.

A schizophrenic patient who is, however, unable to process the information and is clearly unfit to make decisions regarding his safety and the safety of others cannot be expected to act rationally or with sound judgment. In these cases, the condition of the patient is to be something that the


In these cases, the rights of the patient are placed in the care of the professional care provider because it is deemed that the patient cannot be held accountable for his or her own decision-making processes.


Information regarding patient care that is reviewed for quality assurance purposes is protected both by information access and privacy legislation in Ontario and by common law across all Canada. Specifically, it is protected by a number of Acts. For instance, there is the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) that is a federal law impacting all parts of Canada and serves to protect personal information from being shared. There is also the Quality Care Information Protection Act, which is Ontario law and which "protects the quality assurance/peer review process only if it is conducted by or for a hospital committee designated specifically as a quality of care committee to carry out the functions described by QCIPA" (OHA, 2004).

Additionally, as Cranston and Rozmus (2015) have indicated, "courts have recognized the importance of protecting QA-type records at common law" levels and this is evident in the Supreme Court case Slavutych v. Baker (1976) in which it was decided that the confidentiality is essential in all communications. However, as the Ontario Superior Court decided in Steep v. Scott (2002), "the goal of improving the quality of health care and health services ahead of any litigation advantage that may accrue to a party by the use of QA-type records" is given precedent (Cranston, Rozmus, 2015, p. 2). Thus, while laws and court rulings do exist, the basic concept of balancing health assurance with privacy rights is one that is constantly being monitored and re-assessed in Ontario.

The aim of this balancing act is to allow and encourage health care providers to learn about and improve upon the ways in which quality assurance can be delivered and to use data to make the situation better continuously. At the same time, the goal is to prevent negligence and respect patient rights and allow injured parties to pursue legal recourse. Privacy rights do matter in Ontario just as much as quality assurance concerns do. The laws that have developed by in Ontario and throughout Canada that are used to reflect this need to balance both portions of this societal issue are evidence that the topic is not easily navigated or maneuvered in every instance or occasion (Downie, Caulfield, Flood, 2011).

Thus, it is necessary to protect quality assurance information to ensure the full involvement of health professionals in the process of quality improvement -- but it is also important to protect the rights of patients and prevent negligence from occurring, allowing them legal recourse. The nature of the issue is such that every case must be examined and the facts made to come to light in order to make a decision in favor of health care professionals or patients. There is no simple solution or sweeping legislation that can serve as a general rule for every case.


The case of Hassan Rasouli is one court case that has addressed the issue of who should have final say with respect to the…

Cite this Document:

"Obtaining Informed Consent In Ontario" (2016, October 03) Retrieved April 17, 2021, from

"Obtaining Informed Consent In Ontario" 03 October 2016. Web.17 April. 2021. <

"Obtaining Informed Consent In Ontario", 03 October 2016, Accessed.17 April. 2021,

Related Documents
Thematic Analysis of Security Issues
Words: 20201 Length: 78 Pages Topic: Recreation Paper #: 25267847

Security Study Travel and tourism are major industries in European countries such as Greece. The hotel industry is dedicated to making the accommodations for their patrons as enjoyable as possible. This means ensuring that hotel guests, visitors, and staff have a safe and secure environment. It is for this reason that many of the larger hotel chains have their own private security personnel who are entrusted to maintain the safety of

Resolving Clinical Ethical Dilemma
Words: 1424 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 88202580

Ethical Dilemma- A Framework Ethical Dilemma Taking into account ethical concerns is one of the key components in providing healthcare in the therapeutic nurse-patient relationship (Rosenbaum, 1982). Nurses face ethical uncertainty, distress and conflict in their day-to-day work. When more than one ethical value applies to a particular case, and all of them recommend following a different course of action, then an ethical dilemma exists in such a case a nurse would

Contexts for Managing Depression and Its Stigma
Words: 503 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Sports - Women Paper #: 14805500

Contexts for Managing Depression and its Stigma among Black West Indian Canadian Women This qualitative study by Schreiber, Noerager, and Wilson (1998) was conducted to ascertain the depression experiences of black West Indian women living in Canada in order to inform clinical practice (p. 511). The authors note there is a lack of research to assist nurses and other healthcare providers in knowing how to meet the specific needs women

Master in Quality & Safety
Words: 6426 Length: 14 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 5751190

This particular aspect is what most medical trainers miss when dealing with interns or newly appointed nurses. They found that oxygen use, if below the necessary requirement can be damaging, so can its overuse. In another study, it has been found that using oxygen below the prescribed level can instigate damage in the organs, respiratory structures and can be especially damaging for patients who have chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

Therapeutic Cloning
Words: 2537 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Genetics Paper #: 37788280

Therapeutic Cloning Recent years have seen intense debate on the ethicality of human cloning and therapeutic cloning. While the former involves reproduction of a new human (clone to the adult from whom the DNA was taken), therapeutic cloning has a very different goal. Having said that, therapeutic cloning, too, has been under the spotlight. This paper's purpose is to focus on therapeutic cloning alone and explore the possible pros and cons

Words: 10745 Length: 30 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 90713233

It will focus discovering the treatment option, or combination of options that results in the lowest incidence of recidivism for the longest period following the treatment. It is difficult to predict future events, therefore the research will take a historical perspective on the problem. This study will compare recidivism rates for the four most common treatments used for pedophile offenders. It will only consider treatment for those that were convicted