Answer #1
Essay Topic 1: The Ethical Quandary of Nurse Triage Decisions During the COVID-19 Pandemic
Opposing Viewpoints:
Viewpoint A: Nurses must prioritize saving the most lives possible during triage, even if it means sacrificing the chances of others.
Viewpoint B: Nurses have a duty to consider the individual needs and circumstances of each patient, including their age, comorbidities, and personal preferences, when making triage decisions.
Arguments Supporting Viewpoint A:
Triage is a necessary process to allocate scarce resources efficiently during a public health emergency.
By prioritizing patients with the highest chance of survival, nurses can save more lives overall.
Utilitarian principles dictate that the greatest good for the greatest number should prevail.
Arguments Supporting Viewpoint B:
Each person has intrinsic value and should be treated with dignity and respect, regardless of their age or health status.
Nurses are not mere triage machines; they have a duty to care for individual patients to the best of their ability.
Triage decisions should take into account the patient's wishes and preferences, as well as their medical prognoses.
Essay Topic 2: The Impact of COVID-19 on Nurse Staffing and Well-being
Opposing Viewpoints:
Viewpoint A: The COVID-19 pandemic has had a devastating impact on nurse staffing levels and well-being, leading to burnout, compassion fatigue, and moral distress.
Viewpoint B: While the pandemic has certainly presented challenges, the nursing profession has adapted and found ways to mitigate its negative effects on staffing and well-being.
Arguments Supporting Viewpoint A:
The surge in COVID-19 patients has led to increased workload and stress levels for nurses.
Lack of adequate personal protective equipment (PPE) and support from hospital administration has contributed to burnout and compassion fatigue.
Moral distress arises from conflicts between nurses' ethical obligations and the realities of patient care during a pandemic.
Arguments Supporting Viewpoint B:
Hospitals have implemented measures to increase nurse staffing, such as hiring additional personnel and reassigning nurses from other departments.
Nurses have developed coping mechanisms to manage stress and prevent burnout, such as peer support and self-care practices.
The pandemic has also fostered a sense of community and resilience among nurses, who have worked tirelessly to provide care for those in need.
Essay Topic 3: The Role of Nurses in Public Health Education and Vaccine Administration
Opposing Viewpoints:
Viewpoint A: Nurses should play a central role in public health education and vaccine administration, as they are trusted and accessible healthcare providers.
Viewpoint B: Nurses should focus on providing direct patient care and leave public health education and vaccine administration to other healthcare professionals.
Arguments Supporting Viewpoint A:
Nurses have a deep understanding of disease processes and vaccine safety, making them well-equipped to educate the public about COVID-19.
Nurses are often the first point of contact for patients, providing them with an opportunity to receive accurate information and address vaccine concerns.
By administering vaccines, nurses can help increase vaccination rates and protect communities from COVID-19.
Arguments Supporting Viewpoint B:
Nurses already have a heavy workload, and adding on public health education and vaccine administration could further strain their resources.
There are other healthcare professionals, such as public health nurses, who are specifically trained in these areas.
Nurses should prioritize providing direct patient care, as this is their core competency and area of expertise.
Best Answer
