Paramilitary Model of Policing: Benefits and Limitations
This paper evaluates the paramilitary model of modern policing, exploring how its military-style hierarchy and discipline can strengthen police departments while also generating significant limitations. The paper examines the chain-of-command structure, the ethical expectations placed on officers, and the model's capacity to foster unity and confidence within a department. It then addresses key drawbacks—including the potential for community alienation, reduced officer autonomy, attraction of the wrong type of recruit, and the marginalization of community voices. The paper argues that these risks make a complementary community policing model necessary to balance discipline with genuine public service orientation and accountability.
- Introduction to the Paramilitary Model: Overview of the paramilitary model and its core purpose
- Chain of Command and Organizational Discipline: Hierarchical structure, unity, and officer conduct standards
- Ethical Standards and Officer Accountability: Benefits of discipline, ethics, and community trust
- Limitations and Community Impact: Power abuse risks, community alienation, and wrong recruits
- The Case for Community Policing: Community policing as a corrective to paramilitary drawbacks
- Conclusion: Dual-model recommendation balancing discipline and community engagement
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper presents a balanced argument — it acknowledges genuine strengths of the paramilitary model before systematically identifying its limitations, avoiding one-sided advocacy.
- Concrete examples, such as the Arizona officer incident, ground abstract policy arguments in real-world cases that illustrate the human stakes of organizational model choices.
- The paper sustains a clear thesis throughout: the paramilitary model is valuable but incomplete, and must be paired with community policing to address its shortcomings.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective comparative analysis by setting the paramilitary and community policing models against each other across multiple dimensions — structure, community perception, officer decision-making, and recruitment outcomes — rather than treating either model in isolation. This side-by-side evaluation builds a nuanced argument that neither wholly endorses nor rejects either approach.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a thesis framing both models, then moves through a detailed description of the paramilitary model's structure and discipline, followed by its ethical demands on officers. It pivots to limitations — organizational rigidity, community fear, and problematic recruitment — before making an affirmative case for community policing as a corrective. The conclusion synthesizes both sides and restates the dual-model recommendation.
Introduction to the Paramilitary Model
The paramilitary model of policing incorporates a military-grade level of discipline into the ranks of the police so that officers maintain better use of force at all times. The goal of this model is to help officers become more disciplined public servants who are self-possessed yet fully equipped to restore order when public disturbances threaten to turn chaotic or violent (Potter, 2013). While the paramilitary model of policing certainly has its benefits, it also has significant limitations — particularly when it comes to the differences between police work and military work. It should be remembered that soldiers are tasked with engaging an enemy, while the police are tasked with serving and protecting the public.
The militarization of the police can give communities the wrong impression that they are being occupied by a militarized force rather than served and protected by a department that truly has their best interests at heart. This perception is especially likely when police departments begin purchasing military-grade equipment directly from the military. A community policing model should therefore be implemented alongside the paramilitary model to keep a police department balanced. The paramilitary model can provide the discipline officers need, while the community policing model can give police the appropriate orientation they should have toward the community.
References
Cruickshank, D. (2013). Evaluating the paramilitary structure and morale. Retrieved from
Friedersdorf, C. (2017). Footage of police shooting that jurors chose not to punish. Retrieved from https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/12/footage-of-a-police-killing-that-jurors-didnt-punish/547868/
Greene, J. R. (2000). Community policing in America: Changing the nature, structure, and function of the police. Criminal Justice, 3(3), 299–370.
Potter, G. (2013). The organization of policing. Retrieved from http://plsonline.eku.edu/insidelook/organization-policing
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.