ACA Compliance Strategies for Midwest Education Company
This paper examines how Midwest Education, an American educational materials manufacturer with 416 employees across three divisions, should comply with the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA). Two primary viewpoints are considered: paying the ACA penalty and allowing employees to obtain insurance through state exchanges, or offering a company-sponsored healthcare plan with a two-tiered structure that charges smokers and obese employees higher premiums. The paper evaluates the financial, operational, and human capital implications of each approach, discusses expected outcomes, and proposes a resolution process in which division heads analyze each option from their respective perspectives before the CEO makes a final executive decision.
- Company Overview: Midwest Education: Profile of Midwest Education's divisions, locations, and workforce
- Two ACA Compliance Viewpoints: Pay ACA penalty versus offer tiered employee healthcare plan
- Expected Outcomes of Offering Employee Healthcare Insurance: Morale, productivity, and brand benefits of company-sponsored coverage
- Resolving the Viewpoint Differences: Division-level analysis and CEO decision-making process
- References: Cited academic and case study sources
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its analysis in a concrete business case, providing specific employee counts, cost figures, and divisional structures that make the argument tangible and verifiable.
- It presents two clearly defined and contrasting viewpoints before evaluating outcomes, giving the reader a balanced framework for understanding the trade-offs involved in ACA compliance decisions.
- The resolution section demonstrates practical managerial thinking by recommending a structured, bottom-up analysis process rather than simply declaring one option superior.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper employs a pros-and-cons analytical framework applied to a real business scenario, linking each policy option to the company's stated core values (cost reduction, innovation, and quality enhancement). This technique connects abstract regulatory compliance to organizational strategy, showing how policy decisions must align with a company's broader mission and competitive positioning.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a detailed company profile establishing context, then defines and compares two ACA compliance viewpoints. A dedicated section explores the expected outcomes of the preferred option before a final section proposes a conflict-resolution mechanism. This four-part structure moves logically from description to analysis to prescription, which is well-suited to business case studies at the undergraduate level.
Company Overview: Midwest Education
Midwest Education is an American manufacturer and supplier of educational materials. The company focuses on learning tools and systems used in technology, science, and business classrooms. Midwest also offers manuals, books, videos, hardware, and software used in technology education, business applications, and instructional development. There are three major divisions: the Manufacturing Division, the Transportation, Service, and Maintenance Division, and the Creative Development Division.
The company's headquarters is located in Kansas City, and the manufacturing plant is situated on the outskirts of Kansas City. The Transportation, Service, and Maintenance Division has its headquarters in Texas, with additional branches in Phoenix and Baltimore. The Creative Development Division is located in Massachusetts and California. Overall, the company has 416 employees spread across the three major divisions: the Manufacturing Division has 158 employees, the Creative Development Division has 123 employees, and the Transportation, Service, and Maintenance Division has 135 employees (Fischer, 2013). An additional 71 employees work at the Kansas City headquarters.
The key values of the company are cost reduction, innovation, and quality enhancement. Each division exemplifies one of these values: the Creative Development Division exemplifies innovation, the Manufacturing Division exemplifies quality enhancement, and the Transportation, Service, and Maintenance Division exemplifies cost reduction.
Two ACA Compliance Viewpoints
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act presents Midwest Education with a compliance decision that involves weighing two distinct viewpoints. The first viewpoint is for the company to pay the penalty of $2,000 (minus 30 employees) and allow employees to source their own insurance through state exchanges. The second viewpoint is for the company to offer healthcare insurance but implement a two-tiered program in which certain employees pay more due to lifestyle choices such as smoking or obesity.
Because the company is focused on cost-cutting, the first option — paying the penalty — is initially appealing, as it is cheaper than sourcing and paying for healthcare insurance for all employees. Paying the penalty reduces the company's overall expenditure while still keeping it in compliance with the healthcare act. The company's current insurance cost is approximately $10,000 per employee; by paying the penalty instead, the company would save roughly $8,000 per employee, resulting in a substantially more favorable operating cost position.
However, the disadvantage of this option is that the company risks losing some of its best talent. As the Creative Development Division heads have noted, it is difficult to compete with Silicon Valley companies that offer comprehensive benefits to their employees. Cost-cutting in this manner could result in employees leaving, and attracting new hires would become increasingly difficult if Midwest Education's benefits package is not competitive with what other employers offer (Hofmeister et al., 2017).
The second viewpoint — sourcing and offering employees healthcare insurance with certain restrictions — requires the company to create a program where smokers and obese employees pay higher premiums. The strategy is intended to discourage smoking and encourage employees to adopt healthier lifestyles. Healthier employees are expected to take fewer sick days, keeping productivity high. Under this same viewpoint, the company could establish an in-house insurance program and even hire nurse counselors to educate employees on wellness and help them lead healthier lives. The advantages of this approach include a more productive workforce, stronger talent retention, and a more competitive position in the job market.
The primary disadvantage of this strategy is that the company will not achieve the same degree of cost reduction as it would by simply paying the penalty.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.