This paper examines the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), signed into law in March 2010, as a significant piece of legislation affecting the delivery of human services in the United States. It outlines the law's five main aims, including near-universal health insurance coverage and improved care quality, while discussing its rationale and effects on healthcare providers and human service organizations. The paper also presents arguments both for and against the ACA, addresses the political controversy surrounding its passage, and reviews potential legal ramifications for non-compliance, including anti-discrimination protections under Section 1557.
The paper demonstrates effective use of policy analysis framing: it moves from defining the law and its intent, to examining its operational implications, to evaluating controversy and enforcement. This layered approach shows students how to treat legislation not just as a political event but as a system with practical and legal dimensions.
The paper is organized into six sections: an introduction explaining what the ACA is and its five main goals; a section on purpose and rationale focusing on insurance reform and preventative care; an operational section covering effects on healthcare providers; a balanced section on political arguments for and against; a section on non-compliance and civil rights enforcement; and a brief conclusion affirming the law's constitutional standing and lasting significance.
A current law that significantly impacts the delivery of human services is the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, signed into law by President Barack Obama in March 2010. The legislation — most commonly known as the Affordable Care Act but also referred to as "Obamacare" — substantially overhauled existing healthcare statutes and was aimed specifically at reducing the number of Americans without health insurance coverage.
There are multiple reliable sources from which to gather information about this major change in the way healthcare services are delivered in the United States. The law's implications are spelled out clearly by the federal resource at PubMed / National Library of Medicine (National Center for Biotechnology Information / National Library of Medicine / National Institutes of Health) (Rosenbaum, 2011).
The Act "establishes the basic legal protections" that until now had not been available to citizens — that is, the Act is a "near-universal guarantee of access to affordable health insurance coverage, from birth through retirement" (Rosenbaum). When the law is fully implemented, an estimated 94% of Americans will be covered by health insurance.
The five main aims of the Act include: a) achieving "near-universal coverage" for Americans through "shared responsibility among government, individuals, and employers"; b) improving the fairness, quality, and affordability of health insurance coverage; c) improving the value, quality, and efficiency of healthcare while reducing "wasteful spending"; d) providing preventative healthcare services; and e) making "strategic investments in the public's health" by expanding clinical preventative care and making community investments (Rosenbaum). The Act fundamentally represents an effort to "reframe the financial relationship between Americans and the healthcare system" in order to address the "crisis that has enveloped individuals, families, communities, the healthcare system and the national economy" (Rosenbaum).
One of the central rationales for the ACA is to bring a sense of fair play to the relationship between Americans and insurance companies by legally prohibiting harmful industry practices. The White House explains that when the law is fully in place, insurance companies will no longer have "unchecked power to cancel your policy, deny your child coverage due to a pre-existing condition, or charge women more than men" (White House). Another rationale is to make preventative care widely available; as of June 2012, more than 86 million Americans had enjoyed preventative care "free of charge," including mammograms for women and wellness visits for seniors (White House). Moreover, the law has helped 6.6 million young adults who, because of the legislation, can remain on their parents' healthcare insurance policies until age 26 (White House).
Additionally, insurance companies can no longer drop an individual's coverage simply because that person becomes ill. Insurers can no longer impose "a lifetime cap on the dollar amount of coverage" a person may receive, nor can they raise premiums with "no accountability" (White House). These provisions collectively represent the law's intent to protect ordinary Americans from the most damaging practices of the private insurance market.
The human service organizations most directly impacted by the Affordable Care Act are the doctors, nurses, and other healthcare professionals who provide services to insured patients. The White House explains that the ACA will cut red tape for physicians and other healthcare providers. It simplifies rules for eligibility and healthcare claims by establishing guidelines expected to save physicians "an estimated $14.8 billion." The use of electronic billing rather than paper transfers is also expected to save healthcare providers up to $3.6 billion (White House).
The Affordable Care Act has funded an "Innovation Center" that has introduced 17 initiatives involving more than 50,000 healthcare providers. Those initiatives are expected to reduce costs for doctors and will "touch the lives of Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries in all 50 states" (White House). Hospitals nationwide will also be paid based on the quality of care they deliver rather than solely on the "quantity of care provided" (White House). Furthermore, it will be easier for healthcare organizations to coordinate patient care through the "Accountable Care Organizations" established by the Act (White House).
Since the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that the Act is constitutional, it is the law of the land. Getting it passed through Congress was an enormous task for President Obama. During the informational period, when legislators held town hall meetings, those opposed to the Act were often loud, disruptive, and intentionally obstructive, making it difficult for citizens to learn what the law actually entailed. Nevertheless, the Affordable Care Act is now settled law and has had — and will continue to have — an enormous impact on the delivery of health services in America.
You’re 59% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.