Watson v. Fort Worth Bank & Trust and subjective promotion criteria
✍️ How to write this paper — writing tools ▾
Watson v. Fort Worth Bank & Trust 108 S.Ct. 2777 (1988)
Relevant Case Facts:
After being rejected four times for promotion to a supervisory position at Fort Worth Bank & Trust, an African-American employee (P, the Plaintiff) at Fort Worth Bank & Trust brought a claim under Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act against the bank (D, the defendant). The basis of P's suit was that in assessing P's qualifications for promotion, D used subjective criteria to determine her performance. These included interviews, rating scales and experiential requirements that had not been subjected to scientific validation procedures. D asserted that interviews and rating scales should not be subjected to the validation procedures required in disparate impact cases. D believed it should not be required to show that the criteria used to determine employee qualifications were strictly are job-related under the law, so long as they had not been designed to have an intentionally discriminatory effect.
History:
Historically, the using of unnecessary qualifications have been employed to bar African-Americans from their civil rights, including the use of quizzes and interviews for those attempting to vote.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.