Question A: If I Was Thesis

PAGES
1
WORDS
388
Cite

QUESTION A:

If I was to receive a summons or draft notice instructing me to
report for active duty and as a result end up being deployed to Iraq, my
first reaction would undoubtedly be one of shock and dismay, due to
believing that the war in Iraq is an immoral action and all those who fight
in this war are supporting immorality. Also, I would be forced to state
that the war in Iraq is an unjust war which should be halted immediately so
that the troops can be sent home where they belong with their friends and
families.
However, when considering what Socrates has to say about
disobedience, justice and injustice, my initial position on being drafted
to fight in Iraq would have to be re-examined. For example, in his Apology,
Socrates maintains that "the only opinion that counts is not that of the
majority (i.e., the U.S. military). . . but rather that of the. . .
individual," but Socrates also declares that the individual "ought never do
wrong. . . (and) it is always wrong to disobey the state. Hence, one should
never disobey the state" (Kemerling, Internet). Thus, in the eyes of
Socrates, it would be wrong to disobey the orders of the U.S. military in
regards to being drafted and sent to Iraq despite having strong personal
objections to the war.
But then again, Socrates clearly believed that just behavior, in this
case refusing to be drafted and deployed to Iraq, is better for human
beings than injustice and that morality is justified because it creates
happiness and well-being for the individual. Also, Socrates firmly held the
belief that justice will inevitably lead an individual to choose good over
evil, in this case, the good being my refusal to fight in Iraq and the evil
being the draft notice. In the end, however, I would be forced to disobey
the state and refuse to be drafted and deployed to Iraq in order to fight
in a war which I personally view as immoral and unjust. This is very much
in line

with what is known as being a conscientious objector or a person who
refuses to fight in a war which he finds immoral or unjustified.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Kemerling, Garth. "Socrates: Philosophical Life." Philosophy Pages.
Internet. Retrieved
January 14, 2009 from http://www.philosophypages.com/hy/2d.htm.

Cite this Document:

"Question A If I Was" (2009, January 14) Retrieved April 20, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/question-a-if-i-was-25454

"Question A If I Was" 14 January 2009. Web.20 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/question-a-if-i-was-25454>

"Question A If I Was", 14 January 2009, Accessed.20 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/question-a-if-i-was-25454

Related Documents

When productivity decreases, because of higher input costs or a natural disaster that inhibits the production process (for example), aggregate supply will decrease, prices will increase because of scarcity, and demand will decrease. Question 7: Productivity is an important factor in increasing aggregate supply. What are some current trends that might lead to increased productivity? Have you experienced any technological change in your job that greatly affected your productivity? Improved technology, operating procedures, and even better management techniques, can make

Question 1: "The Poem
PAGES 1 WORDS 406

Obviously, some kind of intense action is taking place in the narrative along with music ("What struggle to escape?" "What pipes and timbrels?" "What wild ecstasy?"), perhaps some type of a festival or religious celebration or possibly a sexual orgy. The second scene (lines 11-30) begins with more music ("Ye soft pipes, play on") while some "fair" youths, perhaps blonde-haired like the original Greeks, sit beneath some trees. Line 22 indicates that the narrative is occurring in

Homeostasis is the goal promoted by both positive and negative feedback mechanisms. This is the principle which indicates that there is a balance in autonomic life functions which the body attempts always to maintain. This refers to such features as body temperature, heart rate, respiration and the powering of vital organs. When stimuli create a divergence from this status, the body will activate a set of responses designed to regulate a return to balance. 4. In anatomical

As an inhabitant of the Palestinian land which has since 1967 been occupied by Israeli foreigners, I am deeply and emotionally supportive of peace. My future, the future of my countrymen and our chance for independence all hinge fully upon this support. It is why I view with concern and suspicious any of the offers for peace which are on the closer horizon now that we have moved beyond the destructive extremism of the George

Rousseau is right in this instance, as English people who vote for Members of Parliament can no longer control the actions of their representatives once they are voted to office. Thus, their only recourse to altering the political landscape is the elections. In The Social Contract, Rousseau specifies that "The deputies of the people, therefore, are not and cannot be its representatives," thus reflecting on the fact that Parliament members act on their own behalf and not

Question of Evil One of
PAGES 6 WORDS 1702

Yes, of course. But Hick too is making an important initial assumption here: He is assuming that a test of human goodness is a necessary part of the universe. But this is only the case if one assumes the presence of a certain type of God -- one that demands that people demonstrate their faith and their ability to make the choices that God wants them to make. If