Political Scandals In Canada A Political Scandal Essay

Length: 6 pages Sources: 6 Subject: Government Type: Essay Paper: #96003351 Related Topics: Bribery, White Heron, Political Issues, Canada
Excerpt from Essay :

Political Scandals in Canada

A Political Scandal Involving Fraud

During the federal election in Canada in 2011 there was an electoral fraud issue that became known as the "Robocalls Scandal." This fraudulent activity took place in Ontario, in a town called Guelph.

Robocalls are previously recorded and automated phone calls to people from a computer that is programmed to call all phone numbers in a given area; usually robocalls carry a political message asking voters to behave a certain way.

In this case in Canada, the fraud took place because the robocalls were not from the organization they claimed to be from. People receiving the phone calls believed the calls were from the official group, "Elections Canada" but they were not from Elections Canada. The robocalls told voters their polling location had changed, and urged them to go to another place to vote that turned out to be a fraud.

Liberals are accusing conservatives for being behind the calls. "Under the Elections Act, it is illegal to tell voters to go to a wrong or non-existent polling station" (Stechyson, 2012).

The person who made the calls used a "disposable cellphone" registered to a "Pierre Poutine," and he used the group RackNine to mass-produce the calls.

A Political Scandal Involving Bribery

In Montreal there was a scandal involving bribery with three former Canada Revenue Agency employees, Francesco Fazio, Elias Kawkab, and Luigi Falcone. The allegations against the three is that while working for the Canada Revenue Agency they took bribes to help individuals pay overdue tax bills, according to Brian Daley writing for the QMI Agency.

Reportedly, a Montreal restaurant owner was offered a deal in 2005; if he gave an agency worker $90,000 his tax bill would be dramatically reduced (a bribe). Another restaurant owner in Montreal gave $100,000 in bribe money to a Canada Revenue Agency employee in turn for the agency hiding this restaurant owner's "…black market income" (Daly, 2012).

One of the reasons this is political in substance is that the Canada Revenue Agency "…admitted it fired six employees and suspended three others without pay for misconduct," however these employees should have been charged with crimes and prosecuted under Canadian law, not just fired or suspended.

A Political Scandal Involving Perjury

The Boots and Breeches scandal in 1942 was a case that involved perjury. The government had paid for 4,905 pair of boots for Canadian soldiers in WWII; those boots were paid for between March 1, 1938, and December 15, 1941. However the quartermaster's book showed just 3,710 pairs (Rayner, 2001, pp. 162-63). There were fake invoices to cover the tracks of the guilty persons, and a "full-fledged political scandal erupted over the 'slush fund' testimony," Rayner writes. The key individual in the middle of the scandal, Constable Leonard said he was asked by the auditor, George Marshall, to type a letter "…purporting to explain why stock book entries and statements in the public accounts did not match" (Rayner). That is perjury, and the two men responsible were sentences to prison sentences.

A Political Scandal Involving Patronage

The Pacific Scandal in 1873 actually caused the collapse of the Conservative government of Sir. John A. Macdonald. The issue revolved around Macdonald and the conservatives accepting $350,000 from Sir. Hugh Allan during the election in 1872. Why accept that money? It was in turn for a promise of patronage -- that is, Macdonald's government would give Allan the opportunity to build the Canadian Pacific Railway. This was not a bribe, but rather it was based on political patronage.

A Political Scandal Involving Nepotism

Actually the scandal involving RCMP Commissioner Giuliano Zaccardelli was not based specifically on nepotism; it was based on abuses "…of pension and insurance plans" but it was also based on "nepotism, waste and bypassing of controls by management" (Styky, 2007). The commissioner was accused of a cover-up of a scandal involving the mismanagement of funds, which was a serious embarrassment for the top cop of Canada, and for the nation itself.

A Political Scandal Involving Influence Peddling

Former senior aide to the Prime Minister Stephen Harper was charged earlier in 2012 with "influence peddling" by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (Radia, 2012). It has been charged that Bruce Carson attempted to get his fiancee (reportedly a former "escort") a job selling water...


The law prohibits a former political staff person to refrain from lobbying the government for five years once having left the position. Apparently Carson also lobbied the Natural Resources department for funding for a client.

PART TWO: Does the personal sexual behavior of public persons really matter?

What an elected official does in his or her own bedroom should be none of the public's business. Most people would agree to that statement. They would agree unless, that is, there is more than a hint of political skullduggery or improper behavior between the two consenting adults. Or if the person involved in the sexual activity is married and his sexual trysts are with an expensive hooker; in the matter of former New York governor Eliot Spitzer, his lies to his wife and the specter of him spending thousands on a one-night stand with an expensive prostitute led him to immediately step down from his elected position.

Another example U.S. President Bill Clinton having sexual relations (of one kind or the other) with an intern in the White House Oval Office. That was clearly improper and it presented a wildly over-blown response from the media. It even ended up with an attempt to impeach Clinton. What Clinton was accused of offered the conservatives in Congress with an ideal opportunity to attack Clinton and attempt to have him removed from office.

Minnesota Public Radio (MPR News) asked the pertinent question: "Why should the public care about a politician's private life?" And the result was a number of responses on their website that are worth noting in this paper.

Debra Hannu of Duluth, MN, wrote that "…You could have the world's greatest leader with marital issues, or you could have a dangerous fascist with the perfect family -- which would YOU want as leader?" (MPR News). That is a very good point; no one is perfect and if the elected leader has otherwise provide good behavior and has acted in the public's best interest, his private life should not matter.

Michael Miles of Victoria, MN wrote: "Unless they are taking money from somebody who will be affected by their decisions I couldn't care less."

Jerry Ewing of Apple Valley MN explained: "The public should not care at all, except as it affects the politician's public life. Paying a prostitute with taxpayer money, leaving one's office unmanaged, or contracting a venereal disease are all detriments to the job the taxpayers hired you to do."

Rae Mathias of Heron Lake, MN wrote: "Knowing things about a politician's private life often shows blazing hypocrisy. An anti-gay rights politician who is a closet gay. A moral, religious, self-righteous politician who takes money under the table or cheats on his wife. Doesn't that reflect on his public responsibilities as well?"

Doug Campbell in Bloomington, MN, explained his feelings on the subject: "We are who we are. If we are a liar and a cheat in our 'private life' why should anyone expect us to behave differently in our public lives? The public needs to be able to trust their elected representatives, and actions do matter."

The bizarre, incredibly complicated case of Associate Chief Justice Lori Douglass is a case in which the public has every right to know what happened. When a high-ranking judge has sexually explicit photos on the Internet, no matter how they got there or why, that is a major deviation from the public trust that the public has a right to expect. Did Douglass sexually harass Alexander Chapman in 2003? Did Douglass' husband Jack King give naked photos to Chapman (which would have been brutally damaging to the reputation of an associate chief justice) and moreover, what happened in march of 2009 when King allegedly arrange to have Chapman and King's wife, the justice, get together for some sex?

In any event, these activities are clearly immoral and for Douglass to be part of this corrupt charade -- whatever her involvement -- is not just a public relations disaster for the system of justice in Canada. It is a horrendous violation of the public trust.

In a peer-reviewed article in the journal Public, Private and the Media, journalist Jean Seaton asks a number of questions relevant to this issue. For example, on page 174 Seaton asks, "…to what extent is the public appetite for the destruction of reputation (of individuals but also of institutions) led, or merely fed by the media?" She also asks, "…is it possible to sustain any notion of intimacy in which the precious diversity of individuals is treasured in the light of brutal media exposure and authoritarian regimentation of private lives?"

Seaton comes to the defense of the media by…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Daly, Brian. (2012). Bribery scandal rocks Canada Revenue. News Canada. Retrieve August

12, 2012, from http://www.saultstar.com.

MPR News. (2009). Why should the public care about a politician's private life? Retrieved

August 12, 2012, from http://minnesota.publicradio.org.

Cite this Document:

"Political Scandals In Canada A Political Scandal" (2012, August 12) Retrieved June 16, 2021, from

"Political Scandals In Canada A Political Scandal" 12 August 2012. Web.16 June. 2021. <

"Political Scandals In Canada A Political Scandal", 12 August 2012, Accessed.16 June. 2021,

Related Documents
Financial Crisis in Canada Is
Words: 4978 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 4870867

The partisan politics seen south of the border would be impossible, because the resulting inaction would be viewed unfavorably by Canadians. The financial crisis has damaged Canada economically, but it has also highlighted the value of financial conservatism. Canada's handling of the crisis has improved its standing in the world. The Canadian banking system has been lauded for its conservative nature. Further esteem has been brought to the government for

Pharmaceuticals Industry Political and Social
Words: 1647 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 25083407

There are two constant irritations in U.S. pharma companies' relationships internationally: Some developing nations, such as India, Brazil and South Africa, are chipping away at the patent situation, trying to shorten the time until the drugs can be brought out in generic form. The U.S. has supported high prices as the cost for innovation. Since other countries are not playing along, this means that their citizens are benefiting from the innovation paid

SWOT Analysis of Canada World Youth
Words: 1565 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Child Abuse Paper #: 71959438

Child Abuse, Organization Canada World Youth, 2017 Conduct a SWOT analysis. A SWOT analysis of Canada World Youth (CWY) is provided in Table 1 below. SWOT analysis of Canada World Youth SWOT category Description Strengths (internal) • The organization has a proven 40-year track record of success in working with youth groups. • CWY has developed an extensive network of international partnerships. • CWY has an influential patron (the Governor General of Canada since March 2012), a strong management

Union Labor Disputes Canada Wal-Mart
Words: 6077 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 74391495

But when it just recently occurred in 2004 at a store in Jonquiere, British Columbia, the reader must appreciate that a real battle had been won. The original efforts of that particular store for example had the local labor Commission reject certification by a margin of 74 to 65. When the union announced that it won the coveted certification at Quebec, it was quite a blow to the retailer.

Marketing in Germany With Marketing in the
Words: 1435 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Business - Advertising Paper #: 22146541

marketing in Germany with marketing in the United States. The United States Department of State provides cultural, political, economic and other information regarding the marketing opportunities in Germany. The www.export.gov site explains that Germany is currently the fourth largest economy in the world and it accounts for "…more than one-fifth of European Union GDP" (www.export.gov). Germany is in fact the largest trading partner in Europe for the U.S., and Germany

Policy Recommendation for TSA Privatization and Collaboration
Words: 8019 Length: 27 Pages Topic: Political Science Paper #: 71841725

Policy Recommendation for Collaboration and TSA Privatization The objective of this study is to evaluate the benefits of collaboration between the federal government and non-profit organizations. The study cites different examples of collaborations across the world and their achievements. Moreover, the paper investigates whether it is beneficial to privatize the TSA (Transportation Security Administration) since the organization has performed below the international standards in the last few years. Finally, the study